Questions of identity and the recognition of a Jewish state

Please chip in to support more articles like this. Support in its summer fundraiser today for as little as $1 per month!

Questions are generally superior to answers because they open discussion up; potential responses radiate in many directions. Answers have their virtues: they let you get on with it, whatever it is. But they close discussion down and make life less interesting. So, at Passover seders -- the ritual meal Jews held this week to mark Passover, the anniversary of liberation from slavery in ancient Egypt -- things begin with the youngest child asking four questions: Why is this night different from all others? Etc. The rest of the night is a verbose, rambling response that never answers the questions but raises many fascinating issues.

Here's another question in the same ballpark: Who is a Jew? Talk about radiating. Is it the member of a religion? Hardly, many Jews are atheists. A race or ethnicity? Those categories are vague and shifting, plus Jews can convert in, which you can't to a quasi-physical demographic. A culture? There are too many versions and it's unstable. A people? OK, but then: what kind? Those of us who've had the discussion often and unsuccessfully, know you'll never get an answer but you'll know more afterwards and you'll feel smarter. Anyone who'd try to shut it down with a simple answer is either a fool or a troublemaker.

That's the situation the current Israeli government is in. They say they won't make peace with the Palestinian co-inhabitants of the country unless they're acknowledged as a Jewish state. The Palestinians say, more or less: Not our problem. We'll recognize you as a legitimate state but we're not getting into that jackpot, you can hash out the definition yourselves. The result is stalemate, which has always looked like Israel's goal. They keep finding ways to avoid the obvious solution: two states with international security guarantees. This is merely their latest way to evade it, while continuing to expand and colonize. But it's a brilliant move, since everyone knows the question will never be settled.

I mean, how would you do it? Take it to court? Courts are terrible places to deal with complex moral matters. Think of Rob Ford saying the issues about his behaviour are over since he hasn't (yet) been criminally charged. Stephen Harper may try the same ploy regarding the Duffy payoff. Large questions of right, wrong and responsibility are poorly handled in narrow contexts like courts. That's why it's generally in the interest of the powerful -- Ford, Harper, Israel's government -- to keep discussion narrow and restrict it to yes-no answers. Nothing's more obnoxious than someone hectoring someone else by saying: It's a simple question: answer yes or no. You see it on TV panels all the time. Ugh.

In fact the very existence of a "normal" state for Jews, whoever they are, by itself tends to reduce the resonances of their Jewishness since it's a sort of answer to that question. If "We are One," as the signs outside the synagogues say, then "we" are less multi-faceted and indefinable.

Consider Passover. Images like slaves to Pharaoh or crossing the Jordan river to the promised land once echoed broadly and ricocheted through other cultures. African-Americans, for instance, used those images to help create a rich new culture from a tragic past. Those millennia of Jewish life in exile were fruitful, not just painful. But when the very same words -- Egypt, Jordan -- appear in headlines about modern Israel, it grows easier to treat them literally rather than metaphorically.

I don't mean the narrowing of the Jewish mind toward identification with Israel hasn't generated creativity. Israel has a vital culture, but it's primarily Israeli, not Jewish. Jewish cultural creativity during the millennia in Diaspora wasn't just aided by but dependent on precisely the absence of the defining markers of statehood: borders, a government, police or military to enforce laws and loyalty. Overarching identification with Israel can sap that kind of creativity and leave you a little vacant. You still feel Jewish but it's elusive what that means outside Israel. The height of Jewish culture becomes something like Adam Sandler's The Hanukkah Song. We're Jewish because we're, er, Jewish.

This raises other questions. Was there any alternative to Israel? Can there be exile without mortal risk? Etc. Great questions -- and unanswerable.

This article was first published in the Toronto Star.

Photo: JAFI Israel/flickr

Related Items

Thank you for reading this story…

More people are reading than ever and unlike many news organizations, we have never put up a paywall – at rabble we’ve always believed in making our reporting and analysis free to all, while striving to make it sustainable as well. Media isn’t free to produce. rabble’s total budget is likely less than what big corporate media spend on photocopying (we kid you not!) and we do not have any major foundation, sponsor or angel investor. Our main supporters are people and organizations -- like you. This is why we need your help. You are what keep us sustainable. has staked its existence on you. We live or die on community support -- your support! We get hundreds of thousands of visitors and we believe in them. We believe in you. We believe people will put in what they can for the greater good. We call that sustainable.

So what is the easy answer for us? Depend on a community of visitors who care passionately about media that amplifies the voices of people struggling for change and justice. It really is that simple. When the people who visit rabble care enough to contribute a bit then it works for everyone.

And so we’re asking you if you could make a donation, right now, to help us carry forward on our mission. Make a donation today.


We welcome your comments! embraces a pro-human rights, pro-feminist, anti-racist, queer-positive, anti-imperialist and pro-labour stance, and encourages discussions which develop progressive thought. Our full comment policy can be found here. Learn more about Disqus on and your privacy here. Please keep in mind:


  • Tell the truth and avoid rumours.
  • Add context and background.
  • Report typos and logical fallacies.
  • Be respectful.
  • Respect copyright - link to articles.
  • Stay focused. Bring in-depth commentary to our discussion forum, babble.


  • Use oppressive/offensive language.
  • Libel or defame.
  • Bully or troll.
  • Post spam.
  • Engage trolls. Flag suspect activity instead.