"Can a busy female politician give reliable evidence? A judge says no" Globe and Mail

6 posts / 0 new
Last post
Maysie Maysie's picture
"Can a busy female politician give reliable evidence? A judge says no" Globe and Mail

I saw this story posted on one of my Facebook friend's news feeds.

Granted, MacLeod is a Conservative MP, and the only parties mentioned are the Liberals and the Cons. Nevertheless, the lesson transcends partisan politics.

My only amusement is that those who don't identify as feminists (the word isn't used once in the article, but this is the Globe and Mail after all) somehow feel like they can simply reap the benefits of hard work from the past, without realizing that education about assumptions about women's roles (and so much more) needs to continue, both now, and into the future.

Quote:

Can a busy female politician give reliable evidence? A judge says no

Lisa MacLeod is a young female politician who commutes to her job at Queen's Park from Ottawa and leaves her husband, Joe, and four-year-old daughter, Victoria, at home. Mr. Justice Douglas Cunningham of Ontario Superior Court said this is a big distraction for the 34-year-old woman and as a result he felt he could not accept her evidence as corroboration of the Crown's key witness in the recent high-profile, influence-peddling trial of Ottawa Mayor Larry O'Brien.

....

"It is unfortunate that any woman in Ms. MacLeod's situation may be regarded as less reliable because of the demands placed on her life as a politician," said Nancy Peckford, national director of Equal Voice, an organization promoting women in public office. "Would the same approach have been taken with a male politician who is commuting and has a young family at home? Probably not."

Link to the full article here, Globe and Mail. Don't read the comments. Just don't.

remind remind's picture

"Would the same approach have been taken with a male politician who is commuting and has a young family at home? Probably not."

Nope it would not have, and it is no wonder women continue to be marginalize when we have a judge saying shit like this.

remind remind's picture

Glad to see there is a huge amount of outrage over this in the public sphere, even though the media on last nights neews did not draw the juxposition that a  34 old man, who commuutes with a wife and child at home, would be considered to be a valid witness.

Also, the thought struck me, that maybe there can be an appeal of said Judges decision regarding the mayor's culpability because of this sexist prejudicial comment.

remind remind's picture

Quote:
Women in public life

Barbara Yaffe, Canwest News Service
Published: Thursday, August 13, 2009

Baby, we've plateaued. Heck, we may even be regressing. The story of women in politics is not a happy one, asserts political scientist Sylvia Bashevkin.

Her new book Women, Power, Politics: The Hidden Story of Canada's Unfinished Democracy has an intriguing thesis: Canadians just aren't comfortable with females in politics.

The reason so few women sit in the House of Commons and provincial legislatures is no more complicated than that.

A "relentless dissection process" is visited upon women, she says, but not on men.

miles

this is jus disgusting. i dont care that the pol in question is a con the fact that her credibility is being questioned because she works, raises a daughter blah blah blah

 

complete bullshit. when a man is busy it is ok, 

 

but what is shocking is how quiet some political insiders are on this.

remind remind's picture

yep