babble-intro-img
babble is rabble.ca's discussion board but it's much more than that: it's an online community for folks who just won't shut up. It's a place to tell each other — and the world — what's up with our work and campaigns.

Uranium mining proposal sparks protest in Sept-Îles

50 replies [Last post]

Comments

autoworker
Offline
Joined: Dec 21 2008

More on the uranium industry in Canada:

Atomic Accomplice: How Canada Deals in Deadly Deceit by environmental journalist Paul McKay (availible online at paulmckay.com). 


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Review of the McKay book in the G&M here.

 

excerpt:

 

It is a damning and alarming indictment - and thoroughly bipartisan, too. Written from years of accumulated research, Mr. McKay spares neither the left nor the right. The CCF's Tommy Douglas, the socialist premier from uranium-rich Saskatchewan, lobbied hard in the 1950s for federal subsidies to bankroll uranium mines. More recently, the NDP's Lorne Calvert, as Saskatchewan premier, championed the sale of uranium to China - only one in the list of dictatorships courted by Canada as prospective clients for this country's government-sustained nuclear industry.

 

Beyond doubt, this industry has survived solely through overt and covert government manipulation of the marketplace; in the case of Liberal prime minister Pierre Trudeau, for example, through a shameful price-fixing conspiracy that inflated the price of uranium more than fivefold. Federal subsidies to the industry - so far - exceed $30-billion. Prime Minister Stephen Harper has trebled support for the industry, committing a further $1.7-billion in the past three years.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

January 6, 2010: Sept-Îles residents oppose uranium exploration

 

excerpt:

 

The Quebec government has a duty to put a stop to plans for uranium exploration in the Sept-Îles region because of the overwhelming opposition of residents, the city's mayor, Serge Lévesque, said Tuesday.

Lévesque was reacting to the release of a poll ordered by municipal officials last month after two dozen local doctors threatened to resign if B.C.-based Terra Ventures Inc. goes ahead with planned drilling in the area.

 

excerpt:

 

Quebec's Junior Natural Resources Minister Serge Simard has said no uranium mining project in the region would be approved without local support.

Lévesque said he hopes Simard will stand by his word.

"I think he has the power to stop the project right now," Lévesque said.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

A bit off-topic: Residents fear prospect race for lithium

 

 

excerpt:

 

Hart said most property owners are surprised to learn that prospectors have a legal right to go on their land. He said the mining act allows mineral exploration companies to expropriate private land where there are significant mineral finds.


E.P.Houle
Offline
Joined: Feb 2 2009

 

Uranium is one of the most soluable metals and the most toxic. Congratulations to your Doctors! I wish we had this out west. This thread, re, nukes should be it's own large catagory in Babble.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

E.P.Houle wrote:
Uranium is one of the most soluable metals and the most toxic. Congratulations to your Doctors! I wish we had this out west. This thread, re, nukes should be it's own large catagory in Babble.

Thanks for the compliment. A lot of good links in the Facebook group I referenced in post #5 (now at 6,159 members) . It's a great source if you're bilingual - I'm not fully bilingual, but I can usually get the gist of most articles in French.


G. Muffin
Offline
Joined: Sep 28 2008

Boom Boom wrote:

A bit off-topic: Residents fear prospect race for lithium

 

 

excerpt:

 

Hart said most property owners are surprised to learn that prospectors have a legal right to go on their land. He said the mining act allows mineral exploration companies to expropriate private land where there are significant mineral finds.

Seriously?  For batteries or for mood disorders?  That's quite some element.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

G. Muffin wrote:

Boom Boom wrote:

A bit off-topic: Residents fear prospect race for lithium

 

 

excerpt:

 

Hart said most property owners are surprised to learn that prospectors have a legal right to go on their land. He said the mining act allows mineral exploration companies to expropriate private land where there are significant mineral finds.

Seriously?  For batteries or for mood disorders?  That's quite some element.

 

Uranium as well.

 

And, from the same article:

 

When Lemay is asked whether there will be a mine near Meech Lake in Gatineau Park, he chuckles and says there could be a mine if there is a significant find on private property.

The National Capital Commission said in 2006 that mineral exploration and mining are not allowed within the park because of a 1973 agreement between the NCC and the Quebec government.

Jean-Paul Murray, a Gatineau Park activist, said there is nothing the National Capital Commission could do to stop mining in the park because the Quebec government does not recognize the agreement not to issue mining permits on park land.


G. Muffin
Offline
Joined: Sep 28 2008

Geez, I feel kind of ashamed.  I come from a long line of miners on my mother's side.  Cominco in Trail, Thailand, elsewhere.  That was decades ago, though.


G. Muffin
Offline
Joined: Sep 28 2008
Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Almost missed this: Expanding uranium exploration sparks concern, protests in Quebec

 

excerpt:

 

"There's a whole debate that needs to happen," says Loraine Richard, the Parti Quebecois Member of the National Assembly [MNA] for Sept-Iles. "When there are almost 20 doctors who want to leave my region, I stand up and take notice." On February 17, Richard presented a citizens' petition to the National Assembly calling for a province-wide moratorium on uranium exploration, a concept supported by MNAs from the Parti Québécois and Québec Solidaire, but rejected by the majority Liberals.

 

Many activists now see the Sept-Iles experience as a template for successful organizing because it has mobilized citizens and politicians and made prospecting a public issue in a way it has never previously been in Quebec.

 

Nevertheless, the ultimate outcome for the Lake Kachiwiss site remains uncertain. For the moment, the provincial Liberals' strategy seems to be to deal with Sept-Iles as an isolated case that can be dealt with without addressing any broader issues of mining policy.

 

However, speaking in the National Assembly on December 4, Serge Simard, the Liberal minister responsible for mining, promised that a uranium mine at Lake Kachiwiss would not go forward without local endorsement. Also, in recent weeks Terra Ventures has suspended its prospecting in what looks to be a gentleman's agreement with the government.

 

But as Sept-Iles' MNA Richard points out: "If they [Terra Ventures] wanted to dig tomorrow morning, legally speaking, they could do it."

 

And as long as the policy of free-entry mining remains unchallenged, it is difficult to see how either municipal legislators or MNAs like Simard can make promises to their constituents with any degree of conviction.

 

excerpt:

 

Since 2005, a plethora of companies have obtained permits from the Quebec government to drill in approximately 20 locations, and have extracted up to 250 core samples per site along an axis extending 800km from Tadoussac through Sept-Iles to the eastern terminus of Highway 138 at Natashquan.

Natashquan is 44 km from where I live.Surprised


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

another excerpt from that same article:

 

According to Sept-Iles residents, the prospecting site is not fenced in, the drill holes, as of June last year, were uncapped, and the company has neglected to post signs to warn the population about potential radioactivity. The core samples are stored on open-air racks, exposed to the elements.

 

Marc Fafard, a logger and local activist, describes the result of leaving such unusual objects unattended, and essentially unmarked, in a frequented area.

"You've got these lovely core samples, soft, beautiful as fossils, nice to touch," he explains. Samples "were showing up in people's living rooms".Surprised


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

I'm still stunned by the idea that folks have picked up possible uranium core samples to decorate their living rooms. Can someone knowledgeable about this explain to me if there are immediate and/or long-term dangers from touching a genuine uranium core sample?


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Anti-uranium doctors renew threat to resign

 

excerpt:

 

Nearly two-dozen doctors in Sept-Îles, Que., are renewing their threats to resign and leave the province after the government rejected calls for a moratorium on uranium mining and exploration in the region.


George Victor
Offline
Joined: Oct 28 2007

Boom Boom wrote:

I'm still stunned by the idea that folks have picked up possible uranium core samples to decorate their living rooms. Can someone knowledgeable about this explain to me if there are immediate and/or long-term dangers from touching a genuine uranium core sample?

The only danger would be from the dust of a crushed/broken specimen entering the lungs. 

But are you folks petitioning Quebec city? 


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

George Victor wrote:
But are you folks petitioning Quebec city? 

I think the Facebook page has several references to our provincial representative bringing this up in the National Assembly, there has been a petition, and a large demonstration, and many newspaper articles. Quebec is aware of the situation.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004
This is from New Brunswick, not Quebec, but still interesting: Uranium industry hit by price drop, regulation and attitude http://telegraphjournal.canadaeast.com/search/article/1024040

Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004
Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004
Jonathan Genest-Jourdain: Demain en chambre (13:30-14:00), intervention portant sur l'exploration uranifère et le groupement Minganie sans uranium !!

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Login or register to post comments