babble is rabble.ca's discussion board but it's much more than that: it's an online community for folks who just won't shut up. It's a place to tell each other — and the world — what's up with our work and campaigns.
I don't see much evidence that the PC vote is collapsing outside maybe the 416 area and maybe slipping some in the 905 and Ottawa region. In the north, southwestern and eastern Ontario that doesn't seem to be happening. This dynamic may mean some big surprises in ridings no one thought were in play.
Ontario is a collection of regions. Any polling that doesn't recognize that isn't worth squat. In the current strength/weakness in regions for all the parties situation, the seat count could be rather unpredictable.
Which polls lack regional breakdowns. Pretty much every one I've seen has had regional breakdowns and two have riding breakdowns.
But people are not looking at regional numbers. And the polls are all over the frikkin place on those regionals. It will be the regions of Ontario and how they sweep that will determine the numbers. In other words this election is unpredictable.
And as I said in the previous thread, I just don't buy that the Liberals are riding high. That doesn't square with my experience in this part of the world.
The polls seem pretty consistent to me. And the most exciting thing is the return of the NDP not just in Hamilton and Oshawa but generally in the 905. Although Bramalea-Gore-Malton is the only seat this will likely move, I've been really impressed by the consistency amongst the various regional numbers that put the party in serious contention in the Southwest, North and 416.
But people are not looking at regional numbers. And the polls are all over the frikkin place on those regionals. It will be the regions of Ontario and how they sweep that will determine the numbers. In other words this election is unpredictable.
There appear to be regional numbers in some of the polls. I'm looking at the Ipsos-Reid one right now. It has the following breakdowns:
416
LIB 47%
NDP 29%
PC 23% (Will they be shut out here?)
905
LIB 42%
PC 32%
NDP 21%
Central
LIB 36%
PC 35%
NDP 24%
Eastern
LIB 50%
PC 35%
NDP 13%
Southwestern
LIB 36%
NDP 34%
PC 28% (Embarrassing if they finish this low?)
Northern
NDP 40%
LIB 28%
PC 28%
Looks like Northern Ontario is the Liberals' weakest region. If Dalton McGuinty had focused on it more, perhaps he would have been in even better shape. An error in judgement on his part?
They are showing a both a three-day tracking poll (Lib 37.7%, PC 33.2%, NDP 25.8%, Green 2.1%, Others 1.3%) and a two-day tracking poll ((Lib 40.1%, PC 33.0%, NDP 23.2%, Green 2.8%, Others 0.9%). Using their sample sizes, you can calculate what the one-day poll (n=280) result was for Saturday, October 1st:
PC 33.6%
Lib 32.9%
NDP 30.7%
Green 0.7%
Others 2.1%
Imagine the reaction if that poll had made the front page of the Sunday papers!
There is now a final Angus Reid poll of 2,000 just out in the Star. It is very contrary to every other poll and has thenPCs ahead with 36%, followed by the Libs at 33 Nad NDP at 26%
To me the most compelling poll result was Ekos' question about whether the government was going in the right direction. 56% said it was. People are supporting McGuinty because, whether they like him personally or not (and I think unlike Hudak he's more likable than unlikable), they like what he's done. He's run a progressive, activist government: Green Energy Act, Poverty Reduction Strategy, full day kindergarten. There's a lot to like there. That squares with what I hear in my circle: people give him begrudging praise, peppered with "oh, but he's Liberal."
I believe that is called cherry picking as other polls are showing different things, particularly depending on your area. And don't get me started that the Green Energy Act being anything but a greenwash of a massive privatization shift of our electricity generation capacity. It is anything but progressive.
My guess is that we don't know the outcome and neither do the pollsters. Local races are likely to loom much larger than in previous elections. At this point I still think it is possible that any of the three could form government, in orders of liklihood of course. But almost for sure we will be back at it sometime in 2013
And don't get me started that the Green Energy Act being anything but a greenwash of a massive privatization shift of our electricity generation capacity. It is anything but progressive.
Sorry, that just doesn't square with what everyone I know in the environmental movement has said. And I know a lot. McGunity's viewed as a leader in this area.
At any rate, one piece of good news is that all polls seem to agree Hudak will be shut out of Toronto. It's really hard to govern without a single seat in the biggest city in the province.
At any rate, one piece of good news is that all polls seem to agree Hudak will be shut out of Toronto. It's really hard to govern without a single seat in the biggest city in the province.
I think the right realized he was toast weeks ago. I suspect their internal polling looks bad. The Stun not endorsing him, articles in the Toast and Stun talking about his lacklustre campaign, coverage of how even Bill Davis couldnt really come up with anything nice to say about him, Harper getting Flaherty to endorse him rather than doing it himself...
The homophobic and chain gang garbage seems designed just to get his bedrock fundamentalist (of all faiths) creep vote motivated so he doesnt get wiped out.
But, the tories are the masters of getting old white folks rides to the polls so who knows.
Now the push is on by the righgtiwng press to get Tories to "vote strategically" for the Liberals because they don't want the NDP to have any influence on the Liberals. They know that with a majority McGuinty will swing way to the right and that's what they want. God forbid that a minority government might make McGuinty keep his promises!
The Manitoba NDP have shown that voters are not in any big swing cycle. Horwarth will make some gains but no major breakthrough because Canadians seem to want stability in this uncertain world. The Alberta Conservatives will likely win for the same reason when they go to the polls next year.
There is now a final Angus Reid poll of 2,000 just out in the Star. It is very contrary to every other poll and has thenPCs ahead with 36%, followed by the Libs at 33 Nad NDP at 26%
Angus Reid-Toronto Star last poll:
PC: 36%
Liberal: 33%
NDP: 26%
Green: 5%
The tightest Ontario election in a generation will come down to the wire with the Progressive Conservatives facing a shutout in the city of Toronto, a new Toronto Star-Angus Reid survey suggests.
In the final major poll before Thursday's vote, the Tories are at 36 per cent, the Liberals at 33 per cent, the New Democrats at 26 per cent and the Greens at 5 per cent.
"It's a statistical dead heat," Jaideep Mukerji, managing director at Angus Reid, said Tuesday.
That means victory will go to the party that can best mobilize its voters, but the Tories may not win one of Toronto's 23 ridings, so must secure 54 of Ontario's remaining 84 seats for a majority in the 107-member Legislature.
"In the last two weeks despite the (televised leaders') debate and all the different controversies, our polling is showing that the race really hasn't changed all that much," said Mukerji.
In last Saturday's poll, Tim Hudak's Tories were at 34 per cent, Dalton McGuinty's Liberals at 33 per cent, Andrea Horwath's New Democrats at 26 per cent, and Mike Schreiner's Greens at 6 per cent.
And on Sept. 17, the numbers were virtually identical: PC 36, Liberal 32, NDP 26 and Greens 6.
"The first part of the campaign is about persuasion and the last part really just turns out to be about getting your voters out. We have a pretty good sense of where the camps are. It's just how effective are they going to be in getting out their vote on Election Day," he said.
"There does seem to be a higher motivation among Tory voters to get out there and vote on Thursday. They realize there's a lot at stake for them."
Indeed, 77 per cent of Conservative-leaning respondents said they "will definitely" vote PC compared with 71 per cent of Liberal-inclined voters sticking with the Grits, 65 per cent of New Democrat supporters casting NDP ballots and 45 per cent of Greens remaining with their party.
"They really don't like Dalton McGuinty and unlike some of the other parties, they don't really see some other alternative for them," the pollster said.
Another factor encouraging Tories to cast ballots could also be increasing buzz about a minority Liberal government propped up by the NDP. Ontarians have not had a hung Parliament since the 1985 election.
"The Tory turnout looks higher than it did a few days ago and I think it might be because they realize this election might be in jeopardy for them," he said.
Demographics may slightly favour the Tories as well - 41 per cent of respondents 55 and older plan to vote PC compared to 36 per cent for the Liberals, 20 per cent for the New Democrats and 2 per cent for the Greens.
"Historically, people that turn out to vote tend to be older Canadians and that's an area where the Tories have an edge over the Liberals," noted Mukerji. Weather across the province is forecast to by sunny with temperatures in the high teens.
The online survey of 2,223 people was conducted between Sunday and Tuesday and is considered accurate to within 2.1 percentage points, 19 times out of 20.
But there are ominous signs for the Conservatives, including the party's apparent failure to gain traction in Toronto, where they have not won a provincial riding since 1999.
They are mired in third place at 24 per cent in the city. The Liberals, who hold 19 of Toronto's 23 seats, are at 46 per cent. The New Democrats, who have four city seats, are at 27 per cent and the Greens are at 2 per cent.
"There's something to be said for vote efficiency. The Liberals are doing very well in the 416 area," noted Mukerji.
"Even though (the Tories) are at 36 per cent (overall), there's some pretty vote-rich areas, particularly in the 416, where they don't really seem to have made the inroads that they wanted to," he said.
In the 905 region, the Tories are ahead with 41 per cent to 29 per cent for the Liberals, 24 per cent for the NDP and 6 per cent for the Greens.
That suggests both the Conservatives and New Democrats could win GTA seats currently held by the Liberals.
In terms of gender - 40 per cent of men support the Conservatives compared to 31 per cent of women. In contrast, 33 per cent of men and 34 per cent of women back the Liberals. The NDP has 22 per cent of men and 30 per cent of women and the Greens have 4 per cent male and 5 per cent female.
Despite polls indicating his two terms of majority government are at risk, McGuinty still sounds confident, emphasizing he plans to "drive as hard as we can" in the final hours of the campaign.
"I'm after as many seats, as much support, as many MPPs as we can have in order to form a strong, stable Liberal government," he said in the Tory-held riding of Dufferin-Caledon.
Hudak also strived to remain upbeat, but his nervousness about the Liberals pulling off a win was obvious Tuesday as he raised time and again the spectre of a Grit-NDP coalition.
"Ontario families are getting behind the PCs because we're the only party that can actually bring change to Ontario," he said in Ottawa.
But in Toronto Horwath insisted she is "running to be in the top chair" - not to be kingmaker.
"You guys talk about that M-word, 'minority' but I talk about the M-word as 'momentum' and we still have it."
I heard the opposite. Tories being told to vote NDP in swing ridings to get their cherished tax reductions.
I guess you missed all the hysterical articles and editorials in the national Post and the Globe and the Sun begging Ontarians not to give the NDP the balance of power since they might actually pressure the government to do something progressive. the pro-business press wants AUSTERITY and cutbacks. With a Liberal majority - they MIGHT get that. With the NDP having the balance of power - it will nix that whole agenda. the stakes are very high for Bay St - they cannot let the NDP have any influence.
The most recent poll from Nanos poll which came out yesterday, is showing the Ontario Libs dropping from 42% to 34%, or down 8% from the last election while the NDP has gone from 17% in the last election to 30% now, for an increase of 13%. This means that the NDP has effectively gained 21% on the Libs since the last Ontario election. If this momentum continues, and there is nothing to suggest it won't, the NDP could be overtaking the Libs by tomorrow nite.
The most recent poll from Nanos poll which came out yesterday, is showing the Ontario Libs dropping from 42% to 34%, or down 8% from the last election while the NDP has gone from 17% in the last election to 30% now, for an increase of 13%. This means that the NDP has effectively gained 21% on the Libs since the last Ontario election. If this momentum continues, and there is nothing to suggest it won't, the NDP could be overtaking the Libs by tomorrow nite.
I don't see much evidence that the PC vote is collapsing outside maybe the 416 area and maybe slipping some in the 905 and Ottawa region. In the north, southwestern and eastern Ontario that doesn't seem to be happening. This dynamic may mean some big surprises in ridings no one thought were in play.
If you run the latest Ipsos & Ekos polls through the Hill & Knowlton, they both come up with Lib-62, PC-24, NDP-21
Which polls lack regional breakdowns. Pretty much every one I've seen has had regional breakdowns and two have riding breakdowns.
But people are not looking at regional numbers. And the polls are all over the frikkin place on those regionals. It will be the regions of Ontario and how they sweep that will determine the numbers. In other words this election is unpredictable.
And as I said in the previous thread, I just don't buy that the Liberals are riding high. That doesn't square with my experience in this part of the world.
The polls seem pretty consistent to me. And the most exciting thing is the return of the NDP not just in Hamilton and Oshawa but generally in the 905. Although Bramalea-Gore-Malton is the only seat this will likely move, I've been really impressed by the consistency amongst the various regional numbers that put the party in serious contention in the Southwest, North and 416.
Isn't Hill & Knowlton somewhat unreliable? I don't see the Libs going above 60 seats.
So, when do the polls close, exactly?
There appear to be regional numbers in some of the polls. I'm looking at the Ipsos-Reid one right now. It has the following breakdowns:
416
LIB 47%
NDP 29%
PC 23% (Will they be shut out here?)
905
LIB 42%
PC 32%
NDP 21%
Central
LIB 36%
PC 35%
NDP 24%
Eastern
LIB 50%
PC 35%
NDP 13%
Southwestern
LIB 36%
NDP 34%
PC 28% (Embarrassing if they finish this low?)
Northern
NDP 40%
LIB 28%
PC 28%
Looks like Northern Ontario is the Liberals' weakest region. If Dalton McGuinty had focused on it more, perhaps he would have been in even better shape. An error in judgement on his part?
9:00 pm Thursday night.
Nanos has released their last poll of the Ontario election.
They are showing a both a three-day tracking poll (Lib 37.7%, PC 33.2%, NDP 25.8%, Green 2.1%, Others 1.3%) and a two-day tracking poll ((Lib 40.1%, PC 33.0%, NDP 23.2%, Green 2.8%, Others 0.9%). Using their sample sizes, you can calculate what the one-day poll (n=280) result was for Saturday, October 1st:
PC 33.6%
Lib 32.9%
NDP 30.7%
Green 0.7%
Others 2.1%
Imagine the reaction if that poll had made the front page of the Sunday papers!
So many polls today.
Who to trust?
Had the Ontario and Manitoba dates mixed up in my head. I hate when that happens. Good thing I never had a job delivering stays of execution.
Well, as I'm sure most of us here know, the death penalty is wrong anyway.
Too bad the Americans haven't realized that yet
(the only country in the Western world to still have the death penalty).
Agreed. Just a bit of dark humor there. When I drop or spill something, I say "Guess that's why I lost that job at the nuclear power plant".
Abacus poll - I assume this is the last one of the election?
Decided voters
Liberal 37%
PC 34%
NDP 24%
Likely voters
Liberal 40%
PC 35%
NDP 22%
Best Premier
McGuinty 30%
Hudak 21%
Horwarth 19% (near tie with Hudak)
unsure 30%
Favourability
Horwath 48% fav./18% unfav.
McGuinty 37% fav./45% unfav.
Hudak 32% fav//48% unfav.
http://abacusdata.ca/2011/10/04/ontario-election-final-poll-lp-37-pc-34-...
Which polling company to trust?
According to The Globe and Mail, senior PC advisers are saying they are worried.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ontariovotes2011/story/2011/10/04/ontario-...
I missed the earlier posting. This Ipsos Reid poll would seem to indicate a Liberal majority, but it does look like the Conservatives are toast.
Which poll to trust? Maybe all of them. The margins are perhaps so slim in swing ridings there's an unusually broad range of possible outcomes.
To me the most compelling poll result was Ekos' question about whether the government was going in the right direction. 56% said it was. People are supporting McGuinty because, whether they like him personally or not (and I think unlike Hudak he's more likable than unlikable), they like what he's done. He's run a progressive, activist government: Green Energy Act, Poverty Reduction Strategy, full day kindergarten. There's a lot to like there. That squares with what I hear in my circle: people give him begrudging praise, peppered with "oh, but he's Liberal."
I believe that is called cherry picking as other polls are showing different things, particularly depending on your area. And don't get me started that the Green Energy Act being anything but a greenwash of a massive privatization shift of our electricity generation capacity. It is anything but progressive.
My guess is that we don't know the outcome and neither do the pollsters. Local races are likely to loom much larger than in previous elections. At this point I still think it is possible that any of the three could form government, in orders of liklihood of course. But almost for sure we will be back at it sometime in 2013
And don't get me started that the Green Energy Act being anything but a greenwash of a massive privatization shift of our electricity generation capacity. It is anything but progressive.
Sorry, that just doesn't square with what everyone I know in the environmental movement has said. And I know a lot. McGunity's viewed as a leader in this area.
At any rate, one piece of good news is that all polls seem to agree Hudak will be shut out of Toronto. It's really hard to govern without a single seat in the biggest city in the province.
I think the right realized he was toast weeks ago. I suspect their internal polling looks bad. The Stun not endorsing him, articles in the Toast and Stun talking about his lacklustre campaign, coverage of how even Bill Davis couldnt really come up with anything nice to say about him, Harper getting Flaherty to endorse him rather than doing it himself...
The homophobic and chain gang garbage seems designed just to get his bedrock fundamentalist (of all faiths) creep vote motivated so he doesnt get wiped out.
But, the tories are the masters of getting old white folks rides to the polls so who knows.
Now the push is on by the righgtiwng press to get Tories to "vote strategically" for the Liberals because they don't want the NDP to have any influence on the Liberals. They know that with a majority McGuinty will swing way to the right and that's what they want. God forbid that a minority government might make McGuinty keep his promises!
I heard the opposite. Tories being told to vote NDP in swing ridings to get their cherished tax reductions.
The Manitoba NDP have shown that voters are not in any big swing cycle. Horwarth will make some gains but no major breakthrough because Canadians seem to want stability in this uncertain world. The Alberta Conservatives will likely win for the same reason when they go to the polls next year.
Angus Reid-Toronto Star last poll:
PC: 36%
Liberal: 33%
NDP: 26%
Green: 5%
The tightest Ontario election in a generation will come down to the wire with the Progressive Conservatives facing a shutout in the city of Toronto, a new Toronto Star-Angus Reid survey suggests.
In the final major poll before Thursday's vote, the Tories are at 36 per cent, the Liberals at 33 per cent, the New Democrats at 26 per cent and the Greens at 5 per cent.
"It's a statistical dead heat," Jaideep Mukerji, managing director at Angus Reid, said Tuesday.
That means victory will go to the party that can best mobilize its voters, but the Tories may not win one of Toronto's 23 ridings, so must secure 54 of Ontario's remaining 84 seats for a majority in the 107-member Legislature.
"In the last two weeks despite the (televised leaders') debate and all the different controversies, our polling is showing that the race really hasn't changed all that much," said Mukerji.
In last Saturday's poll, Tim Hudak's Tories were at 34 per cent, Dalton McGuinty's Liberals at 33 per cent, Andrea Horwath's New Democrats at 26 per cent, and Mike Schreiner's Greens at 6 per cent.
And on Sept. 17, the numbers were virtually identical: PC 36, Liberal 32, NDP 26 and Greens 6.
"The first part of the campaign is about persuasion and the last part really just turns out to be about getting your voters out. We have a pretty good sense of where the camps are. It's just how effective are they going to be in getting out their vote on Election Day," he said.
"There does seem to be a higher motivation among Tory voters to get out there and vote on Thursday. They realize there's a lot at stake for them."
Indeed, 77 per cent of Conservative-leaning respondents said they "will definitely" vote PC compared with 71 per cent of Liberal-inclined voters sticking with the Grits, 65 per cent of New Democrat supporters casting NDP ballots and 45 per cent of Greens remaining with their party.
"They really don't like Dalton McGuinty and unlike some of the other parties, they don't really see some other alternative for them," the pollster said.
Another factor encouraging Tories to cast ballots could also be increasing buzz about a minority Liberal government propped up by the NDP. Ontarians have not had a hung Parliament since the 1985 election.
"The Tory turnout looks higher than it did a few days ago and I think it might be because they realize this election might be in jeopardy for them," he said.
Demographics may slightly favour the Tories as well - 41 per cent of respondents 55 and older plan to vote PC compared to 36 per cent for the Liberals, 20 per cent for the New Democrats and 2 per cent for the Greens.
"Historically, people that turn out to vote tend to be older Canadians and that's an area where the Tories have an edge over the Liberals," noted Mukerji. Weather across the province is forecast to by sunny with temperatures in the high teens.
The online survey of 2,223 people was conducted between Sunday and Tuesday and is considered accurate to within 2.1 percentage points, 19 times out of 20.
But there are ominous signs for the Conservatives, including the party's apparent failure to gain traction in Toronto, where they have not won a provincial riding since 1999.
They are mired in third place at 24 per cent in the city. The Liberals, who hold 19 of Toronto's 23 seats, are at 46 per cent. The New Democrats, who have four city seats, are at 27 per cent and the Greens are at 2 per cent.
"There's something to be said for vote efficiency. The Liberals are doing very well in the 416 area," noted Mukerji.
"Even though (the Tories) are at 36 per cent (overall), there's some pretty vote-rich areas, particularly in the 416, where they don't really seem to have made the inroads that they wanted to," he said.
In the 905 region, the Tories are ahead with 41 per cent to 29 per cent for the Liberals, 24 per cent for the NDP and 6 per cent for the Greens.
That suggests both the Conservatives and New Democrats could win GTA seats currently held by the Liberals.
In terms of gender - 40 per cent of men support the Conservatives compared to 31 per cent of women. In contrast, 33 per cent of men and 34 per cent of women back the Liberals. The NDP has 22 per cent of men and 30 per cent of women and the Greens have 4 per cent male and 5 per cent female.
Despite polls indicating his two terms of majority government are at risk, McGuinty still sounds confident, emphasizing he plans to "drive as hard as we can" in the final hours of the campaign.
"I'm after as many seats, as much support, as many MPPs as we can have in order to form a strong, stable Liberal government," he said in the Tory-held riding of Dufferin-Caledon.
Hudak also strived to remain upbeat, but his nervousness about the Liberals pulling off a win was obvious Tuesday as he raised time and again the spectre of a Grit-NDP coalition.
"Ontario families are getting behind the PCs because we're the only party that can actually bring change to Ontario," he said in Ottawa.
But in Toronto Horwath insisted she is "running to be in the top chair" - not to be kingmaker.
"You guys talk about that M-word, 'minority' but I talk about the M-word as 'momentum' and we still have it."
http://speakyourmind.thestar.com/thestar/get-talking/last-poll-of-the-ca...
I guess you missed all the hysterical articles and editorials in the national Post and the Globe and the Sun begging Ontarians not to give the NDP the balance of power since they might actually pressure the government to do something progressive. the pro-business press wants AUSTERITY and cutbacks. With a Liberal majority - they MIGHT get that. With the NDP having the balance of power - it will nix that whole agenda. the stakes are very high for Bay St - they cannot let the NDP have any influence.
The most recent poll from Nanos poll which came out yesterday, is showing the Ontario Libs dropping from 42% to 34%, or down 8% from the last election while the NDP has gone from 17% in the last election to 30% now, for an increase of 13%. This means that the NDP has effectively gained 21% on the Libs since the last Ontario election. If this momentum continues, and there is nothing to suggest it won't, the NDP could be overtaking the Libs by tomorrow nite.
No, this is the most recent poll from Nanos:
http://www.nanosresearch.com/library/polls/POLONT-F11-T519.pdf