As the world debates the climate crisis and it's solutions in Copenhagen, Albertans are being asked to take command of their own contribution to global greenhouse gas emissions. In his new book, Green Oil [2], Satya Das believes Albertans need to take charge of their own backyard. Green Oil asserts that Albertans can take the tar sands and develop them in a sustainable manner while generating profit to dedicate to green energy alternatives.
"They are a $15 trillion dollar resource, where we have to share two thirds of our resource extraction with the Americans because the free trade deal. So it's going to be developed one way or the other. We should at least develop it responsibly within a context of environmental responsibility."
Das has been working with the government relations group Cambridge Strategies, an organization he founded, to advise on government relations, strategy and policy development. He became interested in writing Green Oil when he saw all the government reports on the Alberta tar sands with very little citizen input.
"I wrote it out of frustration more than anything. Through all the government studies and reports there is not a lot of voice from citizens. And when it came to government acting on those reports there was not a lot of movement."
But that doesn't give much hope to Das' main recommendation being implemented. Das outlines in his book that profits from the tar sands should be put toward a natural resource severance tax to be invested in green technologies.
Alberta's history of increasing corporate taxes on their main resource money maker is not in Das' favour. With current corporate subsidies, investment in carbon capture and storage, and consistently low royalty rates the Alberta government has put a lot of money in to make sure the tar sands are kept alive. Even when most of Alberta pushed for higher royalty rates and a government commissioned report recommended higher rates, the Stelmach government implemented the minimum recommendations leaving Alberta's royalty take as one of the lowest in the world. The Parkland Institute, a progressive thinktank, believes Albertans will miss out on over five billion dollars in the next three years due to the government's lack of strong action to increase the rates. and increased royalty rates.
"The government does act with an air of caution. The political leadership are scared of the tenants leaving." But Das believes it's time for that mentality to end. "We should call the bluff of those not willing to change and take their leases. If you don't want to develop in a responsible manner then you can leave. Alberta citizens are the landlords and business are the tenants. If the tenants don't like the conditions we set they have to leave." Das believes citizens should take their rightful place as owners of the resource.
"Government are just the managers, business are the tenants and citizens are the ones with control. And tenants have to realize they're not the ones we can do business with." Das is firm Albertans must control who is coming in the tar sands door. "Albertans have the absolute right to set the rules and terms under which we'll accept tenants."
With Copenhagen talks underway, the world will be watching what Alberta and Canada are doing. "It's essential we make the shift. We're being completely irresponsible to the climate and to democracy."--Samantha Power
Samantha Power is an Edmonton-based writer and broadcaster and intern at rabble.ca.
This review was first published in VUE Weekly.
Links:
[1] http://rabble.ca/sites/rabble/files/node-images/GreenOilCover.jpg
[2] http://greenoilbook.com
[3] http://rabble.ca/print/books/reviews/2009/12/go-green-alberta-new-book-says#comment-1091757
[4] http://rabble.ca/print/books/reviews/2009/12/go-green-alberta-new-book-says#comment-1091947
[5] http://rabble.ca/print/books/reviews/2009/12/go-green-alberta-new-book-says#comment-1091958
[6] http://rabble.ca/print/books/reviews/2009/12/go-green-alberta-new-book-says#comment-1093016
[7] http://rabble.ca/print/books/reviews/2009/12/go-green-alberta-new-book-says#comment-1093464
[8] http://rabble.ca/user
[9] http://rabble.ca/user/register
I wonder how this book proposes the tar sands be developed in a sustainable manner. I'll have to check it out. From what I've heard, getting oil out of the tar sands is very energy intensive with no viable way to get around this, so I'd like to hear what this guy has to say.
The tar sands cannot be developed in an ecologically sustainable manner. Even if they could be, they shouldn't. The oil should be left in the ground, not extracted and burned in the pursuit of private profit.
Saying "it's going to be developed one way or the other" is simply giving up on the environment.
As for having to share two-thirds of resource extraction with the US, all it takes is for Canada to tear up the NAFTA agreement. That's no more fanciful a demand than calling on Alberta to get tough with the oil companies that are the backbone of their economy.
It'd be nice to think that Das, at least, has the government's ear on creating a sustainable tar sands industry (an oxymoron, in any case, as the water and energy to extract oil from all that tar make such a project unsustainable, in fact); God knows the rest of those of us who are appalled by the situation, don't.
Missing out on only 5 billion in lost oil royalties over the next few years seems a pittance to the hundreds of billions we've apparently already lost through our government's morally corrupt mismanagement of the oil and water resources. Norway (an oil industry said to be akin ours in terms of size and diffculty of extraction) has put slightly over 400 BILLION in their sovereign fund, while Alberta only has something between $14 and 17 billion.
Since the majority of Albertans can't be bothered to feel outrage over this situation, I see no healthy future for this province, whatsoever.
Dear Folks, can the tar sands be seeded with bacteria to produce methane? http://www.innovations-report.com/html/reports/energy_engineering/report-43773.html
OK, I will answer my question ..... no, so far, the oil ideally must be waxy for the bacteria to turn it into methane.