How have you dealt with the spectre or reality of sexual harassment at work?

40 posts / 0 new
Last post
Yiwah
How have you dealt with the spectre or reality of sexual harassment at work?

I was having a discussion with a friend the other day, in the context of the extreme heat we're experiencing right now.  We were annoyed that despite this heat, we didn't feel comfortable going to work in anything that might be too 'revealing' even though that means suffering in a conservative suit. 

Yes, there are ways you can grieve sexual harrasment after the fact, and we all know it shouldn't happen in the first place...but it does, and most women I know are very aware of the ways in which we are judged depending on how we dress or how 'friendly' we are at work.  Anyone who has experienced the less than satisfying process of making a sexual harrasment complaint is probably unlikely to want a repeat, but it is nonethless infuriating that you have to find ways to 'avoid' having it become an issue. 

How have you dealt with this?  Do you find yourself moderating your behaviour at work in ways that you don't agree with ideologically?  How has the context altered your approach (ie, unionised versus non, large company versus small, etc)?

milo204

depends what kind of harassment it is.  I've never had someone try and touch me inappropriately or anything, but as far as people "hitting" on me, i'll just be straight with them and say i'm not interested and it usually does the trick.  i'm generally a very friendly person and sometimes it's misinterpreted as me being interested romantically with someone, but that is going to happen, and with clear communication it can be stopped before it gets too weird.

depends n the situation of course...is it your boss who is doing it?  is it a small 10 person work environment or is it a 300-1000 person workforce that rarely comes in contact with one another?

that being said, if you usually wear a suit to work i'm assuming there's a strict dress code, so anything "casual" you'd be wearing would not be revealing at all and if people are judging you still you have reason to complain!  it's not like your showing up in booty shorts and a halter top.

 

Yiwah

Okay so a bit of background...,my 'professional' jobs have all had some sort of dress code, but with flexibility.  When I was a teacher, the dress code was fairly casual, but it really ran the gamut...from some teachers in sweat pants to others in suits.  That was the first time I became aware of sexual harassment in the workplace...up until then I'd simply weathered it as a facet of life.  The problem was one administrator, who made inappropriate comments about female employees and who (it later turned out) had a history of such harrassment.  It was limited to comments, and then angry rants when the woman reacted poorly to the comments.  It became such an issue that a number of us went to our union and attempted to file a complaint.  I say attempted, because we were poorly represented by the union (yet another reason I chose to go into law), and some of us were given the wrong information about our rights (ie...could we be fired if we complained?  Well, maybe...)

That was fairly extreme, many details omitted.  It was a really horrible experience, though it was mitigated by the fact that there were a few of us going through it together.

So after that, I became more aware of the assumptions being made about female employees and it really bothered me.  Most women I worked with either didn't see it, or when they did they just joked it off.  However, in conversations with female colleagues, it became clear that many working women ARE aware of the potential for harassment and have different strategies for deflecting it.  When I've discussed this with female colleagues IN FRONT of 'safe' male colleagues, the male colleagues have been horrified.  They couldn't believe that this was such a live issue that we actually had strategies to deal with it. 

It's certainly more of a tricky situation when the person you're worried about is your employer, versus a colleague.  I think the way you have to deal with that situation (employer/employee) is different as well.  You can try to find ways to avoid it becoming a problem, but if it DOES become a problem then there are other issues, such as...is there a formal complaint policy?  Some way to protect you from losing your job and being blacklisted if you do complain? 

So in general, I'm interested in the different strategies women have used, depending on their circumstances.  I work in an un-unionised environment with few colleagues and one boss.  That definitely changes my approach, and I dress much more conservatively than I normally would, and I try to act less 'friendly' than I really am.  Ideologically this enrages me, that this is even an issue I have to worry about, but my pragmatic side says 'deal with it'.

 

Ripple

Well, it's not sexual harassment, but I once had a colleague file a complaint because I wore a button on my coat that read: "I support the right of return for Palestinians".  

Yiwah

Ripple wrote:

Well, it's not sexual harassment, but I once had a colleague file a complaint because I wore a button on my coat that read: "I support the right of return for Palestinians".  

How was that justified?  Where did it go?

Ripple

 

I will start by saying, I'm not unaware of the other threads (although I haven't read them yet today).  I'm pretty sure I've entered into this thread in good faith.  It may have bearing on the meta discussion, but I don't know- that's not my thing.  I've always liked the contents of the box. 

We shared an office and when I hung my coat up my office mate could see the button.  She didn't discuus it with me, but took it to HR.  She was "shocked," "offended" and "surprised that I was anti-semetic". I had always seemed reasonable to her before. (We had many political discussions before, but about safe topics, I guess.) She felt "threatened" - perhaps I wasn't aware that what I meant by my button was that I was "calling for the Jews to be thrown into the sea."

 I work in a non-unionized workplace. I had just started at my job - which I needed, having just quit my previous job over a political issue. My boss mediated a discussion between my colleague and me. It was sort of productive. I was also able to present my views to all of the people my colleague had spoken to about it.  I continued (and continue) to discuss this and other issues with the people I work with, and leave the occasional article for people to read in the kitchen. I found support in surprising places. But, I took the button off. This was 6 or 7 years ago, and every now and then I wear the button to prove some sort of point. I wish I would have done things differenytl.

And I see now that this is in the feminism foirum (was it always?), so this is definitely thread drift.  sorry.

Machjo

Yiwah wrote:

I was having a discussion with a friend the other day, in the context of the extreme heat we're experiencing right now.  We were annoyed that despite this heat, we didn't feel comfortable going to work in anything that might be too 'revealing' even though that means suffering in a conservative suit. 

Yes, there are ways you can grieve sexual harrasment after the fact, and we all know it shouldn't happen in the first place...but it does, and most women I know are very aware of the ways in which we are judged depending on how we dress or how 'friendly' we are at work.  Anyone who has experienced the less than satisfying process of making a sexual harrasment complaint is probably unlikely to want a repeat, but it is nonethless infuriating that you have to find ways to 'avoid' having it become an issue. 

How have you dealt with this?  Do you find yourself moderating your behaviour at work in ways that you don't agree with ideologically?  How has the context altered your approach (ie, unionised versus non, large company versus small, etc)?

 

In none of the workplaces I've ever worked at have I ever been a victim or instigator or witness of sexual harassment. In fact, I've never even heard of any case of it in my workplace.

With that in mind, If I worked in a smutty workplace, why would I want to stay there when probably 99% of people do not engage in it.

RevolutionPlease RevolutionPlease's picture

Usually, it's not "smutty", it's covert and it goes on all around you.  Open your eyes.  99% is a Gretzky fallacy.  I should wiki that.  :)

 

eta: I heard stargazer's call in the religion thread.

Machjo

RevolutionPlease wrote:

Usually, it's not "smutty", it's covert and it goes on all around you.  Open your eyes.  99% is a Gretzky fallacy.  I should wiki that.  :)

 

eta: I heard stargazer's call in the religion thread.

 

Then I've been very lucky in all my career so far. Unless of course the instigators in my workplace are cautious about others like myself not being there, and the victims not speaking out?

RevolutionPlease RevolutionPlease's picture

Perhaps, eh?  You ever read stuff here?

milo204

yeah yiwah i can see what you mean...that kind of thing just isn't cool.  how some people can act like that, making rude comments and expecting everyone to just go along really pisses me off.  

I remember one time at work, the UPS delivery guy, who happens to be Ojibway, was leaving and this guy got out of the elevator, who i didn't know, and said some racist comment, i can't remember what it was but my reaction was like "dude, that is totally racist!  why would you say something like that to someone you don't even know!" and he was just stunned like no one had ever called him on it before and he just walked away flabbergasted..or mad at me for calling him a racist...

however in my case, i'm self employed so i didn't have to worry about getting fired.  Much trickier in a small workplace.  The only thing i can think of is to get someone you do respect to confront the person...you know like a "i overheard that comment you made about so and so.  You know that kind of thing can really hurt someone, and besides it's totally unprofessional to do that at work of all places, cool it down will ya?"

other than that, how much do you like that job if that kind thing happens there?  Is the money worth it?  or would you be happier working someplace else or for yourself?

 

RevolutionPlease RevolutionPlease's picture

We do have to be careful about comments.  Please censure me if necessary mods but words can be corrected much easier than actions.  Is there a lot of problems with words about sexual harassment too? 

 

Realizing now that obviously there must be, thought it was thread drift at first.

 

I'll just repeat Machjo must work alone if he's never seen sexual harassment on the job. 

RevolutionPlease RevolutionPlease's picture

See how fucked up us guys can be on this issue?

Yiwah

I'll reiterate my anecdote, that most of the males I have spoken to on this issue are completely unaware that it even IS an issue for women in the workplace. So while I don't want to discount the opinions of men here, I also don't think we need to engage in 'well I've never seen it' conversations.

 

Yiwah

As for my particular situation right now, it's not that anything HAS happened.  It's just that certain things made me feel that it COULD happen if I am not extremely careful to be very clear where the lines are.

My point in brining this up is that I find it extremely sad this is still a present reality for working women.

Maysie Maysie's picture

Yiwah, thanks for starting this thread.

"My point in brining this up is that I find it extremely sad this is still a present reality for working women."

Me too. Very much.

I don't have much to add, given that I've worked in either badly paid sectors (which were female-dominated including lower and middle management) or the women's service sector for the majority of my working life. But not everyone can do that, and now I work for myself.

With my mod hat on I would like to reiterate this point by Yiwah, to any male contributors to this thread: "I also don't think we need to engage in 'well I've never seen it' conversations."

writer writer's picture

Yiwah, thanks for starting this. I'm actively reading. I would post, too, but I don't know where to begin. Suffice to say I've experienced it, in many forms. With no existing structure to turn to for relief, and no written policy to guide me as to acceptable behaviour in the workplace. My worst experiences were in small "progressive" environments. I was in my 20s during the worst of Robert Bly's men's movement. Not good timing.

Yiwah

That's the thing, writer...what is 'acceptable behaviour' in the workplace?  There is the ideal, and there is the reality, and there is absolutely a gender division.  I'm keeping this focused on sexism, because I have also experienced extreme racism in the workplace, but that came from both women and men, though it was disproportionately directed towards WOMEN of colour so that aspect is certainly there.

How do you deal, for example, with women who denigrate other women for not being okay with certain sexist behaviours in the workplace?  Is it alright to get upset on someone's behalf?  I have two examples.  In the first case, a woman I worked with made a complaint about jokes a male colleague was telling.  Office gossip had her being called everything from a lesbian to a sex-starved old biddy.  These were the women talking.  How do you deal with that?  In the second case, the administrative staff, all women in their 50s, were routinely referred to as 'the girls'.  "Go tell the girls to deal with it."  They seemed to find it endearing...should someone be getting upset when it clearly doesn't bother them?

 

al-Qa'bong

I once had a job fixing the laminate (a bad original glueing job) on a bunch of desks and cabinets in an area staffed with females only.  At one point, while I was crawling around underneath a desk, the supervisor walked into the room and said, "That's what I like to see, a man on his knees under my desk."

I suppose I should have complained, but I didn't do anything.

 

Yiwah

I don't want to dismiss your experience, but I do not believe it is the case that men face anything like the sort of pervasive sexual harassment that women do in the workplace.  If it's possible, I'd like to keep the topic focused on how women deal with this issue.

milo204

Although yiwah, it might be connected.  Perhaps now, some women feel obligated to or enjoy being racist and sexist to the extreme at work, like your example of the women degrading other women at work, or the man on his knees remark.  I have for sure witnessed a few examples of women saying things that if a man said would make my skin crawl.  It could be an attempt to avoid being ostracized for not going along with the general high school  boys club atmosphere in most workplaces?

 

 

 

Yiwah

My working situation is limited to one employer, and one colleague at the moment...the employer is the owner, and there is no 'they'. 

I've worked in a few 'small business' situations like this, and I find they can be some of the most difficult to deal with, because you tend to be there because you're economically vulnerable as it is.

I'm very confident that I can deal with anything if a problem does arise.  I've learned that much over the years.  But re-entering the workforce was a reminder that this sort of thing is a constant background issue, and it brought me a down a little.  Especially since this is a self-styled progressive workplace.

milo204

c'mon we all know women can be mean too, whether it's racism, sexism or whatever.  

I was just responding to Yiwah's comment : "How do you deal, for example, with women who denigrate other women for not being okay with certain sexist behaviours in the workplace? "

Stargazer

Milos, again...no...please.

 

Seems my contribution to this thread is really not the purpose of this thread. Removed now. carry on with discussing this issue in possibilities and I'm sorry I thought this was a thread for what to do. Not how women should dress down, not be themselves etc.

Stargazer

(deleted)

 

 

Yiwah

I wish you hadn't deleted, Stargazer.  I think your suggestions were excellent.  Just because they don't apply to my particular situation doesn't mean they aren't excellent steps to take when they can be followed through on.  This IS a thread for what to do.  Either in situations where there is some formal complaint process (which is still not guaranteed to protect you from retaliation), or situations where there is no formal complaint process.  Which I suppose can be further divided up into workplaces where something like what you posted could be implemented, and what to do when the workplace is simply so small that there is no possibility of external oversight or avoidance of upper management.

 

milo204

and again no explanation.  It leaves me thinking you have no problem with racism/sexism unless it's the kind that directly affects you personally.  I'd like if you could clarify why you are so aghast at my posts, i just want to know where you're coming from or what you mean.

 

remind remind's picture

milo204 wrote:

and again no explanation.  It leaves me thinking you have no problem with racism/sexism unless it's the kind that directly affects you personally.  I'd like if you could clarify why you are so aghast at my posts, i just want to know where you're coming from or what you mean.

 

Did you ever realize we fight our own individual battles?

writer writer's picture

milo204, there are resources out there. If you are serious about wanting to see the world from an informed feminist perspective, please do your own work. At this point, you are coming across as hostile, arrogant, ignorant and coercive – whether you intend to or not – and you are derailing an important discussion.

Yiwah

Milo, let me say this... sexual harassment is not okay, no matter who does it.  And while it does happen to men, it in no way compares to the pervasive danger that women face in so many aspects of life, at work or not.  I think the message here is, please let us discuss the larger problem without getting sidetracked by something that is not an ingrained aspect of the current socio-political system.

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

Hi milo204, you are disrupting the discussions in the  feminism forum right now, both in this thread and the "Don't rape" thread. Furthermore, demanding that babble's feminists explain feminsm to you while they are trying to have a conversation is a bit rich. I'm going to ask that you stay out of the feminism forum for the time being. I'd be happy to help you clear some things up via PM if you like. Sometimes we men just have to check our egos at the door to the feminism forum. Actually, it's best to do it most of the time. It's certainly how I've done a lot of my learning and growing when it comes to feminism, among other things.

milo204

"hostile, arrogant, ignorant and coercive"?  ummm..did you actually read any of my posts?  Thats quite obviously not my intention.  Stargazer told me to butt out of the dialogue with no explanation, for responding to the question posed by Yiwah of why women can be racist and mean towards each other at work.  next thing everyone is attacking me.  

Think i'll switch to a post where we can have a respectful dialogue, minus the riot police.

Timebandit Timebandit's picture

I've dealt with sexual harrassment in the workplace in a few instances. 

The garden-variety commenting in the guise of joking - because if you object to joking, you're just being bitchy, right? - is one that I encountered the most.  I learned to turn it around, to embarrass the commenter, an the louder the better.  When they protest, you can also say you're joking and ask them why they don't have a sense of humour.  It's fairly effective on equals and middle managers.  I know that not all women are up for this, but I'm mouthy and combative by nature and it has worked for me.  By the end of my five years in civil service, the little men (it takes a small mind to be a harrasser) were terrified of me.

I was harrassed by a manager once, took it to HR and it was dealt with to my satisfaction. 

My theory is that it can't be dealt with passively.  I don't mean you have to be aggressive, but most of the time if you call them on it assertively, they stop.  You've shown yourself not to be an easy enough target.  That said, though, anybody puts their hands on me, they get an elbow to the nose.

writer writer's picture

Dear darling feminist babblers who've lived it: this one is for all of you. You know who you are.

Girl quits her job on dry erase board, emails entire office (33 Photos)

"Being your assistant's been a special hell" - text on the dryboard used to quit with.

bagkitty bagkitty's picture

Writer: thanks for that, it was wonderful. The only way of improving it would have been if her messages had been bidding "spencer" farewell when they tossed his ass out on the street.

oldgoat

For some reason thechive site is making my computer go squirrily.

Slumberjack

I'm tired as well of being treated like a piece of meat at work.  I mean for god sakes I'm not the cuddle boy every time the building AC is set to shiver.

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

What a couple of dream get-out-of-work-free stories today. Love it!

Catchfire Catchfire's picture

Ack. Killjoy alert: Gawker says it's a hoax...

ElizaQ ElizaQ's picture

 I just came across this posted on my facebook wall.  Was thinking of posting it but figured it may be a hoax because of the site it was first posted on.  It loses some of it's oomph if it's not real but I still think it's funny,  a humorous comment on sexism and harassment in a work environment and nice little piece on fighting back in a creative way.  I could very much see something like this happening.  Plus I guess it's a bit of cathartic humor.  Made me think of a couple of bosses that I've had, that have been the same sort of sexist ass and how I wish when I had quit because of it I had done something similar.   :) 

My worst experience with harassing which involved actual touching with the comments, things like "Oooo you shaved your legs today...how nice' while touching my leg was in a job that had no recourse.  Sole proprietorship, guy was owner/boss with just two other employees besides myself.  So the option of reporting to HR or his boss wasn't there.    I talked with the other two women and not surprisingly they had experienced similar things. With one women it was actually worse.   We talked about what to do and figured there wasn't a whole lot that would lead to changing or make our jobs better so we decided to go the 'you make our lives miserable, here's a taste back route.'  We all quit on the same day, cited the same reasons (so at least he knew even if he didn't get it)  and left him high and dry on a major catering contract that was occuring that day.    Tough luck I guess.  Yes I felt so guilty that you lost several thousand dollars and got a black mark on your professional rep.  Oh and it's just too bad that when we all went out to look for other jobs we were truthful in why we had quit our last jobs and that since it was a small town word got around.   I made sure everyone knew about it including the person in the company that had organized the event he was supposed to be catering for the day why we quit because I happened to know her from another social group.   I apologized for causing her some work grief that day but you know what she wasn't mad and understood.   Bit of female solidarity at play there because it's not like she hadn't experienced this type of creepy asshole in her working career either.