Machjo
rabble-rouser-machine
Member: 16965
Joined: Jan 10 2009

Judaism ≠ Zionism

Though I oppose Zionism, I think there are approapriate ways of going about it, and publishing the statement above would be a wonderful way of doing to.

We do need to keep it clearly separated from anti-semitism. I remember reading one article recently of a protest in which one man was approached by a protestor and called a 'F***ing Jew.' He did support Zionism, but that's still not a reason to intimidate him and insult him as a Jew. Such actions only hurt the cause of justice in Israel, because then Zionists use such incidents to effect, make sure they get published, and thus can successfully portray the other side as anti-semite. Very effective PR on their side.

From a PR standpoint, I think it would make more sense, especially for non-Jews, to limit protests to petitions, letter-writing campaigns, and ideally even educational programmes, either at schools, in living-rooms, or in public libraries, but certainly not by intimidation and calling people 'F***ing Jew'. There are ways of doing it without attracting accusations of anti-semitism to ourselves, and I think publishing the statement above is definitely an effective way of doing so. It's conservative, in good taste, and yet gets the message across clearly while distancing itself emphatically from anti-Semitism at the same time.


Canadian Jews condemn suppression of criticism of Israel By: Unionist (132 replies) March 15, 2009 - 2:34pm
  • Cueball wrote:[ I just By: Star Spangled Canadian (Mar 16 2009 - 2:58pm)
  • Cueball wrote:He has made By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 2:48pm)
  • Re: Canadian Jews condemn suppression of criticism of Israel By: Cueball (Mar 16 2009 - 2:42pm)
  • Cueball wrote:I find these By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 2:37pm)
  • Caissa wrote:I'm a betting By: Cueball (Mar 16 2009 - 2:27pm)
  • All right, Caissa and By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 2:25pm)
  • Unionist wrote: My second By: aka Mycroft (Mar 16 2009 - 2:20pm)
  • Re: Canadian Jews condemn suppression of criticism of Israel By: Caissa (Mar 16 2009 - 2:19pm)
  • At least we're not By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 2:18pm)
  • Re: Canadian Jews condemn suppression of criticism of Israel By: Caissa (Mar 16 2009 - 2:17pm)
  • Star Spangled Canadian By: Cueball (Mar 16 2009 - 2:18pm)
  • Naci_Sey, I sniffed around By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 2:08pm)
  • Re: Canadian Jews condemn suppression of criticism of Israel By: Naci_Sey (Mar 16 2009 - 11:05am)
  • Sid Ryan doesn't seem to By: Stockholm (Mar 16 2009 - 9:32am)
  • Michelle wrote: Actually, I By: Star Spangled Canadian (Mar 16 2009 - 9:21am)
  • aka Mycroft wrote: Star By: Star Spangled Canadian (Mar 16 2009 - 9:18am)
  • Michelle, I agree with you. By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 8:56am)
  • Actually, I agree with those By: Michelle (Mar 16 2009 - 8:36am)
  • My second healthy laugh of By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 8:32am)
  • Star Spangled Canadian By: aka Mycroft (Mar 16 2009 - 8:30am)
  • That may be true, SSC, but By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 8:30am)
  • Naturei karta are a "shanda By: Star Spangled Canadian (Mar 16 2009 - 8:11am)
  • DrConway wrote:Where were By: Unionist (Mar 16 2009 - 7:26am)
  • Where were these people 20 By: DrConway (Mar 16 2009 - 3:16am)
  • http://nswas.org/ Yet By: Machjo (Mar 15 2009 - 6:56pm)
  • http://www.nkusa.org/ Anothe By: Machjo (Mar 15 2009 - 6:41pm)
  • Re: Canadian Jews condemn suppression of criticism of Israel By: RevolutionPlease (Mar 15 2009 - 6:41pm)
  • Judaism ≠ ZionismThough I By: Machjo (Mar 15 2009 - 6:40pm)
  • It may surprise people to By: Stockholm (Mar 15 2009 - 6:48pm)
  • Well, the Globe's refusal to By: sgm (Mar 15 2009 - 6:33pm)
  • I too have read this letter By: Eliezer Zusken (Mar 15 2009 - 5:47pm)
  • Re: Canadian Jews condemn suppression of criticism of Israel By: remind (Mar 15 2009 - 5:20pm)
  • I will agree with contents By: Skinny Dipper (Mar 15 2009 - 5:06pm)
  • I have read the op and By: Red T-shirt (Mar 15 2009 - 4:04pm)
  • Blogged. And the "news" and By: Naci_Sey (Mar 15 2009 - 3:14pm)