Time for change

Gary Shaul's picture

I've been a political "activist" since the 1970s. I've been involved in a wide range of issues inside and outside of my union focused on labour and human rights, First Nations, the environment and proportional voting. In 2010-11, I coordinated the Catch 22 Harper Conservatives campaign.

The youth vote and democratic reform

| January 31, 2011

Johannes Wheeldon writes an excellent piece in The Mark about engaging the youth vote and reinvigorating Canadian politics at the same time.

How Can Canada Entice Young Voters?

"While the potential of the youth vote is too often tinged with terms like "apathetic," "lazy," and "entitled," largely unexplored are the reasons why encouraging the youth vote matters. This is not a partisan political proposition -- either you believe in democracy or you don't..."

It's a sad state of affairs that Canada's antiquated and undemocratic voting system actually encourages political parties to discourage or even sometimes disenfranchise select voters as a tactic to win elections.

"Philosophically, it seems clear that there is a relationship between ignorance of Canadian history, lack of understanding about our system of governance, and the current era of declining voters. Voting is literally the least you can do to meet your responsibilities as a Canadian citizen. Yet, unless people feel their vote matters, they will not feel compelled to participate come election time."

Advertising

More than 50 per cent of the votes in the last federal election went toward electing no one. More than 50 per cent of voters think that it requires a majority of votes to win an election. No wonder so many people, not just youth, say "why bother" (and not "who cares")? In my own case, I always vote and have never voted for a successful candidate in a federal election. I'm 50-plus. That "why bother" apathy is magnified by a profound and often earned distrust for politicians, parties and government who will say just about anything to get elected. Ignorance clouds voters from identifying what's really ailing them often resulting in emotional responses to manipulative marketing (like Rob Ford's "stop the gravy train").

As Wheeldon points out, pointing the finger at young people is a convenient distraction from tackling the root causes which are, of course, the responsiblity of the grown ups. He goes on to provide a to-do list of important steps including reducing the voting age, increased education and participation, and making it easier to register to vote.

I'll add another. Isn't it about time Canada had an enumeration of all voters? The permanent voters list is out of date and disadvantages those who aren't on the list already, especially young voters, immigrants and tenants. Elections Canada should do at least one enumeration every ten years.

My favorite piece of advice Wheeldon gives to the political parties is worth repeating in its entirety.

"Stop shying away from the real democratic renewal needed in Canada. It is time to think carefully and seriously about the costs of our winner-takes-all voting system, which is failing to provide real representation, ensure stable governance, or inspire confidence that working together works. There are many variants of proportional representation and the old arguments about instability and pizza parliaments seem quaint today. It's coalitions or Conservatives, Canada -– and our current system is making a mockery of meaningful democratic representation."

Democratic renewal, starting by giving every Canadian an equal and effective vote through a proportional voting system, is the number one game changer in Canadian electoral politics today. Until that's firmly on the agenda, all the rest, with the exception of election financing, are good ideas but they are just shuffling the deck chairs around on a sinking ship. For the older ones among us, voting reform is a legacy we can bequeath to future generations.

Reprinted from Catch 22 Harper Conservatives

How Can Canada Entice Young Voters?

embedded_video

Comments

I too can say that I have never missed an election and soon to be 56 and like you never voted for a successful candidate federally or provincially for that matter. I am from Kelowna BC...need I say more? but I will continue to tilt at windmills because I refuse to give up and eventually will see proportional representation ....though I am less hopeful that I will be able to vote for a winning candidate... 

While voting system reform will very likely increase voter turnout, other measures that increase government accountability and representation also very likely will increase voter turnout by the 15-20% it has dropped in the past 15 years.

Enacting an honesty-in-politics law with high fines for misleading voters with false promises during elections, and with false statements in between elections (including slanderous statements in the House of Commons and provincial legislatures), would also increase voter turnout because the leading reason for low turnout among youth and the drop in turnout among adults (according to the only post-federal election survey, conducted by Elections Canada) is lack of accountability for dishonesty.

Strengthen ethics laws, especially to end the favour-trading between lobbyists and politicians, and increase open government laws, and voters will also feel better about voting for politicians because they will have to represent them and their interests more.

Also, free politicians by taking away the right of party leaders to decide who is the candidate in each riding, and allow party caucuses to choose committee members, and then voters will also be more assured that their politician is worth voting for because s/he will represent their interests not just follow the party line.

Finally, allow voters to vote "none of the above" and promote that option in pre-election advertising (it is allowed in Ontario by "refusing" your provincial ballot, but Elections Ontario has been completely negligent to date in refusing to mention it in any of the voter education and advertising materials it has produced).

Make all these changes to make politicians more honest, ethical, open, representative and accountable, and then if youth and adult voter turnout has still not increased make voting compulsory (but only if voters are given the option to vote for "none of the above").

Hold a coffee party and help push for these changes -- details at:
http://www.CoffeeParty.ca

Hope this helps,
Duff Conacher, Coordinator
Democracy Watch
http://www.goodgovernment.ca

Login or register to post comments