If America were a game of Monopoly

15 posts / 0 new
Last post
Maysie Maysie's picture
If America were a game of Monopoly

Quote:

If America were a game of Monopoly the rules would be a bit different. The following example considers race only to keep it simple. Adding class would be interesting too, but for now I leave that as an exercise for the reader.

Rules:

1. There are four players: one white, one red, one black and one yellow.

2. The white player is the banker.

3. Starting amounts: Before play begins give each player the following amounts to start with:

  • $1500 white
  • $1085 yellow
  • $105 black
  • $75 red

(Based on median household net worth in 2000.)

4. When passing Go: Each player will get the following amounts when passing Go:

  • $200 white
  • $170 yellow
  • $140 black
  • $120 red

(Based on median personal income for 2000.)

5. Settling disputes: If there is a dispute between players, it is put to a vote. (See Voting below).

6. Changing rules: If a player asks for a rule change, it is put to a vote (See Voting below).

7. Voting: To win a vote a motion must get at least 5.1 votes. Each player gets the following number of votes:

  • 8.2 white
  • 1.3 black
  • 0.4 yellow
  • 0.1 red

(Based on those reporting one race on the 2000 census.)

8. Speaking: The white player can speak at any time. Other players speak only when spoken to. They are allowed to raise their hand to try to get the attention of the white player to ask a question.

(Based on media ownership.)

Link here to Abagond blog. Funny. Smart. Infuriating.

jrose

Very infuriating, Maysie. But a very smart way of showing readers realities. I almost feel that this would be an infuriating yet eye-opening way to teach youth about race in America. I witnessed a level of racism directed toward a GO Bus operator last night at a level I've never been face to face with before. A truly disturbing experience.

Boom Boom Boom Boom's picture

jrose wrote:

 I witnessed a level of racism directed toward a GO Bus operator last night at a level I've never been face to face with before. A truly disturbing experience.

I hope the GO driver had the right to throw the offender off the bus - and that he or she did so?

jrose

It actually escaladed beyond the apparent altercation on the GO Bus. I wasn't on the bus, but was sitting near this particular couple on the train. From what I overheard, the bus driver had given them directions to the Milton station instead of Hamilton (though they repeatedly said that the bus driver did it intentionally because they were white). This led to the man throwing things, punching the train windows, spewing the most hateful, threatening things I've ever heard. I ended up having to report it to security because it was so violent, hateful, and I feared for everyone in that particular section of the train. It was very scary stuff.

N.Beltov N.Beltov's picture

There's this too, of course ...

Class Struggle is the name of the game ...

and very few people - other than those who have actually read the book - know that the Chapter "The Great Money Trick" from The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists has a lesson on exploitation (as Marxists understand it) using slices of bread. A narrated version is over here.

Maysie Maysie's picture

That's a great game, N.Beltov. 

And I'm on vacation but this thread is in the anti-racism forum and it's only post 5. I'm just sayin.

 

N.Beltov N.Beltov's picture

grumble grumble race grumble class grumble gender grumble grumble ...

Maysie Maysie's picture

Merry whatever to you, N.

Tongue out

N.Beltov N.Beltov's picture

[strike]Bah! Humbug![/strike] ditto.

jrootham

A link that is not in the anti racism forum.

RevolutionPlease RevolutionPlease's picture

If only we could reflect on the OP.  And take the discussion from there.  Meh...

RevolutionPlease RevolutionPlease's picture

eta DP:  I almost meant to say it twice.

KenS

The rest of the post Maysie linked to in the OP:

Quote:

9. Jail:

  • Going to jail: Red and black players go to jail if they land on any corner square except for the Just Visiting Jail square.
  • Getting out of jail: To get out of a jail you must pay $1000 or wait five turns.

10. The red player: Decisions to build or sell houses must be approved by the white player. The white player can build on any of the red player's squares and keep all income for himself.

11. All other rules are the same.

Advice to white players:

If the other players complain that the rules are unfair, say "Get over it!" Point out that the game is fair and democratic: they can always ask for a rule change and put it to a vote. Also point out that the white player does not always win, so if they lose it is their own fault.

Personal observations:

Most white players act as if the same rules and conditions apply to everyone, as if everyone starts with $1500 and gets $200 for passing Go, etc. If anything, they think yellow players get more for passing Go, that black players get more turns and that red players are too noble to care about winning.

KenS

I dont do any 'official' teaching about racism, but I do try to use 'teachable moments' and think about it. [Including all those times I say nothing.]

Intuitively, this game strikes me as not only illuminating, but usefull for discussion.

Except I would leave out all those parenthetical comments about the factual basis for those blatantly stacked rules. Because my interest would be in how people responded to the layout of the rules. [And I took the liberty of lfting them out of the excerpt I just posted.]

KenS

Quote:

3. Starting amounts: Before play begins give each player the following amounts to start with:

  • $1500 white
  • $1085 yellow
  • $105 black
  • $75 red

(Based on median household net worth in 2000.)

4. When passing Go: Each player will get the following amounts when passing Go:

  • $200 white
  • $170 yellow
  • $140 black
  • $120 red

(Based on median personal income for 2000.)

I think its worth noting that this sort of thing is just more graphic / visual for race than it is for class.

And so what?

There is no need to bring in a reminder that there is class too.

[Let alone, in practice, bringing in that class subsumes race.]