babble-intro-img
babble is rabble.ca's discussion board but it's much more than that: it's an online community for folks who just won't shut up. It's a place to tell each other — and the world — what's up with our work and campaigns.

Stage Set For Vote on $16 Billion, Costly F-35 Stealth Fighter Jets

93 replies [Last post]

Comments

Gaian
Offline
Joined: Aug 5 2011
I've sent away my bit to help with the preparation and presentation of those ads. There will be further calls for assistance throughout the year, no doubt. Jack knew when to squeeze. How about you?

Sean in Ottawa
Offline
Joined: Jun 3 2003

Could a Mod update the thread title to the amount the auditor general said it would cost?


Buddy Kat
Offline
Joined: Sep 21 2006

Gaian wrote:
duncan cameron wrote:

The A.G.'s report gives Mulcair what he needs to go after McKay for sure. Its a gift really. The larger question is why buy a first strike fighter jet in the first place and what would the NDP do differently.

The LARGER question? Uh huh. I'll bet New Democrats would be quite content to do as thorin bane suggested upthread: "F18 superhornet 100 of them and would only cost 4 billion. They could also start delivery ASAP as they already funstion. They also out perform the F35 on everthing except stealth, and have 2 engines. Pilts are familiar with controls=less training, and they have compatable parts that our techs already know about. The 12 billion saved could be put into anything even more warmaking vessels or transport. It doesn't even make sense from a conservative perspective. The only reason for this is like buying a Harley. Name recognizition even if the Honda is better and cheaper."

 

Oh yeah definatley ..especially when you consider Canada is the pinnacle nation for drones and robotic technology..technology the US wants to purchase from us while they sell us useless overpriced garbage...

 

People have no clue whatsoever on how Canada panders to the US puppet string danglers and above all have no clue on the expertise in the nation......Canada is the leader in robotics, drone technology and electronic warfare systems that even make the US drool.

Latest Canadian mil tec

We don't need no USA anything...dammit

 

All these years during the cold war and thinking we are the peace keeper to find out that most of the US war machine was developed in Canada and just pre fab slapped together in the US...especially the technological marvels.

Not just electronic manufacture but in missle radar sites and satellite stations that direct the info to US departments OVER Canadian ones for decades and decades, showing the USA where our water originates ....where our minerals are to exploit......this done years ago before the days of high technology....the conservatives and liberals too have done a fantastic job in demoralizing the Canadain military and country. At least the libs try to make up for it by cherry picking NDP values to implemnet over the years to cheer us up a bit..Undecided

 

It is time to take Canada back from the Conservative sellout traitors..remember the "arrow"....Yell


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Coyne: F-35 debacle demonstrates a system of government in collapse

There are so many layers of misconduct in the F-35 affair that it is difficult to know where to start. Do we especially deplore the rigging of operational requirements by defence officials to justify a decision that had already been made? Or should we focus on the government's decision to buy the planes without even seeing the department's handiwork? Is the scandal that the department deliberatedly understated the cost of the jets, in presentations to Parliament and the public? Or is it that its own internal figures, though they exceeded the published amounts by some $10-billon, were themselves, according to the Auditor General, gross underestimates?

 

It's all of those things, of course, and more: a fiasco from top to bottom, combining lapses of professional ethics, ministerial responsibility and democratic accountability into one spectacular illustration of how completely our system of government has gone to hell.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Rex Murphy completely eviscerated Peter Mackay tonight, and, by extension, Harper. Laughing


NDPP
Offline
Joined: Dec 28 2008

Be Heard - No Stealth Fighters!

http://www.ceasefire.ca/?p=10587

"Tell Stephen Harper, other party leaders, and your own MP that you do not support the F-35 Stealth Fighter. Send your letter right away. Sign the Petition!"


autoworker
Online
Joined: Dec 21 2008

NDPP wrote:

Security Experts Say China Hijacked Stealth F-35 Fighter Jet Plans From BAE Systems

http://www.terminalx.org/2012/03/security-experts-say-china-hacked.html

"The Chinese exploited vulnerabilities in BAE's computer defences to steal vast amounts of data on the $300 Billion F-35 Joint Strike Fighter.."

and are now shaking their heads and wondering why anyone would put a plug nickel into this outrageous, ill-designed lemon...

BAE is also involved with the manufacture of the Eurofighter, which has a similar history of cost overruns, and is also subject to much the same political debate surrounding the F-35 procurement. Is it possible that the impending cost inflation is the result of a scandalous breach of security that has compromised it's operational effectiveness. Perhaps the Anglo-American, industrial-military-academic complex is sitting on a titanic turd during a U.S. election cycle?


NDPP
Offline
Joined: Dec 28 2008

Den Tandt: AG Shreds Harper's Fig Leaf of Deniability on F-35 Debacle

http://www.canada.com/Tandt+shreds+Harper+leaf+deniability+debacle/64179...

"So that's it then. They knew and they lied.

To Parliament.

To all of us.

If that's true then they will have no defenders, anywhere.

Cabinet-level resignations yes, as a starting point.

But it's bigger than that.

The government itself will be discredited.

There is no moving on from a lie this big."


NDPP
Offline
Joined: Dec 28 2008

THe F-35 Stealth Fighter Program:   - by Michel Chossudovsky

http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=va&aid=30144

"How the war economy contributes to exacerbating the social crisis. War and the neoliberal economic policy agenda are part of an integrated process..'

 

Scrapping Fighter Jet Purchase Would Hurt Everyone: US (2011)

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/Scrapping+fighter+purchase+could+hurt+e...

'US Defense Secretary Robert Gates said he didn't wish to interfere in Canada's domestic affairs BUT..."


NDPP
Offline
Joined: Dec 28 2008

F-35 Scandal: We Need a Canadian Spring Now More Than Ever - Derrick O'Keefe

http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/derrick/2012/04/f-35-scandal-we-need-can...

"It's the military-industrial complex, stupid.."


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Peter Mackay was just on CTV's Question Period saying the extra $10billion is the cost of maintaining the F18 program until we get the F35s. Is that clear to anyone??? Undecided

 

ETA: Mackay said there is no reason for him to resign.


NorthReport
Offline
Joined: Jul 6 2008

So MacKay is a bigger idiot that we already thought he was. 

Of course he won't resign - when was the last time a right-winger resigned on principle?

 


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

The thread title Stage Set For Vote on $16 Billion, Costly F-35 Stealth Fighter Jets perhaps should be updated to read $25 (or is it $30) Billion.

 

On one of the talk shows the pundits said Harper is making all those government cuts in the Budget  in order to pay for the F35s.

On CTV's Question Period today one of the pundits said the purpose of the F35 program is to contain China 30 years from now.


thorin_bane
Offline
Joined: Jun 19 2004

My Issue is the new AG is a tory hack, you can see, he even blames EVERYONE but the people lying. Rigging the table much Harper? It will take decades to fix the destructino wrought by decievin steven. That or a revoltuion and we change to a republic update some rights, ditch FPTP and start reigning in the rich AGAIN.


thorin_bane
Offline
Joined: Jun 19 2004

Ouch first post in a while and its a double


NDPP
Offline
Joined: Dec 28 2008

F-35 Fighter Deal Shaky from the Start - by Geoff Stevens

http://www.guelphmercury.com/opinion/columns/article/701242--f-35-fighte...

"The F-35 fighter jet affair is a scandal that should, by rights, bring down the Harper government. Not only is it huge - in terms of taxpayer dollars, 100 times the size of the sponsorship scandal that destroyed the former Liberal government - it is laced through with lies, deceit and ministerial incompetence. What does the government say now? It says that while it may have invested $500 million in development costs, it has not actually purchased any F-35s. With luck, it never will - not now."

$24 Billion British Budget Blowout in Black Hole F-35 Project

http://rt.com/news/f-35-british-cost-billions-590/

"The UK is set to fork out $24 billion, for the American Joint Strike Fighter program, whose total costs are set to exceed $900 billion over the next 50 years, making it the most expensive military project in history. Each F-35 Lightning II Stealth fighter jet will cost the UK around $136 million, plus an extra $25.6 million for each engine..."

Something tells me this outrageous hustle ain't going to fly. Nor should it.


NDPP
Offline
Joined: Dec 28 2008

Tories Only Want Ministers To Testify on F-35s

http://www.hilltimes.com/news/politics/2012/04/10/tories-want-ministers-...

"The government is attempting to out manoeuvre the opposition parties and prevent a team of National Defence and Public Works managers who have overseen the $25 billion F-35 fighter jet project from being called to testify at the Commons Public Accounts committee, the opposition says..."

PM Harper's Team Gets a Good Laugh Over 'Austerity' - by Linda McQuaig

http://www.thestar.com/opnion/editorialopinion/article/1158786--prime-mi...

"...Just last week, citing 'challenging fiscal times' the Harper team ended a program  that provides internet access at libraries and community centers, giving low-income Canadians - about half of whom lack internet access - a lifeline to the world, as well as a way to apply for jobs. The nationwide program, which costs only $15 million, operates with the help of volunteers.."


Doug
Offline
Joined: Apr 17 2001

This is certainly an interesting look back when all this started. Note how much Peter MacKay says it's going to cost.


bagkitty
Online
Joined: Aug 27 2008

Is it technically possible for the mods to do a strike through in this thread's title and replace the $16 billion with the current (low end) figure of $25 billion? Of course the effect is lost if it can't be done with a strikethrough... maybe we need divine intervention, GOD, are you reading this thread?


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Hell, if GOD is listening, could you please deliver us from Stephen Harper!!!


bagkitty
Online
Joined: Aug 27 2008

Boom Boom: we may have stumbled across something here -- the so-called Manichean heresy may, in fact, not be a heresy at all!


NDPP
Offline
Joined: Dec 28 2008

John Ivison: Pax Americana Alliance At Heart of Harper Government's F-35 Posture

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com/2012/04/10/john-ivison-pax-americana...

"...The wider international backdrop to the F-35 purchase is an America concerned about the rise of China in the Pacific. The Canadian government's decision to go with the F-35 appears to be part of a tacit political agreement between the US and key allies like Japan and Australia to contain China's ambitions.

It seems entirely feasible that the Harper government and National Defence were willing supplicants in a grand Pacific Pax Americana. Having signed up to the F-35 program, they attempted to justify it on the basis of regional industrial benefits and supplying the men and women in uniform with the best equipment available. The uncomfortable truth about the escalating costs and development problems was discounted and all opposition railroaded.."


Doug
Offline
Joined: Apr 17 2001

The F-35 is an expensive dud. The Jet that Ate the Pentagon


M. Spector
Offline
Joined: Feb 19 2005

John Warnock wrote:
The key role of the CF-35 will be to attack targets on the ground with bombs, missiles and rockets. Canadian Forces did this in the first Gulf War, slaughtering unarmed Iraqi conscripted soldiers as they attempted to go home after being defeated in combat on the ground. In Yugoslavia the Canadian Air Force, operating under NATO direction, dropped bombs on just about everything. In Lybia, Canada and several NATO allies carried out an extensive bombing campaign in support of the Islamist forces trying to oust the regime headed by Muammar Gaddafi. Like the bombing campaign in Yugoslavia, this was deemed "humanitarian intervention."...

So for the majority of Canadians who are not in favour of such a military policy, what is to be done? The Harperites and the Liberals have a deep commitment to continuing this policy. But what of the NDP? During the Cold War, the NDP, like all the western social democratic parties and governments, gave full support to the NATO alliance, the extensive mobilization for war and support for the major development of nuclear weapons.

Since then they have demonstrated a firm commitment to the Anglo-American alliance to dominate the world. The NDP caucus in Ottawa supported all of the post-Cold War Canadian military actions. Yes, even Jack Layton. Will Thomas Mulcair be different? Not to date. It will take a major public effort to convince the caucus of the Official Opposition that the majority of Canadians prefer a focus on peace and not war.

- Do we need to buy the F-35? Does anyone speak for the Canadian public?


Fidel
Online
Joined: Apr 29 2004

John Warnock wrote:
 In Lybia, Canada and several NATO allies carried out an extensive bombing campaign in support of the Islamist forces trying to oust the regime headed by Muammar Gaddafi.

Islamist forces? I think the word 'Islamist' in this case would be a smear against a billion, mostly peaceful people holding certain religious beliefs. Perhaps Warnock's smear is unintended but nevertheless Warnock's use of the term Islamist to describe a bunch of terrorists is uncalled for and ony contributes to Islamophobia and the NeoAnglo-American religious crusades in Central Asia, "the Middle East" and Africa.

The people NATO aided and abetted in Africa are right wing radicals and religious fundamentalists. They are the Libyan wing of the mujahideen "freedom fighters" whose fathers and uncles fought for the CIA in 1980s-90s Afghanistan and Bosnia, Macedonia etc. They are mercenaries and right wing extremists. They are our good friends in Libya, John. 

The Gladio Gang bred them. The Gladio Gang led them.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

CBC: UK ditches plans to buy F35s

ETA:

A Guardian story reports the UK is buying a different version of the F35, not ditching  them. I wonder where the CBC story came from? (it's scrolling across the bottom of the screen on CBC Newsworld).


bagkitty
Online
Joined: Aug 27 2008

And the latest estimate? Well, as of 14 May 2012 [drum roll please]

CDN$41,000,000,000 -- yep that is 41 billion - 256% of what was being discussed when this thread was started less than two years ago.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

Think of all that could be done with $41 billion - full funding for First Nations, hospitals, pharmacare, social programs....


CDN_FORCES
Offline
Joined: Nov 24 2011

We won't be buying the F35. It's unproven technology that's unsuitable for Canada. My personal opinion is that we'll buy the F18E/F, just like the Australians.


Boom Boom
Offline
Joined: Dec 29 2004

CDN_FORCES wrote:

We won't be buying the F35. It's unproven technology that's unsuitable for Canada. My personal opinion is that we'll buy the F18E/F, just like the Australians.

Are the Cons really backing down from the F35?


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Login or register to post comments