I was watching CNBC and happened to see this panel about how the number of Americans killed by natural disasters has declined over time. It was also noted that, in early 2010, fewer people died in Chile's earthquake than in Haiti's earthquake.
The discussion quite reasonably outlined how improvements in emergency preparedness, building codes, and infrastructure help to protect people from natural disasters. But two minutes into the segment, anchor Michelle Caruso-Cabrera declared, "The lesson is that capitalism actually saves lives."
Really? Until then, it sounded like government regulation and public infrastructure save lives. It's also true that economic development saves lives, and capitalism is one potential route to economic development. But that does not mean that capitalism, in and of itself, saves lives.
Haiti is a capitalist economy. That has been ensured by plenty of "structural adjustment" from international financial institutions. Yet it remains woefully underdeveloped.
I also checked out the op-ed that inspired the panel. It notes that the average annual U.S. death toll from disasters was significantly lower in 1980-2009 than in 1940-1979, and would have been even lower except for Hurricane Katrina. However, Katrina was so deadly not due to a lack of capitalism on the Gulf Coast, but due to under-investment in critical public infrastructure.
The real story is that well-regulated economic development with investment in public infrastructure saves lives. Put that on a bumper sticker!
This article was first posted on The Progressive Economics Forum.
Thank you for choosing rabble.ca as an independent media source. We're a reader-supported site -- visited by over 315,000 unique visitors during the election campaign! But we need money to grow. Support us as a paying member (click here) or in making a one-off donation (click here).
Actually, wealth saves lives. People with money can take steps to surround themselves with security and comfort that will enable them to survive natural disasters. People who lack wealth are in far greater danger of death from natural disasters, unless they have the benefit of social structure, physical infrastructure, technology, collective management of resources, food security, strong public health systems, and active government preparedness.
This is why, when Hurricane Ike scoured the length of Cuba and hit Haiti and the United States in 2008, only four Cubans died, while at least 50 US residents and 73 Haitian residents were killed.
This "capitalism saves lives" nonsense is reminiscent of last year's "capitalism saved the Chilean miners" meme that the Wall Steet Journal was promoting. [more here]
Capitalism is actually responsible for billions of intentional, negligent, and preventable deaths around the world over the past 200 years.