Ontario MPPs - including NDP - condemn Israeli Apartheid Week in Legislature Part II

111 posts / 0 new

Topic locked

Sun, 2010-02-28 02:26

Fidel

Unionist wrote:

Fidel wrote:
But if we've already decided and made up our minds that Dinovo is wrong, and that the NDP is wrong on this for the exact same reasons the other two parties are wrong, well then there isn't much point in discussing it further. Israeli apartheid observance week is where it's at.

But the ONDP leader's letter is pretty good, and it directly condemns the actions of DiNovo (without naming her) and whoever else supported this fascist motion in Queen's Park. So how about recognizing when the ONDP leader Andrea Horwath does something good, while also recognizing when one of its rogue MPPs speaks garbage? Or does that shake things up too much?

Part of the reason that I appear to be an unapologetic supporter of the NDP right or wrong is where this kind of debate about Israel ultimately leads to, which is this movement's calls for embargoing Israel. I can't support that no matter what's happening in Israel or who is wrong or right. Cubans have endured genocidal trade sanctions and illegal blockades of humanitarian aid for many years and under the false guise of promoting democracy in Cuba. I don't agree with using trade and access to crfedit as political weapons under any circumstances. Denying material goods and humanitarian aid to any country is crossing the line into that grey area of political interference. People can't make clear minded political decisions when faced with outside influence amounting to coercion in the extreme. Children don't vote, for example, and their suffering is meaningless.

Sun, 2010-02-28 02:27

#103

NDPP

A Reckoning for Israel by John Pilger

http://www.greenleft.org.au/2010/828/42569

"Palestinian resistance to the theft of their country reached a critical moment in 2001 when Israel was identified as an apartheid state at a UN conference on racism in Durban, South Africa..

Like the South Africa campaign, the issue of law is central. No state is allowed to flout international law as wilfully as Israel..

Keep that in mind when you next watch the mainstream media [or political parties] 'balance' such suffering with the weasel protestations of the oppressors..."

Sun, 2010-02-28 02:45

#104

radiorahim radiorahim's picture

Fidel wrote:

Part of the reason that I appear to be an unapologetic supporter of the NDP right or wrong is where this kind of debate about Israel ultimately leads to, which is this movement's calls for embargoing Israel. I can't support that no matter what's happening in Israel or who is wrong or right. Cubans have endured genocidal trade sanctions and illegal blockades of humanitarian aid for many years and under the false guise of promoting democracy in Cuba. I don't agree with using trade and access to crfedit as political weapons under any circumstances. Denying material goods and humanitarian aid to any country is crossing the line into that grey area of political interference. People can't make clear minded political decisions when faced with outside influence amounting to coercion in the extreme. Children don't vote, for example, and their suffering is meaningless.

So Fidel, did you oppose sanctions against apartheid South Africa? Just curious.

Sun, 2010-02-28 02:58

#105

Fidel

radiorahim wrote:
So Fidel, did you oppose sanctions against apartheid South Africa? Just curious.

Those were decisions by people in the end not to invest in S. Africa and not so much US, Canadian or any other governments. People around the world began asking where their pensions and other funds were being invested. And investment companies reacted by witholding somewhere on the order of $600 billion a year from S. Africa. Neocolonialism is still a problem in Africa in case anyone hasn't noticed.

Israel is a different story altogether. They receive more in US aid every year than all of Africa and South America combined. Israel has been a frontline state in the cold war and now a continuing colder war. The Yanks and Brits aren't going to let Israel fall to democracy anytime soon. I think the left is looking for an easy victory against another apartheid regime, and it's not going to happen this time. The left needs a concentrated laser guided effort toward abating the problem at its source. Israel would be a good prize for the left - but there are bigger fish to fry. Only one way to deal with a bully, and the first goal statement for the left should be to actually identify the bully and main culprit orchestrating imperialism and neocolonialism around the world. That's step number one.

Sun, 2010-02-28 03:21

#106

NDPP

Weekly Report on Israeli Human Rights Violations in the Occupied Territories

http://www.pchrgaza.org/portal/en/index.php?option=com_content&view=arti...

We Must Never Forget Gaza

http://palestinethinktank.com/2010/02/27/khalid-amayreh-we-must-never-fo...

"Unfortunately, this callous criminal policy is not being challenged by the international community which keeps issuing platitudinous remarks...It is necessary to once again mobilize the peoples of the world to rise up and demonstrate loudly in order to exert pressure on their respective governments...Gaza has become the ultimate test of humanity's moral commitment.."

consider what is at stake while we dither they die - the paramount consideration should NOT be the political interests of the NDP

Sun, 2010-02-28 04:18

#107

Fidel

They're dying in the Middle East. And they're dying in the Congo and Afghanistan and Haiti and El Salvador and Guatemala, India and Pakistan, Bangladesh, Philippines, Iraq, Yemen, Angola, Colombia and so on and so on. We're not going to stop it by foisting blame for Israeli apartheid on third political parties in Toronto or the effective opposition in Ottawa. It's like going nowhere fast.

I think leftists should be concerned about the larger issues of war and war crimes in general, and which of Canada's largest trade partner is making moves toward world wide conflict and possibly another terrible world war? Why is Israel still a frontline state? What else is going on with NATO in the Middle East and Central Asia and Africa? Why does NATO still exist and expanding into Eastern Europe and encircling Russia and China? Which one or two leading fascist nations are benefiting the most from warfiteering and aggression around the world? How many countries did the Nazis march into before democratic countries finally stepped in to defend the world from fascist aggression? Where is the left on today's wars of naked aggression? Why do the USSA and Brits and 45-plus other NATO allies enjoy so little resistance from the left? We're looking at full spectrum world domination by a few lead NATO countries enforcing an oppressive neoliberal financial regime amounting to so much colonialism in modern times, and the left is obsesssing over one of the tiniest countries in the world in the Middle East? Who's writing this leftwing script?

Sun, 2010-02-28 04:35

#108

NDPP

"Effective opposition"??!! You crack me up. Anyway you've got their ring through your nose and will follow them over whatever cliff they may decide to lead you to. Their pattern of treachery and constant sellouts is well documented and an old story. A fixed game and one they invariably play badly. But for those who still believe - harsh correction should be administered. It's the only language politicians sometimes understand. I'll certainly be kicking my mpp's ass over this - maybe literally. After all there are real flesh and blood freedom fighting Palestinian people giving everything just to survive - the ndp varmints shouldn't be allowed to defile their cause with no consequences - that's why they keep selling out over and over again. Disgusting.

But then - as you suggest in another context - focus on the Organ grinder not his monkey.

This is slow work - enough.

Sun, 2010-02-28 04:50

#109

RevolutionPlease RevolutionPlease's picture

remind wrote:

Again I go to the point of how out to lunch the majority of voters are in Ontario....

Smarten up.

Sun, 2010-02-28 08:29

#110

Skinny Dipper

As I mentioned before, if the ONDP wants to support IAW or had opposed Shurman's bill, then it could do so. The provincial party would be putting a lot of resources into this issue.

I think it would be better for the federal NDP to take up the challenge of seeking some balanced solution in the Middle East. The NDP doesn't need to support IAW; it doesn't need to oppose it either. The federal party can oppose any Conservative motion that doesn't consider the balance of both sides in the issue.

Finally, I do encourage citizens who support IAW to become actively involved. When I look at the recent anti-prorogation rallies, these were led by average citizens--not by the political parties.

Sun, 2010-02-28 08:38

#111

Maysie

RevolutionPlease, post # 108 is out of line. Don't do it.

Closing for length.

Pages

Topic locked