babble-intro-img
babble is rabble.ca's discussion board but it's much more than that: it's an online community for folks who just won't shut up. It's a place to tell each other — and the world — what's up with our work and campaigns.

Is PETA directing "hate speech" towards fat people?

53 replies [Last post]

Comments

Timebandit
Offline
Joined: Sep 25 2001
Stargazer wrote:
I love it when meat eaters get all bloody uptight when you point out the obvious. It doesn't take a genious to know that meat causes more food poisoning than veggies. It is all about the risk factor. Nice try though. I know it helps to stay in a bubble world where food poisoning applies equally to both meat eaters and vegans/vegetarisn. Alas, it is not so. 
  I don't think I said that... But hey, thanks for the heaping helping of self-righteous scorn. It makes you ever so much more credible.   What I asked was: What evidence do you have that the majority of meat eaters have had food poisoning at least once in their lives. You haven't given me a lot to chew on, here. I did point out that food poisoning can be contracted through vegetables as well, guilty as charged. But it has been known to happen. (In fact, it's supported by your Alive magazine link - although the source is questionable, IMO. Homeopathy? Oy vey.)    
Stargazer wrote:
   http://www.canada.com/topics/news/national/story.html?id=ee66451e-aa59-4bf1-90d7-7ecd7985f582&k=33656 "The Council for Agricultural Science and Technology, a private nonprofit organization, estimated that in one year as many as 9,000 deaths and 6.5 to 33 million illnesses in the US and Canada are food-related. And these are only the serious cases; it's safe to say that the majority of the less serious food contamination cases are not reported and are passed off by the victims as a stomach flu." http://www.alive.com/3740a1a2.php?subject_bread_cramb=389 http://www.healthlinkalberta.ca/Topic.asp?GUID={B099F484-BA5F-444F-B7A5-ECBB0602BABB} http://www.canadianfoodsafetytraining.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=129  
  First of all, most of your links confirm my assertion that you can get food poisoning from any type of food, including fresh fruits and vegetables.   There's emphasis, when we get into meat, that the cause of food poisoning is either a lack of refrigeration for storage and/or improperly or poorly cooked food. Also cross-contamination from unclean prep surfaces, that sort of thing. It's not the simple fact that meat is being eaten that causes food poisoning. I also note that a good chunk of the discussion in all but one link talk a lot about contamination of fruit and veg. Nuts are mentioned, too. I have a friend who got wicked sick on pine nuts that had been stored in the cupboard. I keep mine in the freezer nowadays.    
Stargazer wrote:
  As far as colon cleansing, well, here are a few nice sites for some information. If you're not too worried about the meat you eat and what it does to your body then hey, no need to bother. But there are many people who DO worry, and they bother all the time and what comes out is not exactly appetizing. I'm unsure about the whole process myself...
  I AM sure about the whole process. It's complete and utter bunk that anybody, regardless of what they eat, needs to have a hose stuck up their butt to clean it out.   Did you actually read the link I posted? There are risks to colon cleansing and it's unnecessary. The colon sheds the lining of cells and mucous, there's nothing for feces to stick to. It all gets expelled. I know there are people who buy the woo and that it plays on their worries, but it's just woo.   Do I worry about the meat I eat? Well, to some degree, but not in the way you're suggesting. I take care in what I buy, where it comes from - I buy in bulk from local farmers that I can acutally get to know, and from a neighborhood butcher shop that is very meticulous about the products they sell. I take care to store it properly, use a clean board/prep area and cook it sufficiently. All the same care that I take with vegetables, in fact. As for what it does to my body, healthwise, eating a small to moderate amount of meat seems to keep me on an even keel with energy, where as a (careful) vegan, I was always tired and found that my endurance with running (was training for a 10k race at the time) was much lower than when I was lacto-ovo vegetarian or ate omnivorously. At the present time, I am in excellent health. I don't have any of the health-scares that PETA uses to convince people not to eat meat. It's all about the balance.  
Stargazer wrote:
 Me? I like to make sure the food I eat doesn't make me sick. I have not had food poisoning Once since I have become a vegetarian. I used to get it at least once a few weeks when I ate meat.  
I'm sorry you got sick that often. I think that's most unusual. I like to make sure my food doesn't make me or my family sick, too. As I've pointed out, I've never had food poisoning. Nor have my kids. My husband has had it once from eating bad burgers in a divy restaurant. I don't think we're all that unusual - but I'm open to evidence, if you have any. You just have to have some common sense.

Timebandit
Offline
Joined: Sep 25 2001

al-Qa'bong wrote:

What is it about PETA that makes so many people here go crazy?

 

They're trying to draw attention to their cause, and aren't worried about alienating or offending anyone to do so.  I find their approach rather refreshing.

 

It's the absolutism, for me.  It really bugs me. 

The problem with the way they draw attention to the cause is that it alienates more people than it draws in. 


Stargazer
Offline
Joined: Jun 9 2004

Gripes, I posted two posts in the wrong thread....

 

Timebandit, I know that both meat eaters and non-meat eaters can get food poisoning. I never said we couldn't, what I said is in the links - the more meat you eat the more likely you'll get food poisning, which is well documented and given the way food is processed and handled these days, I'd say a lot more people are coming down with food poisoning. There is article after article on the web about the amount of people who think they have the flu but in fact, have food poisoning - the symptoms are the close enough that food poisoning is often misdiagnosed as the flu. 

 

As for colon cleansing - I've never done it and I doubt I will but I have friends who do it on a regular basis and personally, I'll take their experience about it over someone who is so quick to dismiss it.

 

 


Sineed
Offline
Joined: Dec 4 2005

Stargazer wrote:

 There is article after article on the web about the amount of people who think they have the flu but in fact, have food poisoning - the symptoms are the close enough that food poisoning is often misdiagnosed as the flu. 

Even though it's on the web, this is actually true.  I became a vegetarian for 2 years after getting food poisoning from undercooked chicken at a folk festival.  And yes; when people say they have, "stomach flu," it could be a bug like Norwalk, but often it's food poisoning.


Timebandit
Offline
Joined: Sep 25 2001

Stargazer wrote:

 

As for colon cleansing - I've never done it and I doubt I will but I have friends who do it on a regular basis and personally, I'll take their experience about it over someone who is so quick to dismiss it.

 

 

I'm not suggesting you take my word for it - I've provided a link that takes its sources from professionals who know much more about the workings of the human colon than I do.  However, I'm sure that your friends' anecdotes are far more powerful than, say, doctors. 

I'm not sure, either, that you can claim I'm quick to dismiss it, either.  I heard about it, did reading on both sides and came to a rational conclusion some time ago.  The evidence, not just my opinions, don't add up to colon cleansing being anything more than a scam.  Just because you know people who have bought into it doesn't make it legit.


al-Qa'bong
Offline
Joined: Feb 27 2003

Michelle wrote:

Normally I'd agree with you, al-Q, but this one doesn't even make sense.  What does this say to fat vegans who have already embraced their cause?  You don't lose weight by going vegetarian. 

 

I hear ya.  Beer is vegetarian, azfarazino.  Twenty years ago I had six-pack abs.  Now I have a keg.


Stargazer
Offline
Joined: Jun 9 2004

Hahahaha @Al Q


KeyStone
Offline
Joined: Apr 23 2008

The logic that asserts because there are overweight vegans, and healthy meat-eaters might also so suggest that because there are healthy smokers, and unhealthy non-smokers, that we can't know for sure that smoking is bad for you. Obviously, there is a correlation between eating meat (especially a lot of it), and weight gain.

 

 


RosaL
Offline
Joined: Mar 4 2007

Timebandit wrote:

al-Qa'bong wrote:

What is it about PETA that makes so many people here go crazy?

It's the absolutism, for me.  It really bugs me. 

 

It's not as if there's any other absolutism around here Wink I don't think anybody is bothered by absolutism. What bothers people is absolutism they don't share.


Sven
Offline
Joined: Jul 22 2005

RosaL wrote:
 

It's not as if there's any other absolutism around here Wink I don't think anybody is bothered by absolutism. What bothers people is absolutism they don't share.

That is absolutely correct!!


Snert
Offline
Joined: Nov 4 2008

Quote:
Obviously, there is a correlation between eating meat (especially a lot of it), and weight gain.

 

I think there's a correlation between eating a lot of just about anything, and weight gain.


RosaL
Offline
Joined: Mar 4 2007

Snert wrote:

Quote:
Obviously, there is a correlation between eating meat (especially a lot of it), and weight gain.

 

I think there's a correlation between eating a lot of just about anything, and weight gain.

 

Nonetheless, a lot of bacon or donuts is a lot more fattening than a lot of cucumbers or green beans. And I don't think styrofoam peanuts would make you fat at all. 


Weltschmerz
Offline
Joined: Feb 7 2003

RosaL wrote:

Snert wrote:

Quote:
Obviously, there is a correlation between eating meat (especially a lot of it), and weight gain.

 

I think there's a correlation between eating a lot of just about anything, and weight gain.

 

Nonetheless, a lot of bacon or donuts is a lot more fattening than a lot of cucumbers or green beans. And I don't think styrofoam peanuts would make you fat at all. 

Donuts are a meat?  Well that changes my diet planning.


RosaL
Offline
Joined: Mar 4 2007

Weltschmerz wrote:

Donuts are a meat?  Well that changes my diet planning.

Let me go over this for you again: Snert said that a lot of anything would make you fat. I said it wasn't as simple as all that. I did not say that donuts were meat. I said that, although in general (there are exceptions) a lot of anything will make you fat, some things will make you fatter than other things will. 

You can now apply this to the "meat eating" question if you like. It still doesn't imply that donuts are meat. 


Weltschmerz
Offline
Joined: Feb 7 2003

Sorry.  Should I have inlcuded a smiley there?

It was willful misinterpretation designed to bring a little levity.  I do that.


RosaL
Offline
Joined: Mar 4 2007

Weltschmerz wrote:

Sorry.  Should I have inlcuded a smiley there?

Yes Smile 


Weltschmerz
Offline
Joined: Feb 7 2003

Not a problem.  I do try to communicate tone through my choice of words, but I realize that printed text is not the best place to do that.

Back to the topic, sort of: recently introduced edamame to my diet; great snack, not too high in calories, and loads 'o' protein to keep you from getting hungry for those meat-donuts Wink


RosaL
Offline
Joined: Mar 4 2007

Weltschmerz wrote:

 meat-donuts Wink

 

heh. Ever had those sausage-roll things? I think some of those come pretty close... 


Michelle
Offline
Joined: May 10 2001

You could have beer donuts with your meat donuts.

[homer] Mmmmmm! [/homer]


Weltschmerz
Offline
Joined: Feb 7 2003

RosaL wrote:
 

heh. Ever had those sausage-roll things? I think some of those come pretty close... 

Oh yeah.  Processed meat in processed pastry.  Metabolize the sugar and the fat, both at the same time!  Save yourself some time.  We do really excel at combining the worst elements of food: it's not just fat, not just chemicals, not just processed, not just starch (cooked in fat), and not just sugar (also with chemicals)!  It's all of them!

Why do I feel like saying "DAYENU"?


Timebandit
Offline
Joined: Sep 25 2001

I've had Chinese bun-like thingies that are a lot like meat donuts.  They're awesome! 

I also think the comparison of meat consumption to smoking is really stretching it.  Overconsumption of meat will cause health problems, especially fatty meats that are fried.  However, moderate consumption of meat that is leaner and well-prepared is no threat to your health.  A little fat is actually good for you.


Snert
Offline
Joined: Nov 4 2008

Everybody's seen that cheeseburger that's served up on a Krispy Kreme donut in place of a bun, yes?

 

Quote:
A little fat is actually good for you.

 

Exactly. Some vitamins are only metabolically available in fat or oil. Mind you, that oil could be olive oil instead of the sweet, unctious, delicious fat on a piece of pork belly, but why deny yourself?


Timebandit
Offline
Joined: Sep 25 2001

In moderation, bacon fat won't kill you.  Now, if you eat nothing but bacon fat, well, all bets are off.

Balance!


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Login or register to post comments