Brian Topp's blog

Brian Topp's picture

Brian Topp is executive director of ACTRA Toronto. He serves as chair of the board of Creative Arts Savings and Credit Union, and is a member of the board of directors of ROI Fund, a labour-sponsored venture capital fund. He previously served as a senior vice-president at Credit Union Central of Canada, the national office of Canada's credit union system outside of Quebec. He served as deputy chief of staff to Saskatchewan premier Roy Romanow. He co-ordinated the federal NDP's campaign war room during the 1997 and 2004 federal elections, and served as that party's national campaign director during the 2006 and 2008 elections. This blog features original content as well as cross-posted from The Globe & Mail's Second Reading.

We finally have a real Official Opposition

| June 26, 2011

Canadians aren't used to parliamentary government, in large part because we aren't used to federal politics built around real differences between our major parties over real issues. Instead, we are used to two conservative parties squabbling over mutual (often accurate) accusations of corruption, and over symbolic issues -- most with little meaning to the daily lives of citizens.

Canadians have therefore long tuned out federal politics between elections. But that all changed on May 2nd.

We now have some real choices on offer in federal politics, and real debate over real issues. Like, for example, whether or not people have the right to withhold their labour if they don't like the pay they're being offered by their bosses.

The Conservative government is clear on where it stands. Faced with the situation at Canada Post (negotiations over pay and benefits broke down; the employer made a final offer which was not accepted; employees began to pressure the employer; and the employer then locked the employees out of work), the government has intervened with a bill that would order the employees, by law, to accept a worse deal than Canada Post proposed in its final offer.

Consider how that would play out in your own daily life. You're at work and renegotiating your salary. Your employer offers you, say, $50,000 a year. You don't accept this proposal -- you feel you're worth $52,000. So your employer kicks you out of the office and tells you you'll stay out until you accept $50,000. And then Stephen Harper steps in and threatens you with fines or jail if you don't agree to return to work for, say, $48,000 -- less than your boss offered you.

That's what's happening at Canada Post. Before May 2, there would have been relatively little debate on Mr. Harper's intervention, since the Conservatives found a like-minded partner in the former Liberal opposition.

But there's a new sheriff in town -- a new, more numerous and more determined New Democrat Official Opposition with some important tools available to it to shine on light on issues like this. A majority government is in place, and it can ultimately get what it wants. But a real opposition, fighting on a real issue, can make things go very slowly indeed -- so that Canadians can judge the issues, and see what Mr. Harper's government is doing in the bright light of day.

Advertising

In short, we finally have an Official Opposition capable of, and willing to, do its job.

In a panel discussion about this matter a couple of days ago, a Conservative friend suggested that the current debate in Parliament shows the New Democrats have some "growing up to do." In fact it is the Conservatives who have some growing up to do. They need to learn that having power is not a license to abuse it. And that the people of Canada elected 308 MPs, including a muscular Official Opposition that will work, within the rules of our democracy and long into the night, to shine a light on misjudgements and misgovernment.

This article was first published in the Globe and Mail.

Thank you for choosing rabble.ca as an independent media source. We're a reader-supported site -- visited by over 315,000 unique visitors during the election campaign! But we need money to grow. Support us as a paying member (click here) or in making a one-off donation (click here).

embedded_video

Comments

As near as I can tell, the NDP "real" Opposition has been and will continue to be silent on Palestinians, supportive of Israel (including Jack Layton's regular fawning visits to Israeli ambassador anytime anything vaguely progressive about Israel/Palestine is uttered) and all too happy to bomb Libya. 

Excellent discussion on the filibuster is happening right now on babble: http://rabble.ca/babble/canadian-politics/canada-post-filibuster#comment...

A sheriff can arrest someone violating a law, regulation, code, policy, guideline or policy, and lock them up and arrange to have them prosecuted and, if found guilty by a judge, penalized.

So the NDP is not a new "sheriff" because all they (and every past opposition party during majority governments) can do is delay government action -- they can't stop it.

Because of loopholes in the rules, and very weak enforcement agencies (like the Ethics Commissioner, Commissioner of Lobbying, and Integrity Commissioner), it is effectively legal to violate most of Canada's good government laws.

Until these loopholes are closed, and enforcement agencies strengthened, all opposition parties will be able to do is oppose, but not stop, bad government actions.

See how you can help close the loopholes and strengthen the agencies at:
http://www.dwatch.ca/CoffeeParty.html

Hope this helps,
Duff Conacher, Board member of Democracy Watch
http://www.goodgovernment.ca

One of the many aspects of the behaviour and attitudes of Harper and his cronies that causes me discomfort is the potential effect on young people in our country.  Their example is like a neon sign on the top of the Parliament buildings that reads "BULLIES WIN!".  It happened in the May 2 election and it is happening again with their response to the Post Office labour dispute.  In any organization, the tone for behaviour and attitude is set from the top and this applies to our country as much as it does to a workplace, classroom, or club.  It is dismaying to anticipate bully culture pervading our youth through government example.

Login or register to post comments