State of the European Left, June 09

9 posts / 0 new
Last post
jimbabwe
State of the European Left, June 09

In parallel with observations of growing influence of right-wing, nationalist movements in Europe, here are a couple of articles that express negative sentiment about the state of the left in Europe.  One is from the Wall Street Journal, while the other is from the World Socialist Web Site.

 

1) An article in the Wall Street Journal about the bad standing of left-leaning parties at the national level in various European countries:

WSJ: 'Across Europe, Left-Leaning Parties See Clout Faltering'

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124425154944290829.html

Some of the analysis I found lacking, such as:

'"The WTO marked the triumph of the market economy," says Dominique Reynié, head of Paris-based Foundation for Political Innovation. "Since then, the left has been unable to propose another route."'

But the run-down on recent history of left-wing parties in Europe, and their current standing, was informative, and this was interesting:

'Some fear that the inability of many European left-wing parties to attract voters is a cause -- not just a symptom -- of a rise among parties on the far right. "When people fear that they are not protected by their governments, they go back to nationalism," said Anthony Wedgwood Benn, a retired U.K. Socialist lawmaker.'

 

2) Commentary on the confused messages coming from the left-wing national parties that together make up the "European Left" in the European Union parliament, whose most recent elections will conclude this weekend: 'Election platform of the “European Left”: Pious wishes and right-wing policies'

http://www.wsws.org/articles/2009/jun2009/euro-j06.shtml

Interesting excerpts:

'Is the financial and economic crisis rooted in the contradictions of the capitalist system, or is it merely the result of an incorrect policy? Is it possible to renew the existing institutions and organisations—the European Union, national parliaments, the social democratic parties and trade unions—in the interest of workers, or must the working class organise itself independently and develop its own social and political alternative?'

'When carefully considered, the essence of the European Left platform is to promote the illusion that it is possible to achieve a more socially balanced and just European Union. Based on this appeal, the European Left hopes to win a greater acceptance for capitalist institutions in the European population as a whole.'

 

Together these pieces suggest to me that the left in Europe, overburdened with its internal contradictions, is failing to fill the void of credibility that the financial crisis has presented, while the forces of the right are proving much more able at exploiting this opportunity.

Jacob Richter

The mainstream European left pursued neoliberal policies in the 1990s and early 2000s.  Working-class voters are punishing them with abstentions, spoilages, and even votes for far-right parties.

The answer for European workers is class struggle, and that can only be conducted by workers constituting themselves into their own political party distinct from, and opposed to, the parties of the propertied classes and also the various "reformist" parties.

For my part, I suggest a critical, tactical vote for the Party of the European Left.

jimbabwe

Interesting. 

The World Socialist Web Site article I referenced makes a distinction between mainstream left parties (the "social democratic parties" and another set of left parties, the "European Left," which describe themselves as socialist or communist.

The commentary holds that the messaging coming from this second group is politically ambiguous, suggesting that the problem goes farther than simply the "mainstream" left.

Jacob Richter

The WSWS is published by the highly sectarian ICFI.

BetterRed

"The mainstream European left pursued neoliberal policies in the 1990s and early 2000s.  Working-class voters are punishing them with abstentions, spoilages, and even votes for far-right parties."

Seems like the good explanation for this. I would suggest, its also a vote against the EU "Eurocrats", who are often recruited from the social democrats.

 

Just to add more to this topic, Im following the updated results, and yes, indeed in countries where the third way Left have been in power for a while, they are voting massively for center right and the FR.

European Left isnt doing great right now, but is holding steady. Best results for this group is in small-sized, traditionalist countries like Portugal, Greece and Ireland. Stable seat count in Czech rep. as well.

genstrike

Jacob Richter wrote:

The WSWS is published by the highly sectarian ICFI.

It is still not a bad resource for critical analysis of social democrat types and breaking down their platforms.

As for sectarian, it probably is (it is a tiny trot group after all), but I am so sick of intellectual wankers and followers of dear leader Alan Woods saying "everyone is sectarian but us" and getting into a massive intellectual wankstorm over the prospect of who to "work with".  That is, if anyone actually approaches you because no one can stand talking to your tiny sect for more than two minutes and people only buy your shitty pamphlets partially out of pity but mostly to get you to shut up.

</end rant>

Jacob Richter

Given my posts elsewhere, comrade genstrike, you of all people should know about my stance towards the class-collaborationist Alan Woods and sectarians more generally.

BetterRed wrote:
European Left isnt doing great right now, but is holding steady. Best results for this group is in small-sized, traditionalist countries like Portugal, Greece and Ireland. Stable seat count in Czech rep. as well.

The Czech Republic has a constitutional ban on the advocacy of public ownership of the MOP (so much for liberal free speech), so the politics of the EUL affiliate there may be dubious.

Congratulations are in order for Irish workers, and the class-collaborationist Rifondazione needs to fold.

genstrike

fuck, I am so sick of the word sectarian.  Note that it is a word used only on the internet and very rarely in real life.

Sven Sven's picture

It surprises me that people are supporting the Right rather than the Left (in very general terms) in Europe in the throes of an economic crisis.  I thought that this crisis of capitalism would lead to an unstoppable resurgence of the Left.  Although, what may be happening now wouldn't be unprecedented (look at Europe, the Depression, and Fascism in the 1930s).