During the campaign leading up to the recent Alberta provincial election, the website of Lethbridge-West Wildrose Party candidate Kevin Kinahan had two sections outlining his perspective on the party’s health care policy -- one was linked to his home page with no comment on abortion, a second unlinked page included a statement suggesting abortion services should no longer be funded.
Both pages remained online last night.
Kinahan's official health policy page, which is linked to his home page, contains the following statement: "…I would like to see a system where funding follows the patient and where we can make better use of specialized clinics. Having publically (sic) funded, universal access to specialized clinics can only help in easing the burden on our overloaded system. We would always stay in control of the system."
Elsewhere on the same site, however, a nearly identical page reads as follows: "…I would like to see a system where funding follows the patient and where we can make better use of specialized clinics. Having publically (sic) funded, universal access to specialized clinics can only help in easing the burden on our overloaded system. We would always stay in control of the system. We can reduce some of the expenses in the system by de-funding unnecessary medical procedures, including abortions."
The second page, while not linked to the site's homepage, can easily be found with a Google search.
With the thought that either or both pages may not remain online forever, I have provided a link to a screen shot of Kinahan's "official" page here, and of the unlinked page containing the abortion reference here.
Throughout the campaign, the highly divisive issue of abortion was a potential time bomb waiting to go off for the Wildrose Party. It reared its head often enough that Wildrose Leader Danielle Smith issued a statement insisting her party "has absolutely no intentions of legislating on abortion, and that includes delisting."
The short press release also tried to sidestep the party's position on so-called citizen initiatives, which could be used to try to impose anti-abortion laws by referendum. "Citizen initiative is and has always been an important part of the Wildrose platform," Smith said then. "However, any initiative must first be vetted by a federally appointed judge to determine whether or not it is constitutional."
Media coverage at the time described Smith as dodging questions about her views on delisting, and Kinahan was criticized for failing to show up at a forum sponsored by a group representing gay, lesbian and transgendered citizens. At the time, Kinahan dismissed the criticism as ridiculous and explained his absence as "simply a scheduling conflict on that date."
It would be pointless to speculate on why Kinahan, a Coaldale resident who is principal of a Catholic high school in nearby Taber and a former negotiating sub-committee representative for the Alberta Teachers Association, has two different pages on health policy on his website.
The page with the "de-funding" reference may simply have been a draft that was not deleted. Whatever the reason, however, it indicates this particular candidate's position on the controversial issue.
The Wildrose Party's position on abortion and several similar issues was carefully phrased to send a reassuring message to the general public but to acknowledge the party's awareness of the issue to hard-core social conservatives who were among the party's strongest supporters. Repeatedly, the party's precisely worded policy statements left the door ajar to policy directions that would have been strongly opposed by most voters.
This is a strategy that has been used effectively for years by far-right politicians in the United States, and it should not surprise us that parties like the Wildrose in Alberta and the so-called Conservative Party of Prime Minister Stephen Harper have adopted many of the same techniques.
Notwithstanding Smith's carefully phrased denial and her statements that she personally supported choice on abortion, it is said here that Kinahan's unlinked statement on the policy of cutting public funds for abortion services reflected the true policy intentions of the Wildrose Party.
Certainly it is entirely consistent with Kinahan's sincere views expressed on his unlinked web page and Smith's market-fundamentalist desire, notwithstanding her stated support for choice on abortion, to take many medical services out of the public system and hand them to for-profit private operators.
On election night, Kinahan was defeated by Progressive Conservative candidate Greg Weadick and also outpolled by New Democrat Shannon Phillips.
This post also appears on David Climenhaga's blog, Alberta Diary.
Thank you for reading this story...
More people are reading rabble.ca than ever and unlike many news organizations, we have never put up a paywall – at rabble we’ve always believed in making our reporting and analysis free to all. But media isn’t free to produce. rabble’s total budget is likely less than what big corporate media spend on photocopying (we kid you not!) and we do not have any major foundation, sponsor or angel investor. Our only supporters are people and organizations -- like you. This is why we need your help.
If everyone who visits rabble and likes it chipped in a couple of dollars per month, our future would be much more secure and we could do much more: like the things our readers tell us they want to see more of: more staff reporters and more work to complete the upgrade of our website.
We’re asking if you could make a donation, right now, to set rabble on solid footing in 2017.