Parliament Hill under attack

292 posts / 0 new
Last post
Pondering

alan smithee wrote:

Pondering wrote:

alan smithee wrote:

Pondering wrote:

I have heard two descriptions of the gun. "Shotgun" and "single-shot rifle". 

Now let's not get ahead of ourselves and demonize long guns.

My point is that both descriptions sound like fairly basic hunting guns which would be impossible to control in Canada. Guns like that really are tools for people living in some areas. It does not seem like a carefully planned attack. Highschool shooters have been better prepared. That tells me it was an unsophisticated attack. I doubt there is more than one shooter.

Any attack that leads to a death is serious but had he been even slightly better prepared he could have done far more damage.While security should have been better this doesn't sound like the kind of attack that could be stopped by better spying. If there was any "chatter" last week it is very unlikely it was associated with this attack.

My comment was dripping in sarcasm.

But I agree with what you said.

Thanks, I misunderstood. I thought you were suggesting that I thought those were guns that should be controlled.

Shouldn't this all be on security cameras? How can they not know if there were acomplices or not?

Apparently the daycare is still on lockdown. It seems excessive as the shooting ended at 10 this morning. 8 hours isn't enough to secure a path out?

NorthReport

Not impressed with CBC's Solomon

Shooter has a criminal record to do with drugs and robbery. He has lived in Montreal and Vancouver it seems.

 

NorthReport

The shooter, Michael Zehaf-Bibeau, was intent on taking a lot of lives.

Greta Levy, NDP staffer, presently being interviewed on CBC, was right in the thick of things. Apart from Cpl Nathan Cirillo who died, it must have been a terrible ordeal for her, and everyone involved there in Ottawa.

NorthReport

It sounds like the shootout in Parliament was quite close to the NDP caucus room. 

Webgear

Cpl Nathan Cirillo had a young son.

 

NorthReport

Thanks Webgear. How very sad.

Webgear wrote:

Cpl Nathan Cirillo had a young son.

 

NorthReport

CNN is reporting that their sources say the shooting suspect had convented to Islam.

MegB

It was close to both the NDP and the CPC caucuses. As I understand it the caucus rooms of the governing party and the official opposition are down the hall from each other, just off Centre Block.

Webgear

The members of parliament, government employees and staffs were very lucky this morning, if the shooting went on or longer or if there were additional gunman the death and injury total could have been a lot higher than just the small number of current causalities.

I am glad everyone is safe now. 

NorthReport

Just listening to Scott Reid on CTV saying that if the shooter is one of the people on the CSIS 90 list, we will have to take additional measures to deal with them. 

Debater

Prime Minister speaks with NDP, Liberal leaders in display of cross-partisanship

http://www.nationalnewswatch.com/2014/10/22/prime-minister-speaks-with-n...

NorthReport

Former CSIS operative now on CBC and says:

Canada has serious security gap & must be addressed

ISIS claiming credit online although there may well not be any connection. 

 

NorthReport

PM to address nation today.

NorthReport

What responsibility does the media have in this mess?

Sean in Ottawa

NorthReport wrote:

PM to address nation today.

At 7:45

I hope they interview the opposition leaders after -- and that they say things similar to what Elizabeth May said -- she got it right today.

NorthReport

Parliament Lockdown reinstated - there must be additional threats.

zerocarbs

I was at a pub this afternoon, and I tend to have a negative cast of mind, but I was astounded at how utterly cynical everybody else there was - including the barmaid. Every single person figured Harper would use this event to further his agenda. It's criminal how bastardized he's thrown poltical discourse into in our country.

alan smithee alan smithee's picture

zerocarbs wrote:

I was at a pub this afternoon, and I tend to have a negative cast of mind, but I was astounded at how utterly cynical everybody else there was - including the barmaid. Every single person figured Harper would use this event to further his agenda. It's criminal how bastardized he's thrown poltical discourse into in our country.

Because Harpo WILL use this event to further his agenda. It's not cynical. Clearly,people know his act finally.

Sean in Ottawa

NorthReport wrote:

What responsibility does the media have in this mess?

If you mean going forward -- I would say to report the thruth and laternate points of view.

If you mean with respect to causing this I would say they are not responsible -- the rhetoric they have reported was there and not created by the media.

Going forward as I say I would like to see a connection made that this rhetoric increases the risk of incidents like this.

I cannot say if this would have happened without the rhetoric we have had from the government and without Canada's decision to send forces to fight ISIS. But I think it is safe to say the risk would have been much lower. When the PM goes off like the leader of the world in fighting in far away places he risks Canadians here.

As I have said, I think today is the day the warplanes from Canada arrived in the Middle East.

NorthReport

How did this shooter get passed the Parliamentary security at the entrance doors to the East Block?  

Were the door entrance guards not armed?

Michael Zehaf-Bibeau, slain Ottawa shooter, had criminal record in Quebec, B.C.

Zehaf-Bibeau was charged with drug possession, robbery and uttering threats in the last 10 years

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/michael-zehaf-bibeau-slain-ottawa...

NorthReport

Mulcair has finally been allowed to leave and has done so.

 

NorthReport

Tonite we will hear both from the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Official Opposition. Good.

NorthReport

John Baird has spoken with john Kerry and said "this is why we are with you" so has directly linked this Parliament Hill attack to Iraq.

Sean in Ottawa

NorthReport wrote:

Tonite we will hear both from the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Official Opposition. Good.

Apparently also Trudeau who will have a link established by phone to the CBC...

NDPP

'We live in dark and dangerous times'  - Stephen Harper

'Parliament Hill is one gigantic crime scene' - Evan Solomon

 

Canada's Harper Using 'Terror Attack' To Impose Anti-Democratic Measures  

http://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2014/10/22/cana-o22.html

"Canada's Conservative government and corporate media are seizing upon a purported terrorist attack to advance the ruling elite's agenda of war, reaction and attacks on democratic rights.

What is evident is that the government and big business media intend to exploit the tragedy to whip up support for Canada's participation in the new US-led war in the Middle East and to delegitimize opposition to further anti-democratic amendments to the country's anti-terrorism laws.

The St Jean incident came on the eve of yesterday's departure for Kuwait of the six fighter jets Canada is deploying to assist the US bombing campaign in Iraq and Syria.

The Harper government - which is determined that Canada's elite have, to use Harper's words, 'a seat at the table' in the imperialist reordering of the Middle East - has sought to convince a skeptical public to support Canada's participation in yet another US-led war by dressing it up as a humanitarian intervention.

This has been supplemented by lurid claims that if Canada does not fight ISIS in Iraq, it will have to fight it in Canada..."

 

Ottawa Shooting: Canadian Authorities 'Were Aware of Potential ISIS-Style Attacks For Weeks'

http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/ottawa-shooting-canada-authorities-were-aware-p...

"Within minutes of the gun attack at Ottawa's War Memorial, speculation that Islamic State militants were involved in the shooting was rife.

Long before the attack took place, Canadian intelligence experts were assessing the possibility of a terrorist assault.

Following the shooting, a Twitter user who identified himself as a supporter of IS wrote: 'Our soldiers are on the ground in every theater, will battle you everywhere.'

However, the validity of the message has not been verified..."

 

Pondering

I think Harper's comments were tacky.

onlinediscountanvils

Sean in Ottawa wrote:

NorthReport wrote:

What responsibility does the media have in this mess?

If you mean with respect to causing this I would say they are not responsible

Depends on how deep you want to go. Remember, there hasn't always been a guard posted at the war memorial. They were only posted there following the media-fuelled firestorm over an isolated incident of public urination on Canada Day 2006. Had they treated it as simply one of the hundreds of foolish things that people do after a long day of drinking, rather than use it to whip up public outrage and sell newspapers, the corporal probably wouldn't have been a target this morning.

Sean in Ottawa

Harper making direct connection saying "bringing their savagery to our shores"

Here he is saying shooter terrorist but goes further to make it clear that he thinks ISIS sent this attack.

Paladin1

Kevin Vickers was carrying his own personal pistol. He is one of the few Canadian citizens who have an ATC (allowed to carry) permit.

 

North Report, from what I understand most of the security guards at the parliment are not armed.

Pondering, I'm not certain yet but if the shooter used the gun that's featured in his picture that's been released then it's based off of a gun that was designed in the 1800's. 

Pondering

Mulcair's statement was far better than Harper's. Harper sounded like he was using it as an excuse to redouble our war effort.

Sean in Ottawa

I liked Mulcair's tone and words generally-- would prefer less head-bob, squinting and eyebrow movement. There was enough that it was distracting at moment. But everything else was right.

Harper was very clear on how he was using this for his politics agenda.

sherpa-finn

NorthReport asked: How did this shooter get passed the Parliamentary security at the entrance doors to the East Block?  Were the door entrance guards not armed?

Two points: My impression is that the gunman entered the Centre Block. That is certainly what it looks like from Josh Wingrove's much viewed video.  

And no, there are not normally guards at the outside doors. Parliamentary security is inside, in the lobby. So anyone can certainly enter the Parliament Buildings before going through a security screen. Of course that may now change.

And its not true for the PMO / Langevin Block across the street, where access to the entry  itself is controlled.

NorthReport

Regardless, which building and you are probasbly correct,  how did the shooter get past the security screen with a long gun?

With all the previous threats we have had, going back over a period of years, this is a major security gap.

Tragic as the soldier's death is, many MPs could have very easily been killed.

Sean in Ottawa

Some may not be familiar with the layout.

The entrance has been moved since 9-11 to a basement entrance on the right hand side of the Peace Tower. There, you go in and through the check.

I wonder if he did not just go up to the main doors and go through them. Those main doors are open and used as the exit when leaving the building or as an entrance for dignitaries.

If you could open and go through the main doors it would lead to a staircase leading up to the main hall.

One change may be to replace the locks on the big doors so that you could not open them from outside and effectively go around the security screen.

Troubling is that what you could do is just open those doors or go in as someone comes out and there would only be one guard and the stairs between you and the hall where the shoot-out happened. At the top of those stairs there would be more guards and that is likely near where this happened -- the hall of honour is right in front and leads to the Library at the back. There are corridors leading to both sides and right off one of those are the caucus rooms.

So my guess is he went through the front door bypassing the security and of course was seen doing so by the guards at the top of the stairs and that would have been the first burst of gunfire as they would have challenged him. He may have taken cover right near the caucus doors and there the final shootout would have happened.

 

nicky

Twitter response to Mulcair's address overwhelmingly positive.
Much scepticism concerning long delay by Trudeau and comments to effect that it is being rewritten because of Mulcair's message

NDPP
NDPP

Combat Aircraft Over Canada After Shootings

http://www.legitgov.org/Combat-aircraft-over-Canada-after-shootings

onlinediscountanvils

[url=http://www.mediacoop.ca/story/gunmen-ottawa-questioning-canadian-militar... in Ottawa: Questioning Canadian militarism[/url] by Stefan Christoff

let's recall the grassroots response across Spain to the 2004 train bombings in Madrid: instead of calling for military revenge, countless thousands took to the streets for anti-war protests, demanding that Spain stop participating in the US military campaign in Iraq, a demand that quickly built momentum and was eventually won, even working toward the political downfall of the conservative government in Spain at the time.

laine lowe laine lowe's picture

Thanks for that link, OLDA.

I was thinking about Azanar and the backlash he faced after the Atocha bombing. Mind you, Madrid and Barcelona had record breaking anti-Iraq invasion protest marches that Azanar chose to ignore in his support of Bush's war on Terriers.

Stockholm

As I recall, the backlash against Aznar that cost him the election was that he prematurely tried to blame the Atocha bombing in ETA the Basque separatists...and that was quickly proven to be false and so it looked like he was opportunistically trying to use the bombing for political gain.

NorthReport

Unfortunately our war-mongering prime minister has made a serious contribution to what happened today in Ottawa.

Tomorrow there are going to be 2 reactions from Canadians.

Hopefully the one that wants us to go back to our peacekeeping role, and go through the UN will win out. 

It is going to be a knock-down, no holds, take no prisoner approach by the right-wing, so it is going to take some serious courage to oppose them.

I also think the internet, our 24/7 news cycle, showing beheading, etc. is partly to blame as well. 

NorthReport

According to this report there were 2 people in the vehicle.

And so it begins.

Firsthand accounts of fatal Ottawa shooting: ‘There was a very real sense that nothing will ever be the same again’

http://news.nationalpost.com/2014/10/22/there-was-a-very-real-sense-that...

 

NorthReport

Probably, but an excellent question nevertheless.

Is it too early to ask for a sane conversation about terrorism?

The sight of our Parliament buildings under attack is a horrifying one. Sadly, it's likely to rally support for the Harper government’s decision to send warplanes to attack Islamic State in Iraq. It shouldn’t. Yes, there's a strong temptation now to ramp up our anger and vow that we won’t back down until Islamic State is obliterated. And that kind of anger is very satisfying — even if it is exactly the response IS militants are aiming for in their…

http://www.ipolitics.ca/2014/10/22/is-it-too-early-to-ask-for-a-sane-con...

 

NorthReport

Ottawa shooting: Harper, Mulcair speak about attack 

Prime Minister Stephen Harper and Opposition Leader Tom Mulcairgave speeches Wednesday evening in the wake of a shooting on ...

 

Debater

nicky wrote:
Twitter response to Mulcair's address overwhelmingly positive. Much scepticism concerning long delay by Trudeau and comments to effect that it is being rewritten because of Mulcair's message

Do you always have to imply something negative about Trudeau?  Even at times like this?

Trudeau was in lockdown all day - including when he had to make his speech.  There was a delay because they had to connect a conference call phone into the area where Justin Trudeau was still in lockdown.

Trudeau gave a good speech too and Andrew Coyne, Justin Ling and others are saying on Twitter that all leaders conducted themselves well today under these difficult circumstances.

NorthReport

Doesn't this kinda remind you of yourself earlier on today when you started taking pot shots at Jason Kenney?

Why don't you just back off a bit and give the partisan crap a break, eh!

Debater wrote:

nicky wrote:
Twitter response to Mulcair's address overwhelmingly positive. Much scepticism concerning long delay by Trudeau and comments to effect that it is being rewritten because of Mulcair's message

Do you always have to imply something negative about Trudeau?  Even at times like this?

Trudeau was in lockdown all day - including when he had to make his speech.  There was a delay because they had to connect a conference call phone into the area where Justin Trudeau was still in lockdown.

Trudeau gave a good speech too and Andrew Coyne, Justin Ling and others are saying on Twitter that all leaders conducted themselves well today under these difficult circumstances.

Debater

I came to comment positively on the speeches of all 3 leaders and their attempt to put partisianship aside and speak to Canadians.  I was responding to one poster who seemed to be trying to score political points by posting misleading comments above about Trudeau.

Trudeau was in lockdown for longer than any of the other leaders.  Mulcair was able to leave earlier and had more time to get to a studio.  Trudeau was not able to do so until after Mulcair.

Anyway, on a positive note, here is the CTV Link to Trudeau's speech:

http://www.ctvnews.ca/video?clipId=474614&playlistId=1.2065440&binId=1.8...

NorthReport
NorthReport

Ottawa shooting: B.C. MLAs were warned of possible security threat

B.C. premier orders full review of security at B.C. Legislature after soldier killed in Ottawa shooting

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/ottawa-shooting-b-c-mlas-...

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

Jason Kenney's tweet was disgraceful and deserved the widespread condemnation it got. I don't go in for partisanship but politicizing should definitely be on the table. Otherwise all this bullshit tak about ISIS and "Canada will not be intimidated" goes unchallenged when it should be called out immediately, if not pre-empted.

If we are against militarization of our country (and we should be) we need to stick to our guns now more than ever. Because we are right. Now, more than ever.

Pages

Topic locked