babble-intro-img
babble is rabble.ca's discussion board but it's much more than that: it's an online community for folks who just won't shut up. It's a place to tell each other — and the world — what's up with our work and campaigns.

Mulcair-led NDP (thread #8)

132 replies [Last post]

Comments

Sean in Ottawa
Offline
Joined: Jun 3 2003

I think the NDP MUST be prepared to fight a new leader of the Cons-- someone who may in fact wear fuzzy sweaters more attractively. Otherwise we are setting a trap and planning for an election that, I, for one, believe is unlikely to ever happen.

This is not to say Harper will definitely go-- I am just saying that if trends continue it is more likely that he will go (pushed or of his own accord) before the next election. At least we need to avoid building our plans assuming he will still be there.


6079_Smith_W
Offline
Joined: Jun 10 2010

@ Sean

It's kind of hard not to, since the party IS Harper. There is no conservative party any more. Whatever comes afterwards is going to be completely different. There is no way around that.

But even the brand isn't a sure target, because we have seen enough cases of parties dissolving when they become too toxic and re-emerging as something "new".


finois
Offline
Joined: Jun 10 2004

Sean, i speculated the concept of an early end to Harper a few months ago. I believe it is not so much about how the CONS are polling althought that is key. It is about how badly Harper is polling.

i believe we need certain conditions to develope that may casue an early election

1) Harper's polling continues to fall and he personally polls consistently lower than the cons themselves:

2) A split occurs on his right side whcih bleeds even a few % of votes

3) The NDP gradual increase in the polls

4) The loss of B.C. over the pipeline and the concept of the Cons picking sides over alberta vs b.c.. Some of these con  caucus meetings as this develops should be interesting

5) The maritimes continues the shift to the NDP. i expect the liberal seats and votes will collapse here and this will also cause some conservatives sets to fall

6) If Obama wins in November and has 4 years without any chance of running again watch him become very friendly with the moderate leader from Canada who advocates similar tax policies. Obama has much more in common with Mulcair.  obama remembers Canada's awkard involvement by the cons to assist republicans and mccain in the last election as well as embarasing him pver pipeline.. Obama might like to give Harper a good slap for old times sake

i Still believe Harper will resign amidst growing disallusionment and the cons will be forced to call an election bye summer 2014.

Here's hopin'

 

 


Sean in Ottawa
Offline
Joined: Jun 3 2003

I think an early election is not likely but certainly Harper going is.

@6079 I think the key is to talk about failed Conservative ideology as well as personalizing Harper governemnt etc.


6079_Smith_W
Offline
Joined: Jun 10 2010

Yes, that works for us, but not for the many people here in Saskatchewan who spit when they hear the name "Grant Devine" but who think Brad Wall is cute as a button.

And I don't see Harper letting anything stop him completely other than the courts. In my opinion he crossed the Rubicon when he quashed legislation passed by the House with his unelected majority in the Senate. Stalls and reversals to legislation are one thing, but I can't imagine anything that would compel him to go of his own free will.

 

 


Stockholm
Online
Joined: Sep 29 2002

finois wrote:

Sean, i speculated the concept of an early end to Harper a few months ago. I believe it is not so much about how the CONS are polling althought that is key. It is about how badly Harper is polling.

i believe we need certain conditions to develope that may casue an early election

1) Harper's polling continues to fall and he personally polls consistently lower than the cons themselves:

2) A split occurs on his right side whcih bleeds even a few % of votes

3) The NDP gradual increase in the polls

4) The loss of B.C. over the pipeline and the concept of the Cons picking sides over alberta vs b.c.. Some of these con  caucus meetings as this develops should be interesting

5) The maritimes continues the shift to the NDP. i expect the liberal seats and votes will collapse here and this will also cause some conservatives sets to fall

6) If Obama wins in November and has 4 years without any chance of running again watch him become very friendly with the moderate leader from Canada who advocates similar tax policies. Obama has much more in common with Mulcair.  obama remembers Canada's awkard involvement by the cons to assist republicans and mccain in the last election as well as embarasing him pver pipeline.. Obama might like to give Harper a good slap for old times sake

i Still believe Harper will resign amidst growing disallusionment and the cons will be forced to call an election bye summer 2014.

Here's hopin'

 

I would add to this:

7) The federal Liberals continue to disintegrate and Liberal voters in Ontario start a stampede to the NDP as the only party that can beat Harper and polls in Ontario start to consistently shift from the current CPC 38/39, NDP 28/29, Libs 26/27 to a new paradigm of CPC 37/38, NDP 35/36, Libs 18/19


janfromthebruce
Online
Joined: Apr 24 2007

Arthur Cramer wrote:

Jan, I wasn't surprised when we won here. I was of the feeling we were going to get at least 32 seats. I think the memory of the Filmon Tories just keeps hanging aroudn their necks. The MTS privitizaton steal isn't forgotten, and reminding people about Manitoba Hydro being possibly privitized by the Tories was simply an albatros Hugh McFayden couldn't shake. He'd have done it for sure. It was a great victory. But, I was REALLY surprised by the size of the majority.

thanks Arthur. I had another babble poster who suggested initially that the NDP would lose because leading into the election the polling was better for the Conservatives.


6079_Smith_W
Offline
Joined: Jun 10 2010

So on the one hand when we talk about the Liberals it is as if they are no better than the Harperites. Yet when we think about the prospect of the party dissolving all of a sudden all the rats are going to jump ship over to the NDP. 

Sorry if I am a bit sceptical.

 


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Will the Cons use the "Bob Rae Days" as a boogeyman to scare voters away from the NDP?


quizzical
Offline
Joined: Dec 8 2011

what are Bob Rae days?

 


Howard
Offline
Joined: Aug 31 2011

If Harper were to step down because he didn't want to lose, whoever inherited his mantle would be expected to lose, kind of like Christy Clark. Trying to dig yourself out from under that political perspective is pretty tough.


Fidel
Offline
Joined: Apr 29 2004

quizzical wrote:

what are Bob Rae days?

 

 

12 unpaid holidays a year for civil service workers in the 1990s. Excluded were those earning less than $30,000 annually.

So they threw out the NDP in 1995 and elected Tories. Harris' Tories permamently laid off 10,000 nurses and ran the deficit up borrowing $35 billion from private sources to finance tax cuts for rich people.


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Login or register to post comments