Rachel Notley & Mike Layton Conflicting Views On Climate Change

9 posts / 0 new
Last post
Mighty Middle
Rachel Notley & Mike Layton Conflicting Views On Climate Change

Toronto’s Mike Layton is bringing a motion to city council this week asking for a report on the cost implications of climate change for Toronto and “any legal avenues to pursue compensation for those costs from major greenhouse gas emitters.”

“Just like tobacco companies knew their products caused cancer, but hid that information from the public, major oil companies have known for decades that their products would cause climate change,” the motion reads. “As tobacco companies have been held accountable for the health-care costs associated with smoking, big polluters should have to pay their fair share for building a climate-safe city.”

UCP Leader Jason Kenney took the move as a direct attack on Alberta’s energy industry, publicly posting a four-page letter addressed to Toronto Mayor John Tory on Tuesday.

Hours later, NDP Leader Rachel Notley also condemned Layton’s motion, writing on Twitter that “it’s clear Mike Layton is out of touch with Canada’s economic reality and doesn’t see Alberta’s contributions because he has tunnel vision.”

She added that Layton would be “wise to read the federal budget and see exactly what Alberta contributes to Confederation.”

Layton wrote on Twitter Tuesday that his motion has been “taken out of context,” adding that he’s simply asking for a report on climate-change costs and options for recouping them. A spokesperson from his office said he was not available for an interview Wednesday, as Toronto city council is in an all-day meeting.

Full text to article at link

https://www.thestar.com/calgary/2019/03/27/one-thing-the-alberta-ucp-and...

bekayne

There's an Alberta election thread.

Pondering

I don't really care about what Notley had to say. I think Layton's motion is much more interesting and it's a valid argument. 

May I suggest alternate the title to something that stresses recouping costs of climate change?

Sean in Ottawa

Pondering wrote:

I don't really care about what Notley had to say. I think Layton's motion is much more interesting and it's a valid argument. 

May I suggest alternate the title to something that stresses recouping costs of climate change?

The bias and purpose of the poster is often placed in the thread title. Most threads are dominated by the poster being either pro- or anti- NDP. This comes from a poster with the mission of exposing any divison or problem with the NDP possible. It can be contrasted with the rah-rah NDP threads.

I wish there was a little more focus on the ideas than the horse race stuff but it seems most threads are dominated by the horse race almost like a sports team. It gets in the way of honest conversation about the parties. I cannot say the thread title s are wrong becuase they are an accurate reflection on the fact that the comments also skew the same way with a minority on policy and principle and a majority on proclaiming partisan ship before anything else.

Mighty Middle

Sean in Ottawa wrote:

The bias and purpose of the poster is often placed in the thread title.

Title changed - will follow this lead in the future

swallow swallow's picture

You could just call all your threads "division in NDP!" 

Misfit Misfit's picture

Sean,

you made only one slight mistake. He is a Liberal shill. He is not pro anything NDP. He is like Tokyo Rose only to promote trouble and doom for the NDP.

 

it is best for everyone just to ignore this and every other thread of his. That is the only way for him to stop - to get discouraged and leave.

Sean in Ottawa

Misfit wrote:

Sean,

you made only one slight mistake. He is a Liberal shill. He is not pro anything NDP. He is like Tokyo Rose only to promote trouble and doom for the NDP.

 

it is best for everyone just to ignore this and every other thread of his. That is the only way for him to stop - to get discouraged and leave.

Sorry if I was not clear -- not just this poster. His posts are all pro Liberal anti-NDP but we also have posters who create threads and put clearly NDP-biased thread titles on them.

Two sides of the same coin really.

Mighty Middle

Misfit - Please take your own advice when it comes to any and all of my posts in the future to

Misfit wrote:

just to ignore this and every other thread of his. That is the only way for him to stop - to get discouraged and leave.

Thanks in advance, much appreciated.