Libya 24: Aftermath

There's another part of the story that is being left out in the media and here: how the climate crisis helped make this disaster possible, along with many others in Africa.. 

Since 1900, 23% of Africa's deadliest weather-related events have occurred in the last two years, in other words in less than 2% of this time, as the climate crisis takes an ever greater brutal toll on the continent that had the least to do with creating the climate crisis. "The storm flooding catastrophe in Libya this month is the seventh weather-related disaster to kill at least 500 Africans since 2022". (https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2023/09/the-libya-floods-a-climate-an...)
"The death toll in Libya's coastal city of Derna has soared to 11,300 as search efforts continue following a massive flood fed by the breaching of two dams in heavy rains" (https://www.ctvnews.ca/climate-and-environment/flooding-death-toll-soars...);and at least 10,000 more are missing, with thousands washed out to sea, has had very little coverage, with even less on its link to the climate crisis. It's as if the media and political powers don't want to discuss the implications of this disaster in terms of what it warns about the future impacts of climate change. 

Africa’s deadliest storm in recorded history struck eastern Libya on Sunday and Monday, leaving thousands dead and an already struggling society faced with a mammoth recovery effort. Storm Daniel’s preliminary death toll of 5,300 in Libya as of Wednesday morning surpasses the 1927 floods in Algeria (3,000 killed) as the deadliest storm in Africa since 1900, according to statistics from EM-DAT, the international disaster database. Storm Daniel is also the deadliest storm globally since at least 2013 when Super Typhoon Haiyan killed 7,354 people in the Philippines.

The worst flooding from Storm Daniel was in the port city of Derna (population 90,000), where the failures of the nearby Derna and Abu Mansur dams, both about 50 years old, allowed a wall of water to rip through the heart of town along the Wadi Derna, which is a dry riverbed during much of the year. Carving a path some 100 meters (320 feet) wide, the floodwaters inundated some buildings and caused others to collapse.

Derna was still largely inaccessible on Wednesday, making it difficult to assess the flood’s full impact. The eastern and western parts of Libya, riven by conflict, have operated largely apart from each other for more than a decade, which has complicated the effort to address the catastrophe.

Reuters cited the director of the Wahda Hospital in Derna as reporting 2,300 deaths on Tuesday. According to the Associated Press, a spokesperson for eastern Libya’s interior ministry said later in the day that the death toll in Derna was more than 5,300, and the Libyan Red Crescent Society estimated that at least 10,000 people were missing. Flooding in other parts of northeast Libya led to dozens of other deaths.

The torrents that caused the Libya floods were delivered by Storm Daniel, a medicane (shorthand for Mediterranean tropical-like cyclone) that moved southward into Libya as an unusually well-formed system, with gale-force winds reported northwest of its center. It is already clear that Daniel will be by far the deadliest and costliest medicane ever recorded. 

“Medicane” is a nickname for storms that develop tropical characteristics just off the coast of southern Europe. (There is no official definition of a medicane, although one group is working to develop one.) Medicanes are rarely full-fledged tropical systems with a warm core, since they typically evolve from cold-cored upper-level lows, and the waters of the Mediterranean aren’t extensive or warm enough to sustain a true hurricane. And despite the implication embedded in the name, very few medicanes achieve sustained winds as strong as a Category 1 hurricane. ...

Derna averages only 10.8 inches of rain a year, and more than 90% of that typically falls from cool-season storms in October through April. When the core of Daniel pushed ashore, an immense amount of rain was squeezed out as Daniel’s moisture-laden winds were forced upward by striking the compact Jebel Akhdar plateau (Green Mountains).  ...

The Libya flood disaster was driven in part by the meteorological bad luck of Daniel coming ashore directly atop a compact zone of higher elevation. That’s only part of the story, though.

Human-induced climate change is loading the dice, enhancing the abilityof tropical cyclones and similar storms to produce extreme rain as they draw more water vapor out of oceans into a warming atmosphere.  The Mediterranean Sea has warmed by an average of roughly 2 degrees Celsius (3.6°F) over the past 40 years. This summer the daily average sea surface temperatures of the Mediterranean hit new records for July (topping 28 degrees Celsius or 82°F for the first time in any month) as well as for August, according to the Spanish research center CEAM.

In its recent Sixth Assessment Report, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change noted that the long-term outlook for medicanes is similar to that for tropical cyclones: fewer, but stronger on average. “A growing body of literature consistently found that the frequency of medicanes decreases under warming, while the strongest medicanes become stronger.” Similarly, the IPCC added, “The frequency of Mediterranean wind storms reaching North Africa, including medicanes, is projected to decrease, but their intensities are projected to increase, by the mid-century and beyond.”

As summarized by Dr. Liz Stephens, an associate professor in climate risks and resilience at the University of Reading, “Climate change is thought to be increasing the intensity of the strongest medicanes and we are confident that climate change is supercharging the rainfall associated with such storms.”

Mid-latitude atmospheric blocking in the summertime, which led to Storm Daniel as well as record heat in central Europe and another cold-core low that brought flooding to Spain (see embedded tweet/post below from September 4), may also be influenced by climate change. Possible factors include the disproportionate warming toward the Arctic versus mid-latitude areas, although the possible effects of Arctic warming on “weather weirding” are still being studied and debated....

Climate change doesn’t occur in a social or ecological vacuum. Whether it be the proliferation of non-native grasses in Hawai’i or frenzied development along the Gulf or Atlantic coast, changes in ecosystems, housing patterns, and infrastructure can overlap in ways that exacerbate the risks posed by a changing climate by increasing our vulnerability to extreme weather events.

In the case of Libya, poor maintenance of the Derna-area dams may have further raised the risk of this week’s catastrophe. As reported by Sky News, research published last year by civil engineer Abdelwanees A R Ashoor (Omar al Mukhtar University) warned that the city’s naturally flood-prone landscape could lead to disaster if the local dams were not properly maintained.

Libya’s meteorological agency issued warnings for Daniel three days in advance, and a state of emergency was declared for parts of eastern Libya, according to the World Meteorological Organization. It’s unclear how much of a difference these warnings made, especially given the freakish nature of Storm Daniel and the rapid onset of floodwaters in Derna. ...

Despite recent improved weather forecasting technology and increased disaster awareness and preparation efforts, Africa has suffered an unprecedented number of deadly weather-related disasters over the past two years. The catastrophe in Libya is the seventh weather-related disaster to kill at least 500 Africans since 2022; an astonishing 23% of Africa’s 30 deadliest weather-related disasters since 1900 have occurred in the past two years. This ominous figure could well be a harbinger of the future, as higher vulnerability, a growing population, and more extreme weather events from climate change cause an increase in deadly disasters.

Innovations in climate science have made it possible for scientists to study whether human-caused climate change influenced a specific disaster, a field known as attribution science. A human climate change influence has been found via scientific attribution studies in more than 20 African extreme weather events since 2000, including 13 droughts, seven floods, and two heat waves. As in other parts of the world, drought as well as extreme flood-producing rains in Africa have been associated with climate change in several analyses from the World Weather Attribution group (WWA).

• In a study of the 2020-22 drought in East Africa, WWA concluded: “Climate change has made events like the current drought much stronger and more likely; a conservative estimate is that such droughts have become about 100 times more likely.”
• A May 2022 study from WWA on the South African floods of 2022 that killed 544 people concluded that “greenhouse gas and aerosol emissions are (at least in part) responsible for the observed increases [in rainfall].”
• A separate WWA study for the summer 2022 floods in West Africa that killed 876 people concluded that human-caused climate change made the event “about 80 times more likely and approximately 20% more intense.”
• However, WWA’s June 2023 study for the floods in Rwanda and the Democratic Republic of Congo that killed 603 people concluded, “the scarcity of data does not allow us to draw any conclusions on the role of climate change in the floods.” 

For more on Africa’s vulnerability to weather disasters, including those exacerbated by climate change, see our May post, Five of Africa’s top 30 deadliest weather disasters have occurred since 2022.

https://yaleclimateconnections.org/2023/09/the-libya-floods-a-climate-an...