Seat Projections (2)

115 posts / 0 new
Last post
George Victor

That's also been my experience. One lives in hope. (and I see Jim Stanford has something to say in a column about why gas prices haven't been an issue. I'm going to take a gander at it).

Sean in Ottawa

I have calculated my first prediction of the campaign-- I may revise tomorrow

Conservative 145

NDP 94

Liberal 48

BQ 21

I hope the NDP is higher becuase this is a difficult result with the NDP and Liberals below the cons and below a majority.It would leave Harper in power I think.

There are so many seats in play though that the possibilities range from an NDP plurality to a Con Majority. Most possible however is the need for all 3 opposition parties to vote together to be more than the Cons.

 

Ciabatta2

Lard Tunderin Jeezus wrote:

I think you ignore the BQ's strength on the ground, and the relative inexperience of the NDP campaigners in Quebec.

Bang on.  The NDP's get out the vote system is second to none.   The problem is you need people and expertise to run it, and need to run it for a whole campaign in order to use it to full advantage.

I think it will be more difficult to turn phone opinions into voters than many realize, particularly if people are stretched so think in Québec that they're taking away from other campaigns/ridings.

peterjcassidy peterjcassidy's picture

moved to election prediction contest

edmundoconnor

.

Wilf Day

Potential NDP gains by the latest Angus Reid (naming a few interesting winners I hadn't heard much of):

Winnipeg North

St. John's South--Mount Pearl

Parkdale--High Park

Saskatoon--Rosetown--Biggar

Davenport

Beaches--East York

Gatineau

Dartmouth--Cole Harbour

York South--Weston  

Halifax West

Hull--Aylmer

Jeanne-Le Ber

Saint-Lambert: Sadia Groguhé

Drummond

Ahuntsic

Alfred-Pellan: environmental Master's student Rosane Doré Lefebvre

Laval

Brossard--La Prairie: lawyer Hoang Mai

Brome--Missisquoi

South Shore--St. Margaret's

Random--Burin--St. George's

Surrey North

Oshawa

Sydney--Victoria: CUPE Rep Kathy Macleod

Westmount--Ville-Marie

Rosemont--La Petite-Patrie

Laurier--Sainte-Marie: former foreign service officer (and sociology Ph.D) Hélène Laverdière (defeating Gilles Duceppe)

Newton--North Delta

Repentigny

Verchères--Les Patriotes

York West

Hochelaga: union activist and anthropologist at Musée d'archéologie de Montréal Marjolaine Boutin-Sweet

Nunavut

Montcalm: former municipal councillor Manon Perreault

Terrebonne--Blainville: McGill NDP co-president Charmaine Borg

Rivière-du-Nord

Sherbrooke

Cape Breton--Canso: Mayor of the Town of Mulgrace Marney Simmons

Longueuil--Pierre-Boucher

Châteauguay--Saint-Constant

Chambly--Borduas

Kings--Hants

Saint-Bruno--Saint-Hubert: Algerian-born doctor Djaouida Sellah

Marc-Aurèle-Fortin

Papineau: CSN rep, and Dominican Republic native, Marcos Tejada

Saint-Hyacinthe--Bagot: Marie-Claude Morin

Argenteuil--Papineau--Mirabel: Mylène Freeman

Notre-Dame-de-Grâce--Lachine: Isabelle Morin

LaSalle--Émard: Hélène LeBlanc

Rivière-des-Mille-Îles: Laurin Liu

Shefford

Esquimalt--Juan de Fuca

Honoré-Mercier: Teacher (and Chilean exile) Paulina Ayala

Beauharnois--Salaberry: Anne Minh Thu Quach

Joliette: Francine Raynault (although that might be a surprise)

Compton--Stanstead

Saint-Jean: Tarik Brahmi

Laval--Les Îles

Bourassa: Julie Demers

Abitibi--Témiscamingue: local nurse Christine Moore

Lac-Saint-Louis

Beauséjour, New Brunswick: former Band Chief Susan Levi-Peters (defeating Dominic LeBlanc) 

Scarborough Southwest

Beauport--Limoilou: Raymond Côté is in the lead

Louis-Hébert: Denis Blanchette is in the lead

Charlesbourg--Haute-Saint-Charles: Anne-Marie Day is in the lead

Portneuf--Jacques-Cartier: Elaine Michaud is in the lead over Andre Arthur

Québec: Annick Papillon is tied for first

Louis-Saint-Laurent : Alexandrine Latendresse is tied for first

Scarborough Centre: Natalie Hundt

Ottawa--Vanier: Trevor Haché

Etobicoke North: ETFO leader, French teacher and anti-racism activist Diana Andrews

Rimouski-Neigette--Témiscouata--Les Basques: potential cabinet member Guy Caron

Pontiac

Vancouver Centre: Karen Shillington

Scarborough--Guildwood: NDP staffer Danielle Ouellette

Vaudreuil-Soulanges

Trois-Rivieres: Robert Aubin

Saint-Maurice--Champlain: Lise St-Denis

Gaspésie--Îles-de-la-Madeleine

Pierrefonds--Dollard: Lysane Blanchette-Lamothe

Abitibi--Baie-James--Nunavik--Eeyou: Romeo Saganash

That would leave nine Bloc MPs. 

That's 118 NDP MPs.

Now, if the Liberals can hold on to 38 or more seats -- a modest target, I hope -- that holds the Conservatives down to 143 or less.

 

An NDP government with Liberal participation, support or tolerance would not need support from the Bloc.

 

This matters because the NDP platform says "If the mandate we receive justifies it, we will work with other federalist parties, through informal or appropriate stable arrangements."

 

Boom Boom Boom Boom's picture

Sean in Ottawa wrote:

I have calculated my first prediction of the campaign-- I may revise tomorrow

Conservative 145

NDP 94

Liberal 48

BQ 21

I hope the NDP is higher becuase this is a difficult result with the NDP and Liberals below the cons and below a majority.It would leave Harper in power I think.

Definitely would leave Harper in power, and if the Opposition voted down the Budget then Harper will force another election - and almost no chance the G-G would ask the Opposition if they could govern. Who besides the Cons would be able to afford another election?  And if another election is forced - can you just imagine the outrage from the population?  Rather than allow this to happen I see the Liberals propping the Cons up for another five years - during which time the Libs do absolutely nothing but try to rebuild their party.

josh

Cons 142

NDP   114

Libs     39

Bloc     12

Ind       1

 

http://www.ridingbyriding.ca/2011/05/01/1055

 

NorthReport

I have no idea where you are getting that from Boom Boom as chances are very high that the GG would ask the 2nd party to try and form a government in the case of an early defeat of the government in a confidence vote, throne speech, etc.

 

Boom Boom wrote:

Definitely would leave Harper in power, and if the Opposition voted down the Budget then Harper will force another election - and almost no chance the G-G would ask the Opposition if they could govern. Who besides the Cons would be able to afford another election?  And if another election is forced - can you just imagine the outrage from the population?  Rather than allow this to happen I see the Liberals propping the Cons up for another five years - during which time the Libs do absolutely nothing but try to rebuild their party.

josh

Cons 147

NDP   107

Liberals  38

Bloc  14

Green   1

Indp    1

 

http://themace.ca/?p=316

 

 

bekayne

josh wrote:

Cons 142

NDP   114

Libs     39

Bloc     12

Ind       1

 

http://www.ridingbyriding.ca/2011/05/01/1055

 

Some real howlers in that one

Pontiac: NDP 46.9, Con 21.6

Jonquire-Alma: Con 40.5, BQ 30.8, NDP 24.3

Laurier-Ste Marie: NDP 55, BQ 28

Outremont: NDP 79.1, Lib 12.0

Westmount: NDP 65.4, Lib 23.3

Vancouver Centre: NDP 30.9, Lib 28.9, Con 24.4, Grn 14.0

Also picks the NDP to win "St. John's North" & the Conservatives to win "North Nova"

bekayne

josh wrote:

Cons 147

NDP   107

Liberals  38

Bloc  14

Green   1

Indp    1

 

http://themace.ca/?p=316

 

 

So the site predicts the Conservatives 8 short of a majority, yet 

my model predicts only a 3.9% chance that the Conservatives will win a majority government

Pirrip

In Saskatchewan, I'd say that 3 are probable: Palliser; Desnethe Missinippi Churchill River; and Saskatoon Rosetown Biggar

I think 3 are "have a shot, but not quite probable": Regina Qu'appelle; Saskatoon Humbolt and, yes, Regina Lumsden. My own riding, Blackstrap is too rural to be in play, I think, but will be closer than the last two. I am going to say 4 NDs elected in Saskatchewan.

MegB

Closed for length.

Pages

Topic locked