Murray Dobbin's blog

murray dobbin's picture

Murray Dobbin is a guest senior contributing editor for rabble.ca. Murray has been a journalist, broadcaster, author and social activist for 40 years. A board member with the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, he has written five studies for the centre including examinations of charter schools, and "Ten Tax Myths." Murray has been a columnist for the Financial Post and Winnipeg Free Press and contributes guest editorials to the Globe and Mail, the Toronto Star and other Canadian dailies. He writes a regular "State of the Nation" column for the on-line journal TheTyee.ca which is published simultaneously on rabble.ca. His blog is murraydobbin.ca.

A corrupt political elite

| March 19, 2010

It's difficult to avoid the conclusion that our entire political elite is ethically challenged. There are many examples but the one that persists in the public eye is the reaction of that elite to the torture scandal involving Canada's handing over of Afghan prisoners of war to the psychopaths who run the Afghan secret police.

It seems that while mid-level bureaucrats like Richard Colvin were able to see what was happening, senior levels of the Canadian government and military were either completely incompetent in examining the issues involved, or so bereft of any sense of moral duty that they simply didn't care -- and didn't get what all the fuss was about.

The military and the foreign affairs department under both the Liberals and the Harper Conservatives consistently ignored not only advice and expressions of alarm from their own people on the ground, but also the example set by their NATO allies, the British and the Dutch, who set up rigorous inspection regimes to deal with prisoners they turned over.

Did the politicians and the generals think the Geneva Convention was some kind of joke, not to be taken seriously? Did they think the Brits and the Dutch were simply soft-headed fools to be concerned about the treatment of so-called "terrorists" -- a convenient misnomer that frames people fighting foreign invaders as a threat to the world?

This went on for years -- up to and including last year when Canada promised to build a new prison for the prisoners of war, and help train people to run it. Nothing has come of that promise and it seems it was never made with the intention of following through.

Add to that the pathological lying of the current government and the cover up engaged in by the Liberals and you have to wonder if any of the people in these two corrupt political parties are fit to run anything beyond a corner grocery store (with apologies to those who do).

Lastly, we have yet another shameful chapter as demonstrated by the willingness of former Supreme Court of Canada justice Frank Iacobucci to serve as Stephen Harper's lap dog in delaying the issue even further. Virtually all experts in Parliamentary procedure agree that the Harper government's refusal to hand over un-censored documents -- demanded by a vote in the House of Commons -- is a classic case of contempt of parliament. There is no legitimate reason for refusing and Harper and his ministers could face serous consequences for doing so.

Advertising

That Frank Iacobucci knows this is a virtual certainty. If he didn't know if before he was asked to serve his master (virtually unbelievable) then it was his duty just as a citizen to find out. And as a former SCC judge he had a far greater duty, knowing that his status would make him almost immune from criticism from opposition politicians. And, of course, he had to know that this is precisely why Harper chose him, given that he has no expertise in determining what is or is not a threat to national security.

Yet he has allowed himself to be shamelessly used to thwart the will of Parliament. He knows that the argument regarding "national security" is a farce yet he is willing to play the game -- for what? Money? Surely his pension and the money he saved making hundreds of thousands a year ought to look after the man.

Apparently not. Perhaps that's the problem -- pay these people too much and they come down with a case of moral dyslexia and are incapable of making a decision that doesn't line their pockets regardless of the consequences for the country.

embedded_video

Comments

This of course is not the first time Iacobucci has run interference for Harper's crimes against humanity.

Just over three years ago he agreed to be a one-man commission of inquiry into the government's role in the foreign detention and torture of three Canadians: Abdullah Almalki, Ahmad El Maati, and Muayyed Nureddin. The terms of reference given to him, which he accepted, required him to take "all steps necessary to ensure that the inquiry is conducted in private" and provided for the right of the government to censor any portion of his report for reasons of "national security".

As a result, witnesses were interviewed in private and documents were examined in secret, and the three men in question were not allowed to be present at the hearings or challenge the "facts" presented by the government. The version of the final report released to the public was heavily censored by the government.

Login or register to post comments