babble is rabble.ca's discussion board but it's much more than that: it's an online community for folks who just won't shut up. It's a place to tell each other — and the world — what's up with our work and campaigns.
Minister of Education Line Beauchamp has given the three main student organizations until the end of today to publicly condemn acts of "violence" and "vandalism". On that basis, she will decide who she will be kind enough to sit down and negotiate with.
Beauchamp, of course, has ignored invitations to condemn the numerous instances of police violence since the start of the strike. And she is also well aware that CLASSE (the organization she hates the most and which represents the largest percentage of strikers) has said it has no mandate to make such a public declaration and can't get one before its weekend meeting.
This fascistic divide and rule tactic was likely learned from the Israeli Zionists' method of avoiding negotiations with the Palestinians - putting forward preconditions which they either know can't be met, or if they are, will undermine the credibility and bargaining power of the other side.
Unfortunately I'm making no predictions about what will happen, but it's clear that a critical point is fast approaching. All I have is the hope and confidence that the students will maintain the kind of solidarity they have shown to date.
Attempts to have any kind of normalcy on the campus of the Université de Montréal in the wake of an ongoing student strike completely unravelled on Wednesday after the administration had to retreat on its efforts to provide classes in striking departments for students who don’t support the boycott.
Tensions were high not just at U de M, but on many campuses, where there were clashes as students resisted hardline tactics to try to force them back to class during the tenth week of their protest over tuition increases of $1,625 over five years.
Injunctions taken by university administrations backfired as students found increasingly violent and disruptive ways to ensure campus activities could not resume, such as broken windows, vandalized art work and fire alarms going off during exams at U de M. [...]
U de M made a decision to temporarily end all classes in departments that have strike votes, a decision that Stéfanie Tougas, secretary general of U de M’s student association, called “good and responsible.”
[...] Tougas said the administration’s decision gives students what they want: recognition of their strike votes.
“This will definitely calm down tensions on campus,” she said.
Recall Minister of Propaganda and Repression Line Beauchamp had given all three student organizations until the end of Wednesday to declare their opposition to "violence and vandalism". CLASSE said it couldn't do so before putting the issue to its assembly this Saturday. Beauchamp therefore condemned them to the wasteland and has been furiously working to get a meeting going with the FECQ (CÉGEP students) and FEUQ (university students) tomorrow. Divide and rule.
After having said that it accepted Mme Beauchamp's invitation, the FECQ has reevaluated its position. It will no participate in the meeting because of FEUQ's decision.
..this article uses the word boycott instead of strike. there seems to be a serious attempt to contain this action now. they've brought out the riot squad. the other day i was wondering about what they (the gov, the police, military/security) must be thinking. it's is slowly being revealed. and then i thought of europe. Student Strike Closes Montreal Court
MONTREAL (CN) - Montreal Superior Court was closed Wednesday afternoon due to a 2-month long student strikeagainst Quebec's plan to increase tuition fees. Court doors were locked when security officials decided to block a crowd of student protestors from entering the building.Tens of thousands of Quebec students, clad in red as a sign of debt, have dropped out of their school year, staging protests throughout Montreal and elsewhere in Quebec to challenge the government's plans to raise university tuition fees by $325 a year for 5 years.
quote
In recent weeks Quebec courts have issued three rulings on temporary injunctions for three post-secondary institutions, forcing students to end picket lines and allowing classes to resume.
20-year old Université de Montréal political science major Stephane Viau called the tuition increase "class war."
Viau compared the lack of education funding with the tens of millions of dollars spent on the construction and mining industries in Quebec.
Paul Gareau, a court runner with a son attending Concordia University, said he pays taxes to fund education, and thinks students should fight for their rights.
"The people in power are making all the decisions, when it should be the civilians, especially when it comes to education," Gareau said.
With no end to the protests in sight, the Quebec government has not backed down and the student movement is equally unrelenting, with daily protests being organized by student groups.
It is absurd, given the rather extreme police violence against peaceful protestors - the young man who lost an eye was playing the harmonica at the time; that was on camera.
There is only one action - done by Gord knows whom - that could be considered potentially violent - bags of bricks on metro rails. It would be a very odd thing for anyone in a progressive student movement to do - usually it is rightwing groups that attack public transport, from fascists in Italy to Al Qaida in London and Madrid. All the other stuff was just the usual "redecorating" - some of it actually very creative and pretty - one usually finds in such conflicts, some sit-ins and occupations, etc.
In my very humble opinion, it would not be a bad move for the student associations - all together - to speak out against such sabotage that could endanger ordinary commuters, but to emphasize the fact that not only have Beauchamp and Charest failed to condemn the extreme police response and the serious wounding of students, arrests of reporters and professors etc, Charest has actually said (I don't have the exact quote, unfortunately) something to the effect that if one takes part in a protest, it is at the participant's peril. Very authoritarian indeed.
I'm wondering how the student movement will be approaching the upcoming Earth Day demo.
Riot Police Kettle UQO Students, Make Dozens of Arrests
Gatineau riot police kettled over 200 students, professors, supporters, and journalists on Lac des Fées parkway on Wednesday, April 18.
The demonstration was en route to the Université du Québec en Outaouais’s (UQO) Lucien-Brault campus as students defied a court injunction for a third day ordering them back to class and criminalizing protests within 25 metres of both UQO’s Gatineau campuses.
On Monday, students barricaded themselves inside the Alexandre-Taché campus and forced the university administration to suspend classes. One student was injured by police and sent to hospital after the university rector ordered food not be delivered to students barricaded inside.
On Tuesday, protests and road blockades were held at the Taché campus, with police entering the campus building and riot police deployed. Video footage revealed a professor being arrested and taken outside of the building, the same man who spoke at a press conference on Monday and condemned the police as well as the Quebec government for using the judicial system as a weapon to end the strike.....
Within a few minutes, the students were kettled, boxed in by police on all sides, and told that they could not leave. Meanwhile,supporters gathered outside police lines on the road and on the campus. After an hour or so, police announced that they would let people leave one by one where they would then show identification and be given a $300+ fine for blocking the road. Those who refused to present identification would be arrested for obstruction.
Police later threatened demonstrators outside the kettle that they would raise the fine for those inside to $500. Radio-Canada reported fines were being issued for $444 and that over 100 arrests had been made by 2:15pm.
Students remained peaceful throughout the day although infuriated that the judicial system and the police are being used to stifle their freedom of assembly and expression.
Lagatta, I agree with you about provocations, etc. But what violence?? Even the bricks on the Métro tracks were carefully preceded by synchronized pulling of the emergency stops at several stations. I repeat: What violence??? It's a diversion, pure sabotage by Charest and Beauchamp. And of course, there's no definition of "violence" or "vandalism", so the student organizations are being asked to denounce everything from artistic murals to "hard picketing" (as the students call it, by contrast with "soft picketing"), and who knows what else. The government is isolated and is running around like cornered rats, trying anything to divert attention from the main game.
The students have responded well, by calling on Beauchamp to condemn police brutality (only the police and security guards have actually committed violence!). And CLASSE has said, "Don't tell us what declarations to make - we are answerable to our members. We'll let you know!"
Meanwhile, another day on the front lines. This is downtown Montréal:
Another demo was declared illegal here today. Many other demos around Québec. Students at U de M did a silent artistic demo, physically recreating Rodin's sculpture "The Thinker", in order to promote the education of "free thinkers".
Too many other events to report. Read the article! More to come.
You are right - it was not violence as such. But it would have been a very unwise move by the students, who have been making use of such creative and inspiring tactics. I am so relieved that the FECQ is standing with the other two groups now. Charest and Beauchamp have a lot to answer for.
As for "boycott", it is a deliberate weasel-word used by right-wingers - the same who natter on about student "entitlement". Lysiane Gagnon, Alain Dubuc, that sort of person (oddly, both were lefties in their youth). Strike is a legitimate word for collective actions not involving wage-labour - think rent strike, hunger strike etc.
The student movement in Quebec is an incredibly important development, with implications that reach well beyond provincial borders. The movement emerged in response to a 75 per cent increase in tuition fees to be implemented over the next five years, but it has quickly evolved into something far more significant. “People are starting to realize that the real problem behind the rising tuition fees and the commodification of education is something related to a socioeconomic system that is behind it all,” said Frank Lévesque-Nicol, a spokesperson for a protest that was held on February 2, 2012. The student movement has rekindled the political imagination to a degree not seen since the Quiet Revolution of the 1960s. This is the most troubling and dynamic period in recent Quebec history, and the possibility that this energy will foster fundamental social change is very real.
quote:
Broadening the Struggle
The speed with which the student movement broadened to a general social struggle is significant and worthy of replication elsewhere. Austerity budgets have been introduced in provinces and cities across Canada and the world, and the level of political organizing in opposition to these measures is promising. It is important to recognize that most of these initiatives are led by students and youth. As Noam Chomsky wrote in defence of the students in 1968, “the student movement today is the one organized, significant segment of the intellectual community that has a real and active commitment to the kind of social change that our society desperately needs.” The achievements of students and youth in the 1960s were significant, and they are certainly replicable, but the conditions and struggles being waged are radically different today.
The student movement began gaining visible momentum in January 2012, as college and university student unions across the province started to adopt unlimited general strike mandates during their general assemblies. These assemblies affirmed the merits of syndicalist organizing, as the strength and effectiveness of the movement in Quebec rests upon highly localized student associations meeting regularly in their communities to adopt collective decisions. Implementing the strike was most effective where students organized within their own departments, rather than through larger centralized unions. The smaller departmental associations then send delegates to weekly congress meetings organized by La Coalition large de l'ASSÉ (CLASSE), which must wait for local assemblies to adopt positions before moving forward. The model is proving very effective. This same approach should be emulated elsewhere – in university departmental groups and associations along with public and private sector workplaces, for example.
Students received a boost of support when two of the largest public sector unions publicly endorsed the student strike, calling on their membership to join the national protest in Montreal on March 22. The protest drew roughly 200,000 people and may have been one of the largest marches in Canadian history. It was around this time that the movement clearly became a general social struggle. Streetlamps, windows, storefronts and balconies are draped with red felt squares that have symbolized the Quebec student movement since 2004, and dozens of people don the square on their lapels in a show of solidarity with the movement. Students organized solidarity actions with locked out Rio Tinto Alcan workers and with hundreds of Aveos employees who recently lost their jobs, and actions were also organized in opposition to the Liberal government's controversial Plan Nord, which seeks to exploit natural resources on indigenous lands.
A major action is planned for Earth Day on April 22 that will be organized along internationalist lines in solidarity with environmental struggles across the world. Several internationalist solidarity actions have taken place in France, England, South Korea and elsewhere. The actions are simply too numerous to list. Queer and feminist groups have also had a visible and articulate presence within the movement, and autonomous actions and mass events have become a daily occurrence.
A philosophy teacher decided to show her support for the strike by giving her lecture outdoors. Some 400 students showed up at lunch hour to attend. The school administration stopped the teacher from giving her class. This resulted in a spontaneous demonstration, spilling into nearby streets. Police were called, brutally arrested 49 students, and gave them all tickets of up to $494. This has become the norm for cops declaring demos "illegal" and dispensing on-the-spot physicial and financial "justice".
Meanwhile, university and college professors have held another press conference condemning the "judicialization" of the strike and the establishment of a police-state atmosphere in and around educational institutions.
ETA: OH, forgot the best part. Students at Limoilou are not on strike, having voted against in their general assembly. But in these times, any young person outside a school is the enemy. Some of those arrested were for the fee increase and against the strike!
Oppression is not merely taking the form of rhetoric. The Occupy and student movements were treated naively when they began, but youth are now pepper sprayed and beaten on a near-daily basis in Montreal and elsewhere. Police have begun to deploy riot squads immediately to dismantle actions, whereas some effort was made at conciliation in the past. “Our job, as police officers, is repression,” said the President of the Police Fraternity of Quebec, Yves Francoeur. “We do not need a social worker as a director, we need a general. After all, the police is a paramilitary organization, let's not forget it.” It is wretched to say this, but the point has been reached where creative thinking is needed to figure out how to organize effectively in the face of increasing physical oppression.
Lagatta, I agree with you about provocations, etc. But what violence?? Even the bricks on the Métro tracks were carefully preceded by synchronized pulling of the emergency stops at several stations. I repeat: What violence???
Yes, reasonable people can disagree on the appropriateness of that tactic, but it really shouldn't be compared to bombing trains and buses. The Tyendinaga railway blockades of 2006 and 2007 are a more apt comparison. Disruptive? Yes. But not violent.
CAUT supports Quebec students’ protests to maintain accessibility
The Canadian Association of University Teachers joins with our colleagues in the Fédération québécoise des professeures et professeurs d’université (FQPPU) in expressing support for Quebec students currently opposing higher tuition fees announced by the Charest government. We also deplore the excessive force that has too often been used against student demonstrators.
Quebec universities require more funding, but shifting the burden to students and their families is counterproductive. CAUT’s policy is that tuition charged to students must be kept as low as possible with the goal of moving toward a zero tuition policy. The reasons are many.
A high tuition policy makes post-secondary education less accessible to students with modest means. Access to post-secondary education should be decided by ability and interest, not family wealth or willingness to undertaken substantial debt. On average, university and college graduates more than pay the cost of their education due to the higher income they earn and the resulting higher taxes they pay.
Perhaps most importantly, as has been recognized for elementary and secondary education, the benefits of post-secondary education are societal as much as personal. As a society we all benefit by having doctors, engineers, librarians, nurses, and other educated professionals and personnel. Our costs for health, social services, and social assistance are reduced as our population is better educated. The cultural benefits are enormous.
Quebec students know this and are speaking out. We support them. But we also support the demand of many in the post-secondary sector in Quebec for more adequate public funding for universities and colleges. This is a difficult economic time that tests a society’s true values. Regrettably, too many recent federal and provincial governments have valued lower taxes for corporations and the wealthy at the expense of education, health care and social welfare.
Canada is a rich country. Quebec’s students are reminding all of us of what our priorities should be.
Today, multiple contingents of demonstrators defied the injunction again, blocking roads, protesting outside of buildings, and seeking to outflank police lines upon the deployment of kettles. In mid-afternoon, police began making mass arrests, filling two buses with protesters, including at least one professor, destined for a detention facility. Many others were ticketed on site and released.
Buses tomorrow morning are expected to transport dozens of supporters from Montreal to Gatineau, where resistance to judicial and police intervention in the strike will continue.
Student associations are facing similar battles elsewhere in Quebec. A critical site will the Université de Sherbrooke, where a judge today ordered all students back to class tomorrow morning and banned protests within 25 meters of campus for the next ten days. A protest is planned for tonight at 8pm outside the Sherbrooke courthouse. Another judge rendered a less heavy-handed decision on a request for a similar injunction at Cégep de Saint-Laurent, upholding today the agreement between the administration and students suspending all classes, with the exception of those in which the petitioner is registered, which are mandated to restart.
The Association des juristes progressistes has joined all national student organizations in denouncing the government’s growing recourse to the courts to repress student protest and strike activity.
Downtown Montréal is the scene of massive confrontations between police riot squads (city police, now apparently bolstered by provincial cops) and thousands of student demonstrators. The protestors massed at the Palais des Congrès (Convention Centre), where Premier Jean Charest was addressing some kind of fair to promote his Plan Nord. There were rocks, bottles, some broken windows, lots of tear gas and stun grenades, physical fights, injuries, about 16 arrests known so far, and in the past hour the cops have declared the demonstration "illegal" several times - it doesn't work. Charest can't get out of the Palais, nor has anyone else been allowed in or out for the past couple hours.
I've also heard that the demo is splitting up, some going to Complexe Desjardins (a major nearby office and shopping complex - I think it still houses the U.S. consultate?), others to Parthenais (police HQ).
Here's the ongoing live coverage from the Gazette:
MONTREAL — A chaotic scene unfolded at a high-profile event featuring Jean Charest, with rubber bullets, projectiles and tear gas raining on what was supposed to be the Quebec premier's political parade.
A speech by the premier was delayed as protesters disrupted a long-planned Montreal symposium on his northern-development project Friday.
A group of students had managed to get into the Palais des Congres convention centre, leading to a standoff with police.
Riot police were guarding the inside of the centre. One protester was being treated for injuries following a scuffle. At least eight people were arrested, as police announced over a loudspeaker that the protest was being declared an illegal assembly.
Outside, the scene was equally messy.
While some protesters hurled objects or built a barricade in the street with construction materials they'd found, police fought them off -- with batons, chemical irritants, and even rubber bullets which were fired on some protesters.
Nicolas Moran, 21-year-old law student at the Universite du Quebec a Montreal, was one of the students who had earlier managed to get into the building.
He had a gash on his forehead and blood on his shirt.
"I wasn't doing anything violent," he said. "A police officer hit me over the head... But I doubt the education minister will denounce violence from police."...
An Open Letter in Support of the Student Strike in Québec
We, the students of the City University of New York and State University of New York, openly support the Québécois student strike. For over nine weeks, post-secondary education students have been on indefinite strike, galvanizing 300,000 people to take the streets and holding the largest student demonstrations in North American history.
Three Brooklyn College student organizers visited Montréal for four days over our spring break to meet with and learn from the student strike–to understand the challenges that Québécois students face and how they have been able to successfully mobilize around their tuition hikes. Even if for only a couple of days, what we witnessed was beyond our wildest dreams of what a student movement could look like and accomplish. We marched with hundreds of students in the strikes, we saw students with pepper spray stained cheeks and the courage to stand up for their right to education.
Québec is rightfully proud of its institutions of higher learning, and Québécois students are rightfully proud of years of work they have put into ensuring that these places remain accessible despite provincial attempts to raise tuition beyond the reach of many Québécois and to convert grants and scholarships in to student loans. In keeping with the tradition that has kept Québec’s tuition the lowest in Canada — an important insurance that education will remain available to the many instead of the few in one of the country’s poorer provinces — students have taken to the streets to protest tuition increases of 127% over ten years. We see these hikes as an attack on the rights of low-income and communities of color to access higher education, and we find their parallel in the tuition increases that will affect SUNY and CUNY students. Our “rational tuition increase” will result in students and their families having to pay an additional $1500 over the next five years.
In addition to seeing clear connections between the struggles around access to education facing our two provinces, we also see the Québec student strike as a model for gaining legitimate student power in our own city in struggling against the anti-austerity measures affecting students across the United States.
We denounce the violence against strikers and unjust profiling of students in Montréal for exercising their right to protest against unjust policies. In particular, the use of pepper spray to violently hinder the strength of the hard picketing on the part of students.
As an act of solidarity and a symbol of our escalation campaign as a student movement in New York, we are launching a “Red Square Campaign” in which allies wear the very same red squares pinned to their chests as the student strikers of Québec. We do this in solidarity with the student struggles in Québec, and to signify our shared struggles against the neoliberal corporatization of our institutions of higher learning. We will wear the red square because we share a common vision of a truly free university.
Thank you for being an inspiration to students everywhere, despite the colonial borders that separate us. We are together in this fight. Nous sommes ensemble.
CBC certainly seems dismissive of the strike. Today CBC reported that Charest is getting more support as a result of the strike, and that the strike talk is taking the focus of investigations into corruption in the province. Also, Charest gave a speech on 'Plan Nord' today and got a long standing ovation, all the while police outside are tear gassing and arresting demonstrators.
Here's a relatively decent wrap-up of the day's events from the Gazette, of all sources. It includes a hint of the anger generated by Charest in his speech to the millionaires inside the Palais, when he "joked" that the students protesting outside were knocking on the door looking for jobs in his Plan Nord project (the planned rape of northern Québec's resources and environment):
Pics from yesterday's protest in Gatineau. FTP!
L'une des suites d'une altercation entre manifestants et les policiers du Service de police de la ville de Gatineau à cause d'une tentative de la part des derniers d'entrer au pavillon Lucien-Brault de l'Université du Québec en Outaouais.
Breaking GroundConcordia President to Send Letter to Charest
Concordia University Senate voted unanimously to request that Quebec Premier Jean Charest start an unconditional dialogue with student groups, and that Interim Concordia President Frederick Lowy pass along the message.
“I think that this is a very important and powerful step,” said Concordia Student Union President Lex Gill. “Concordia is the first university to call on the minister to negotiate without condition and with all stakeholders at the table to resolve the student conflict.”
The original motion proposed by Fine Arts faculty member David Douglas asked that a letter from Lowy be addressed to Education Minister Line Beauchamp. An amendment was added by Arts and Science Senator June Chaikelson to send it to Charest instead.
“That’s even better. It goes to the premier, that’s her boss,” said Gill. “I think its a breaking point for universities to realize that they also have a responsibility to tell the minister and the premier that they need to show some serious leadership right now,” she added.
It is currently unknown how the letter will be written, but Gill believes it might be the original wording of the final motion, and that the letter will first have to be presented to the university community.
The Trans Identity Project also made progress with an announcement by VP Services Roger Cote that students will now be able to list their preferred name on student records and gender will be removed from forms. Legal last names will remain on all documents.
Despite lengthy discussions at the Senate and Board of Governors meetings this week, there is still a lot of confusion surrounding the finances and governance of eConcordia and KnowledgeOne.
Minister of Education Line Beauchamp has given the three main student organizations until the end of today to publicly condemn acts of "violence" and "vandalism". On that basis, she will decide who she will be kind enough to sit down and negotiate with.
Beauchamp, of course, has ignored invitations to condemn the numerous instances of police violence since the start of the strike. And she is also well aware that CLASSE (the organization she hates the most and which represents the largest percentage of strikers) has said it has no mandate to make such a public declaration and can't get one before its weekend meeting.
This fascistic divide and rule tactic was likely learned from the Israeli Zionists' method of avoiding negotiations with the Palestinians - putting forward preconditions which they either know can't be met, or if they are, will undermine the credibility and bargaining power of the other side.
Unfortunately I'm making no predictions about what will happen, but it's clear that a critical point is fast approaching. All I have is the hope and confidence that the students will maintain the kind of solidarity they have shown to date.
19 demonstrators, mostly CEGEP students, arrested in Sherbrooke for picketing government offices
Bravo! Big tactical victory:
Université de Montréal retreats from providing classes - Tensions high as students resist hardline tactics to try to force them back to class
inspiring video from Wednesday at UQO
Right now at UQO
Inside...
...and outside.
LA CONTESTATION ÉTUDIANTE À L'UNIVERSITÉ DU QUÉBEC EN OUTAOUAIS EN DIRECT
I still cannot get over the uniforms of the SQ riot police. Are we living on an Alfonso Cuarón film set?
Recall Minister of Propaganda and Repression Line Beauchamp had given all three student organizations until the end of Wednesday to declare their opposition to "violence and vandalism". CLASSE said it couldn't do so before putting the issue to its assembly this Saturday. Beauchamp therefore condemned them to the wasteland and has been furiously working to get a meeting going with the FECQ (CÉGEP students) and FEUQ (university students) tomorrow. Divide and rule.
And this just in:
FEUQ refuses to meet Beauchamp without CLASSE
And then this:
BRAVO!
The students united will never be defeated!!
Student Strike Closes Montreal Court
MONTREAL (CN) - Montreal Superior Court was closed Wednesday afternoon due to a 2-month long student strikeagainst Quebec's plan to increase tuition fees. Court doors were locked when security officials decided to block a crowd of student protestors from entering the building.Tens of thousands of Quebec students, clad in red as a sign of debt, have dropped out of their school year, staging protests throughout Montreal and elsewhere in Quebec to challenge the government's plans to raise university tuition fees by $325 a year for 5 years.
quote
In recent weeks Quebec courts have issued three rulings on temporary injunctions for three post-secondary institutions, forcing students to end picket lines and allowing classes to resume.
20-year old Université de Montréal political science major Stephane Viau called the tuition increase "class war."
Viau compared the lack of education funding with the tens of millions of dollars spent on the construction and mining industries in Quebec.
Paul Gareau, a court runner with a son attending Concordia University, said he pays taxes to fund education, and thinks students should fight for their rights.
"The people in power are making all the decisions, when it should be the civilians, especially when it comes to education," Gareau said.
With no end to the protests in sight, the Quebec government has not backed down and the student movement is equally unrelenting, with daily protests being organized by student groups.
http://www.courthousenews.com/2012/04/19/45759.htm
It is absurd, given the rather extreme police violence against peaceful protestors - the young man who lost an eye was playing the harmonica at the time; that was on camera.
There is only one action - done by Gord knows whom - that could be considered potentially violent - bags of bricks on metro rails. It would be a very odd thing for anyone in a progressive student movement to do - usually it is rightwing groups that attack public transport, from fascists in Italy to Al Qaida in London and Madrid. All the other stuff was just the usual "redecorating" - some of it actually very creative and pretty - one usually finds in such conflicts, some sit-ins and occupations, etc.
In my very humble opinion, it would not be a bad move for the student associations - all together - to speak out against such sabotage that could endanger ordinary commuters, but to emphasize the fact that not only have Beauchamp and Charest failed to condemn the extreme police response and the serious wounding of students, arrests of reporters and professors etc, Charest has actually said (I don't have the exact quote, unfortunately) something to the effect that if one takes part in a protest, it is at the participant's peril. Very authoritarian indeed.
I'm wondering how the student movement will be approaching the upcoming Earth Day demo.
Gatineau riot police kettled over 200 students, professors, supporters, and journalists on Lac des Fées parkway on Wednesday, April 18.
The demonstration was en route to the Université du Québec en Outaouais’s (UQO) Lucien-Brault campus as students defied a court injunction for a third day ordering them back to class and criminalizing protests within 25 metres of both UQO’s Gatineau campuses.
On Monday, students barricaded themselves inside the Alexandre-Taché campus and forced the university administration to suspend classes. One student was injured by police and sent to hospital after the university rector ordered food not be delivered to students barricaded inside.
On Tuesday, protests and road blockades were held at the Taché campus, with police entering the campus building and riot police deployed. Video footage revealed a professor being arrested and taken outside of the building, the same man who spoke at a press conference on Monday and condemned the police as well as the Quebec government for using the judicial system as a weapon to end the strike.....
http://www.mediacoop.ca/story/riot-police-kettle-uqo-students-make-dozen...
quote:
Within a few minutes, the students were kettled, boxed in by police on all sides, and told that they could not leave. Meanwhile,supporters gathered outside police lines on the road and on the campus. After an hour or so, police announced that they would let people leave one by one where they would then show identification and be given a $300+ fine for blocking the road. Those who refused to present identification would be arrested for obstruction.
Police later threatened demonstrators outside the kettle that they would raise the fine for those inside to $500. Radio-Canada reported fines were being issued for $444 and that over 100 arrests had been made by 2:15pm.
Students remained peaceful throughout the day although infuriated that the judicial system and the police are being used to stifle their freedom of assembly and expression.
Lagatta, I agree with you about provocations, etc. But what violence?? Even the bricks on the Métro tracks were carefully preceded by synchronized pulling of the emergency stops at several stations. I repeat: What violence??? It's a diversion, pure sabotage by Charest and Beauchamp. And of course, there's no definition of "violence" or "vandalism", so the student organizations are being asked to denounce everything from artistic murals to "hard picketing" (as the students call it, by contrast with "soft picketing"), and who knows what else. The government is isolated and is running around like cornered rats, trying anything to divert attention from the main game.
The students have responded well, by calling on Beauchamp to condemn police brutality (only the police and security guards have actually committed violence!). And CLASSE has said, "Don't tell us what declarations to make - we are answerable to our members. We'll let you know!"
Meanwhile, another day on the front lines. This is downtown Montréal:
Student strike: Several police interventions
Another demo was declared illegal here today. Many other demos around Québec. Students at U de M did a silent artistic demo, physically recreating Rodin's sculpture "The Thinker", in order to promote the education of "free thinkers".
Too many other events to report. Read the article! More to come.
You are right - it was not violence as such. But it would have been a very unwise move by the students, who have been making use of such creative and inspiring tactics. I am so relieved that the FECQ is standing with the other two groups now. Charest and Beauchamp have a lot to answer for.
As for "boycott", it is a deliberate weasel-word used by right-wingers - the same who natter on about student "entitlement". Lysiane Gagnon, Alain Dubuc, that sort of person (oddly, both were lefties in their youth). Strike is a legitimate word for collective actions not involving wage-labour - think rent strike, hunger strike etc.
The student movement in Quebec is an incredibly important development, with implications that reach well beyond provincial borders. The movement emerged in response to a 75 per cent increase in tuition fees to be implemented over the next five years, but it has quickly evolved into something far more significant. “People are starting to realize that the real problem behind the rising tuition fees and the commodification of education is something related to a socioeconomic system that is behind it all,” said Frank Lévesque-Nicol, a spokesperson for a protest that was held on February 2, 2012. The student movement has rekindled the political imagination to a degree not seen since the Quiet Revolution of the 1960s. This is the most troubling and dynamic period in recent Quebec history, and the possibility that this energy will foster fundamental social change is very real.
quote:
Broadening the StruggleThe speed with which the student movement broadened to a general social struggle is significant and worthy of replication elsewhere. Austerity budgets have been introduced in provinces and cities across Canada and the world, and the level of political organizing in opposition to these measures is promising. It is important to recognize that most of these initiatives are led by students and youth. As Noam Chomsky wrote in defence of the students in 1968, “the student movement today is the one organized, significant segment of the intellectual community that has a real and active commitment to the kind of social change that our society desperately needs.” The achievements of students and youth in the 1960s were significant, and they are certainly replicable, but the conditions and struggles being waged are radically different today.
The student movement began gaining visible momentum in January 2012, as college and university student unions across the province started to adopt unlimited general strike mandates during their general assemblies. These assemblies affirmed the merits of syndicalist organizing, as the strength and effectiveness of the movement in Quebec rests upon highly localized student associations meeting regularly in their communities to adopt collective decisions. Implementing the strike was most effective where students organized within their own departments, rather than through larger centralized unions. The smaller departmental associations then send delegates to weekly congress meetings organized by La Coalition large de l'ASSÉ (CLASSE), which must wait for local assemblies to adopt positions before moving forward. The model is proving very effective. This same approach should be emulated elsewhere – in university departmental groups and associations along with public and private sector workplaces, for example.
Students received a boost of support when two of the largest public sector unions publicly endorsed the student strike, calling on their membership to join the national protest in Montreal on March 22. The protest drew roughly 200,000 people and may have been one of the largest marches in Canadian history. It was around this time that the movement clearly became a general social struggle. Streetlamps, windows, storefronts and balconies are draped with red felt squares that have symbolized the Quebec student movement since 2004, and dozens of people don the square on their lapels in a show of solidarity with the movement. Students organized solidarity actions with locked out Rio Tinto Alcan workers and with hundreds of Aveos employees who recently lost their jobs, and actions were also organized in opposition to the Liberal government's controversial Plan Nord, which seeks to exploit natural resources on indigenous lands.
A major action is planned for Earth Day on April 22 that will be organized along internationalist lines in solidarity with environmental struggles across the world. Several internationalist solidarity actions have taken place in France, England, South Korea and elsewhere. The actions are simply too numerous to list. Queer and feminist groups have also had a visible and articulate presence within the movement, and autonomous actions and mass events have become a daily occurrence.
http://www.socialistproject.ca/bullet/619.php
This is incredible:
49 arrests at Cégep Limoilou
A philosophy teacher decided to show her support for the strike by giving her lecture outdoors. Some 400 students showed up at lunch hour to attend. The school administration stopped the teacher from giving her class. This resulted in a spontaneous demonstration, spilling into nearby streets. Police were called, brutally arrested 49 students, and gave them all tickets of up to $494. This has become the norm for cops declaring demos "illegal" and dispensing on-the-spot physicial and financial "justice".
Meanwhile, university and college professors have held another press conference condemning the "judicialization" of the strike and the establishment of a police-state atmosphere in and around educational institutions.
ETA: OH, forgot the best part. Students at Limoilou are not on strike, having voted against in their general assembly. But in these times, any young person outside a school is the enemy. Some of those arrested were for the fee increase and against the strike!
quote
Oppression is not merely taking the form of rhetoric. The Occupy and student movements were treated naively when they began, but youth are now pepper sprayed and beaten on a near-daily basis in Montreal and elsewhere. Police have begun to deploy riot squads immediately to dismantle actions, whereas some effort was made at conciliation in the past. “Our job, as police officers, is repression,” said the President of the Police Fraternity of Quebec, Yves Francoeur. “We do not need a social worker as a director, we need a general. After all, the police is a paramilitary organization, let's not forget it.” It is wretched to say this, but the point has been reached where creative thinking is needed to figure out how to organize effectively in the face of increasing physical oppression.
http://www.socialistproject.ca/bullet/619.php
Yes, reasonable people can disagree on the appropriateness of that tactic, but it really shouldn't be compared to bombing trains and buses. The Tyendinaga railway blockades of 2006 and 2007 are a more apt comparison. Disruptive? Yes. But not violent.
CAUT supports Quebec students’ protests to maintain accessibility
The Canadian Association of University Teachers joins with our colleagues in the Fédération québécoise des professeures et professeurs d’université (FQPPU) in expressing support for Quebec students currently opposing higher tuition fees announced by the Charest government. We also deplore the excessive force that has too often been used against student demonstrators.
Quebec universities require more funding, but shifting the burden to students and their families is counterproductive. CAUT’s policy is that tuition charged to students must be kept as low as possible with the goal of moving toward a zero tuition policy. The reasons are many.
A high tuition policy makes post-secondary education less accessible to students with modest means. Access to post-secondary education should be decided by ability and interest, not family wealth or willingness to undertaken substantial debt. On average, university and college graduates more than pay the cost of their education due to the higher income they earn and the resulting higher taxes they pay.
Perhaps most importantly, as has been recognized for elementary and secondary education, the benefits of post-secondary education are societal as much as personal. As a society we all benefit by having doctors, engineers, librarians, nurses, and other educated professionals and personnel. Our costs for health, social services, and social assistance are reduced as our population is better educated. The cultural benefits are enormous.
Quebec students know this and are speaking out. We support them. But we also support the demand of many in the post-secondary sector in Quebec for more adequate public funding for universities and colleges. This is a difficult economic time that tests a society’s true values. Regrettably, too many recent federal and provincial governments have valued lower taxes for corporations and the wealthy at the expense of education, health care and social welfare.
Canada is a rich country. Quebec’s students are reminding all of us of what our priorities should be.
http://www.caut.ca/pages.asp?page=1075
quote
Today, multiple contingents of demonstrators defied the injunction again, blocking roads, protesting outside of buildings, and seeking to outflank police lines upon the deployment of kettles. In mid-afternoon, police began making mass arrests, filling two buses with protesters, including at least one professor, destined for a detention facility. Many others were ticketed on site and released.
Buses tomorrow morning are expected to transport dozens of supporters from Montreal to Gatineau, where resistance to judicial and police intervention in the strike will continue.
Student associations are facing similar battles elsewhere in Quebec. A critical site will the Université de Sherbrooke, where a judge today ordered all students back to class tomorrow morning and banned protests within 25 meters of campus for the next ten days. A protest is planned for tonight at 8pm outside the Sherbrooke courthouse. Another judge rendered a less heavy-handed decision on a request for a similar injunction at Cégep de Saint-Laurent, upholding today the agreement between the administration and students suspending all classes, with the exception of those in which the petitioner is registered, which are mandated to restart.
The Association des juristes progressistes has joined all national student organizations in denouncing the government’s growing recourse to the courts to repress student protest and strike activity.
http://tuitiontruth.ca/
Downtown Montréal is the scene of massive confrontations between police riot squads (city police, now apparently bolstered by provincial cops) and thousands of student demonstrators. The protestors massed at the Palais des Congrès (Convention Centre), where Premier Jean Charest was addressing some kind of fair to promote his Plan Nord. There were rocks, bottles, some broken windows, lots of tear gas and stun grenades, physical fights, injuries, about 16 arrests known so far, and in the past hour the cops have declared the demonstration "illegal" several times - it doesn't work. Charest can't get out of the Palais, nor has anyone else been allowed in or out for the past couple hours.
I've also heard that the demo is splitting up, some going to Complexe Desjardins (a major nearby office and shopping complex - I think it still houses the U.S. consultate?), others to Parthenais (police HQ).
Here's the ongoing live coverage from the Gazette:
http://live.montrealgazette.com/Event/Students_against_tuition_fee_hikes...
video
MONTREAL — A chaotic scene unfolded at a high-profile event featuring Jean Charest, with rubber bullets, projectiles and tear gas raining on what was supposed to be the Quebec premier's political parade.
A speech by the premier was delayed as protesters disrupted a long-planned Montreal symposium on his northern-development project Friday.
A group of students had managed to get into the Palais des Congres convention centre, leading to a standoff with police.
Riot police were guarding the inside of the centre. One protester was being treated for injuries following a scuffle. At least eight people were arrested, as police announced over a loudspeaker that the protest was being declared an illegal assembly.
Outside, the scene was equally messy.
While some protesters hurled objects or built a barricade in the street with construction materials they'd found, police fought them off -- with batons, chemical irritants, and even rubber bullets which were fired on some protesters.
Nicolas Moran, 21-year-old law student at the Universite du Quebec a Montreal, was one of the students who had earlier managed to get into the building.
He had a gash on his forehead and blood on his shirt.
"I wasn't doing anything violent," he said. "A police officer hit me over the head... But I doubt the education minister will denounce violence from police."...
http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/Canada/20120420/charest-speech-rowdy-protest-120420/#ixzz1sc45Hh4b
An Open Letter in Support of the Student Strike in Québec
We, the students of the City University of New York and State University of New York, openly support the Québécois student strike. For over nine weeks, post-secondary education students have been on indefinite strike, galvanizing 300,000 people to take the streets and holding the largest student demonstrations in North American history.
Three Brooklyn College student organizers visited Montréal for four days over our spring break to meet with and learn from the student strike–to understand the challenges that Québécois students face and how they have been able to successfully mobilize around their tuition hikes. Even if for only a couple of days, what we witnessed was beyond our wildest dreams of what a student movement could look like and accomplish. We marched with hundreds of students in the strikes, we saw students with pepper spray stained cheeks and the courage to stand up for their right to education.
Québec is rightfully proud of its institutions of higher learning, and Québécois students are rightfully proud of years of work they have put into ensuring that these places remain accessible despite provincial attempts to raise tuition beyond the reach of many Québécois and to convert grants and scholarships in to student loans. In keeping with the tradition that has kept Québec’s tuition the lowest in Canada — an important insurance that education will remain available to the many instead of the few in one of the country’s poorer provinces — students have taken to the streets to protest tuition increases of 127% over ten years. We see these hikes as an attack on the rights of low-income and communities of color to access higher education, and we find their parallel in the tuition increases that will affect SUNY and CUNY students. Our “rational tuition increase” will result in students and their families having to pay an additional $1500 over the next five years.
In addition to seeing clear connections between the struggles around access to education facing our two provinces, we also see the Québec student strike as a model for gaining legitimate student power in our own city in struggling against the anti-austerity measures affecting students across the United States.
We denounce the violence against strikers and unjust profiling of students in Montréal for exercising their right to protest against unjust policies. In particular, the use of pepper spray to violently hinder the strength of the hard picketing on the part of students.
As an act of solidarity and a symbol of our escalation campaign as a student movement in New York, we are launching a “Red Square Campaign” in which allies wear the very same red squares pinned to their chests as the student strikers of Québec. We do this in solidarity with the student struggles in Québec, and to signify our shared struggles against the neoliberal corporatization of our institutions of higher learning. We will wear the red square because we share a common vision of a truly free university.
Thank you for being an inspiration to students everywhere, despite the colonial borders that separate us. We are together in this fight. Nous sommes ensemble.
Solidarité,
Brooklyn College Student Union
New York Students Rising
Students United for a Free CUNY
CUNY wide General Assembly
The Graduate Center General Assembly
http://takebackbrooklyn.wordpress.com/
CBC certainly seems dismissive of the strike. Today CBC reported that Charest is getting more support as a result of the strike, and that the strike talk is taking the focus of investigations into corruption in the province. Also, Charest gave a speech on 'Plan Nord' today and got a long standing ovation, all the while police outside are tear gassing and arresting demonstrators.
Here's a relatively decent wrap-up of the day's events from the Gazette, of all sources. It includes a hint of the anger generated by Charest in his speech to the millionaires inside the Palais, when he "joked" that the students protesting outside were knocking on the door looking for jobs in his Plan Nord project (the planned rape of northern Québec's resources and environment):
Student rally against Plan Nord turns ugly
Imagine if Charest wins the next election.
..i post this because i wanted to share my fascination with how well students are organized.
How to Help with the May 2 Student ManifestationALL STUDENTS
1) Attend Upcoming meetings:
2) Plug into Working Groups:Press and Media TeamContact: Julieta Salgado: joolietasalgado@gmail.com
Tasks:Legal Team:
Contact: Stephen Thompson: stephenthompson91@gmail.com ...and much much more.
http://takebackbrooklyn.wordpress.com/2012/04/19/how-to-help-with-the-may-2-student-manifestation/
Pics from yesterday's protest in Gatineau. FTP! L'une des suites d'une altercation entre manifestants et les policiers du Service de police de la ville de Gatineau à cause d'une tentative de la part des derniers d'entrer au pavillon Lucien-Brault de l'Université du Québec en Outaouais.
Concordia University Senate voted unanimously to request that Quebec Premier Jean Charest start an unconditional dialogue with student groups, and that Interim Concordia President Frederick Lowy pass along the message.
“I think that this is a very important and powerful step,” said Concordia Student Union President Lex Gill. “Concordia is the first university to call on the minister to negotiate without condition and with all stakeholders at the table to resolve the student conflict.”
The original motion proposed by Fine Arts faculty member David Douglas asked that a letter from Lowy be addressed to Education Minister Line Beauchamp. An amendment was added by Arts and Science Senator June Chaikelson to send it to Charest instead.
“That’s even better. It goes to the premier, that’s her boss,” said Gill. “I think its a breaking point for universities to realize that they also have a responsibility to tell the minister and the premier that they need to show some serious leadership right now,” she added.
It is currently unknown how the letter will be written, but Gill believes it might be the original wording of the final motion, and that the letter will first have to be presented to the university community.
The Trans Identity Project also made progress with an announcement by VP Services Roger Cote that students will now be able to list their preferred name on student records and gender will be removed from forms. Legal last names will remain on all documents.
Despite lengthy discussions at the Senate and Board of Governors meetings this week, there is still a lot of confusion surrounding the finances and governance of eConcordia and KnowledgeOne.
More to come.
http://thelinknewspaper.ca/article/2973
video
http://rt.com/news/montreal-police-protesters-rally-608/
...or a video game?