Haiti’s post-earthquake disaster is setting powerful social forces in motion towards change
Tectonic Shifts: Haiti After the Earthquake; editors Mark Schuller and Pablo Morales; Kumarian Press, 271 pp, January 2012
This review was first published in the August 2012 issue of NACLA (quarterly print journal and website).
Tectonic Shifts is a vital account of the 2010 earthquake in Haiti. The book is a collection of 46 articles and essays by leading Haitian and international activists, scholars and writers who are on the front lines of the struggle for meaningful relief and reconstruction.
Through Tectonic’s pages, we meet key actors among the army of Haitian people and international supporters who have toiled in unimaginable difficulties since the earthquake to save lives, bring comfort and rebuild a shattered country. We learn of the intense political and class struggle that is determining in whose interests the future Haiti will be guided and governed, a dynamic story shifting wrenchingly from one day’s news to the next.
In view of the limited and sharply criticized outcomes of the reconstruction effort to date, the book amounts to an urgent call for action and change.
In their introduction, editors Mark Schuller and Pablo Morales pay tribute to the Haitian community tradition of youn ede lòt (helping one another). “…The first emergency response came from the people themselves: Complete strangers pulling out children or the elderly half-buried under slabs of concrete. Neighbours pooling together what scraps of food, utensils, charcoal and water they could find, sleeping next to one another on the ground…this was the story of how the Haitian people put away their economic and political differences and worked together, in dignity and solidarity, to collectively survive.”
Youn ede lòt* was ever-present in the earthquake zone in those early weeks and then months. Its overarching presence was under-reported, a startling contrast to the lurid stories of chaos and social violence that were invented by much of the international media. Haiti was said to be perched on a razor wire–on one side loomed descent into mayhem, on the other were the saving arms of foreign military and aid agencies.
In reality, time and experience is proving that the Haitian people are the ultimate wellspring on which all hope for the future of the country rests. So how has relief and reconstruction stacked up? Tectonic Shifts details how ordinary Haitians have been frozen out of planning and decision-making processes that are flawed or do not even exist.
The first third of the book explains how Haiti got to be so vulnerable to an earthquake whose geophysical force was far less than contemporary eruptions yet whose human consequences were catastrophic. “Like the motion of tectonic plates, Haiti’s disaster needs to be examined as a larger process, involving geopolitical structures and transnational tensions,” explain the editors.
The book includes a brief examination of Haiti’s 210-year, post-independence history, specifically how the country was made to be poor by policies of the big, imperial powers of the world. Focusing on recent decades, several essays examine how foreign, non-governmental organizations have become ubiquitous to the provision of social needs that are rightfully the preserve and responsibility of national governments. Haitian Professor Janil Lwijis (who died tragically hours before the earthquake struck) writes, “NGOs manage aid to develop capital in the heart and spirit of the poor masses–in other words, to disable workers.”
Post-earthquake social conditions receive a large treatment in the book and tell a troubling tale. Residents of the vast camps of earthquake survivors that sprung up were thrust into a struggle for daily survival. Everything was and remains in short supply--potable water, sanitation and washing stations, food, employment and other constructive social engagement. We hear from camp residents and from lawyers and housing rights activists of the battles over these past two years for the human rights and dignity of camp residents.
Hardship intensified following the reckless and unbelievable introduction of cholera to Haiti in October 2010 via the soldiers of the UN military occupation force. The sanitation and potable drinking water deficit bequeathed to Haiti by decades of neo-colonial neglect and interference became deadlier than most could have imagined.
Several chapters of Tectonic Shifts address the difficult conditions of women and girls. In Haiti, women bear the large share of responsibility for child-rearing and keeping Haitian households together. A 2009 film, Poto Mitan, co-produced by editor Mark Schuller tells this story. Haiti’s earthquake not only killed people and destroyed buildings, it also ruptured the social ties of family and neighborhood that sustain life and protect women and girls from the violence and discrimination of class society. (A comprehensive report on womens’ rights additional to those reports cited in the book is ‘Nobody Remembers Us’, by Human Rights Watch, August 2011.)
Is there an alternative course for post-earthquake assistance and a future for Haiti? This question is addressed in the final third of the book. The remarkable, final resolution of an international forum on housing that took place nearly one year ago in Haiti is published. It contains the essential elements of the housing program urgently needed and still almost entirely absent. It concludes, “We resolve to regain the sovereignty of our country in order to construct a society in which we can enjoy guaranteed access to housing and all our fundamental rights.”
An essay by Fritz Deshommes, founder of the Haitian Association of Economists, explains that Haiti’s progressive Constitution of 1987 is an excellent guide for rebuilding the country, notably its guarantees of social rights, including housing. What’s needed, he writes, is, “a true re-foundation of the state and nation.”
The book describes the two-round national election of November 2010/March 2011 that brought Michel Martelly to the presidency. That election was a definitive sign that the mea-culpas expressed by the large foreign powers in Haiti following the earthquake over their destructive policies of the past are next to meaningless. They funded and pressed upon Haiti an election in which he country’s most vital and representative political actors were excluded, including the Fanmi Lavalas party of former President Jean-Bertrand Aristide. The majority of the electorate itself was effectively excluded.
Incredibly, one year after this electoral exercise, Haiti has no effective government. The country is lacking key ministries, such as housing. The elected president wants to entrench for paramilitaries and former death squad leaders into national life.
The data contained in the latest monthly report (April 2012) of the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs of the UN (OCHA) updates the ongoing emergency in Haiti that is documented in Tectonic Shifts:
- The report laments that many of the NGOs in Haiti operate outside of any coordination and accounting.
- Aid funding is drying up. Of the $238 million said to be needed for emergency aid (Consolidated Appeal Process) in 2012, only $22 million, nine per cent, has been delivered. CAP funding in 2011 was $211 million, 55 per cent of the declared goal.
- Some 14,000 houses have been repaired and more than 5,000 built since the earthquake, says the report. But that accounts for only ten per cent of damaged or destroyed buildings. And these of dwellings of homeowners, whereas the vast majority of dwellers in Port au Prince are renters or squatters. Six hundred thousand people are still living in the camps while hundreds of thousands more are living in damaged buildings or informal, unserviced settlements.
- Cholera remains a deadly threat as the rainy, spring season commences.
Tectonic Shifts offers no polyannish prescriptions for Haiti. A hard struggle lies ahead if the country is to find a path of renewal and human development. But hope springs from its pages and from mounting evidence of renewal.
Grassroots social and political movements are growing and their voices are rising. An example is the legal suit against the United Nations over the introduction of cholera. The justice of that case is recognized by all but the most hardened and blinded of Security Council officials and sycophants.
Peasant organizations are alive and on the move to place agricultural development at the center of national planning.
The exclusion election of 2010/11 and the weak, unrepresentative government it produced may soon run its course. The door is opening to a new round of struggle for democracy and representative government.
In March, new agreements with Cuba, Venezuela and other Latin American countries will see new or expanded programs in housing, health care, literacy, electrical and fuel provision, reforestation and agriculture.
Internationally, an important Haiti solidarity movement remains active and vigilant, giving voice to the aspirations of the Haitian people.
More tectonic shifts are on the agenda in Haiti, this time in the social and political realm. They are too powerful to resist. Their path is sketched out in this important book.
* A powerful description of youn ede lòt in action was recently written by Toronto Star reporter Catherine Porter and published in the newspaper's Saturday edition of July 28, 2012.
Roger Annis is a coordinator of the Canada Haiti Action Network and resides in Vancouver. He directed an observation mission to Haiti in June 2011 and wrote several articles and reports on its findings.
Thank you for reading this story…
More people are reading rabble.ca than ever and unlike many news organizations, we have never put up a paywall – at rabble we’ve always believed in making our reporting and analysis free to all, while striving to make it sustainable as well. Media isn’t free to produce. rabble’s total budget is likely less than what big corporate media spend on photocopying (we kid you not!) and we do not have any major foundation, sponsor or angel investor. Our main supporters are people and organizations -- like you. This is why we need your help. You are what keep us sustainable.
rabble.ca has staked its existence on you. We live or die on community support -- your support! We get hundreds of thousands of visitors and we believe in them. We believe in you. We believe people will put in what they can for the greater good. We call that sustainable.
So what is the easy answer for us? Depend on a community of visitors who care passionately about media that amplifies the voices of people struggling for change and justice. It really is that simple. When the people who visit rabble care enough to contribute a bit then it works for everyone.
And so we’re asking you if you could make a donation, right now, to help us carry forward on our mission. Make a donation today.