How racism affects health

6 posts / 0 new
Last post
Maysie Maysie's picture
How racism affects health

 

Maysie Maysie's picture

This article, a year old, was just brought to my attention. Very interesting. This level of validation could possible lead to social change in how health services are provided, which would be wonderful.

quote:

African-Americans today, despite a half century of economic and social progress since the civil rights movement, face a higher risk than any other racial group of dying from heart disease, diabetes, stroke, and hypertension. In the United States, affluent blacks suffer, on average, more health problems than the poorest whites.

(snip)

In the early 1980s, Duke University social psychologist Sherman James, introduced his now-classic "John Henryism" hypothesis. The name comes from the legendary 19th-century "steel-driving" railroad worker who competed against a mechanical steam drill and won -- only to drop dead from what today would probably be diagnosed as a massive stroke or heart attack. In James's work, people who churn out prodigious physical and mental effort to cope with chronic life stresses are said to score high on John Henryism. James showed that blacks with high John Henryism but low socioeconomic position pay a physical price, with higher rates of blood pressure and hypertension.

Racism, other research suggests, acts as a classic chronic stressor, setting off the same physiological train wreck as job strain or marital conflict: higher blood pressure, elevated heart rate, increases in the stress hormone cortisol, suppressed immunity.

(snip)

In the mid-1980s scientists began to take advantage of the controlled conditions of the laboratory. When African-American volunteers are hooked up to blood-pressure monitors, for example, and then exposed to a racially provocative vignette on tape or TV -- such as a white store clerk calling a black customer a racist epithet -- the volunteers' blood pressures rise, their heart rates jump, and they take longer than normal to recover from both reactions. Perhaps, scientists reasoned, the effort of a lifetime of bracing for such threats prolongs the effect.

More recently, the lab has moved out into the real world. Several investigations have linked blood pressure to real-time experiences of stress and discrimination as recorded in electronic diaries. In one yet-to-be-published study, Elizabeth Brondolo, a psychologist at St. John's University, found that daytime experiences of racism led to elevated nighttime blood pressure, suggesting that the body couldn't turn off its stress response.

(snip)

Despite these suggestive findings, the field remains beset by unknowns. One of the biggest problems is that researchers don't share a concrete, agreed-upon definition of racial discrimination -- partly because such prejudice takes myriad forms. They also don't know if more exposure to racism produces more disease or if, instead, disease sets in only after a threshold has been passed. They don't know if exposures during certain periods of life are more risky than others. And they don't know why some victims cope better than others.


[url=http://www.boston.com/news/globe/ideas/articles/2007/07/15/how_racism_hu..."How Racism Hurts -- Literally" Boston Globe July 2007[/url]

ElizaQ ElizaQ's picture

Thanks BCG it's an interesting article. To me the just seems like common sense connection, with knowing what I do about the physiological functions of stress and it's consequences on health in general and considering what I would hope would be obvious to most that dealing with racism is both stressful and emotional on many levels.
It's good of course to have studies and research to back this up so at least theres some quantifiable 'proof' for those that need that.

I agree that validation is important and this type of research could add or better said should add another piece as to why it needs to be dealt with. I look at this in terms of the human moral and ethical level but I can also see how this could also lead to arguments based only on the economic terms for those that don't care a whit about the morality of it or even that it has anything to do with them.

Maysie Maysie's picture

quote:


ElizaQ: what I would hope would be obvious to most that dealing with racism is both stressful and emotional on many levels.

Ah, ElizaQ! I've hoped that myself for many years, and so far, SFA. So for me, this kind of validation, from a field that I wouldn't think of as a place to get helpful information on this issue, is positive.

And yes, of course so much is common sense, for those of us who deal with it, and have loved ones and friends and family who deal with it every day.

And in terms of economic ways to get idiot racists on board, I find the tactic tends to be "improved worker production output" crappola. That really sells it. [img]rolleyes.gif" border="0[/img]

ElizaQ ElizaQ's picture

quote:


Originally posted by bigcitygal:
[b]

And in terms of economic ways to get idiot racists on board, I find the tactic tends to be "improved worker production output" crappola. That really sells it. [img]rolleyes.gif" border="0[/img] [/b]


Yeah that's the type of stuff I was getting at but I couldn't bring myself to actually write it. [img]smile.gif" border="0[/img]
Another could, "Well as a taxpayer it's costing you money due to increase burden on the health care system and dealing with it will reduce costs yadda yadda" *ick*

lagatta

I remember reading that West African people from the regions most Black people in the Americas were stolen from have very low rates of high blood pressure - even though in many ways their lives are much harder.