In recent months, as U.S. hedge funds have imploded south of the border, working Canadians have been told our economy isn't "subprimed."
Sure, the experts say, current problems in global credit markets may mean less cash is available for Canadian companies. It will certainly mean fewer buyers for Canadian exports as U.S. workers face house foreclosures and higher costs for basic necessities.
But be thankful, the experts reassure, you could be someone else. You could be one of the two million Americans who recently lost their homes after shady mortgage brokers sold them on crooked contracts.
You could be one of the 14,000 workers at Bear Sterns, some of who taped $2 to their office windows to symbolize what their employee shares were now worth (down from $68 only days before).
You could be a citizen of several small towns in Norway who, until recently, were unaware that hucksters had exposed them to the subprime market. After her town lost $64 million, one mayor remarked, "Because of this, we can't focus on things that matter, like schools or care for the elderly."
Dear readers: don't believe the hype. Working Canadians have suffered enormously from Bay Street bigwigs, but most aren't aware of it. Union pension funds will take a huge hit after dodgy credit investments (once billed as secure) blew up last summer. To make matters worse, officials are letting the perpetrators bury the victims in secrecy, while pension funds, average Canadians and the public purse finance the funeral costs.
Here's what happened. While many of us enjoyed a deserved break last August, Canada's economy nearly tanked, given a defective investment product called Asset Backed Commercial Paper (ABCP).
Until recently, few experts bothered to ask what ABCP was. But that didn't stop financial advisors, credit unions, bankers and bond raters from giving ABCP top marks as a safe and secure investment.
ABCP are short-term debt notes âe" normally set for terms of 30 or 60 days âe" that banks and non-bank finance houses created by bundling packages of consumer debt together to sell on the stock market. Think of thousands of individual car loans and credit card debts rolled into super funds. That's what ABCP represents, and by last summer it comprised more than 30 per cent of Canada's $360 billion short-term debt market.
Until disaster struck, ABCP kingpins were raking it in. Coventree, a non-bank ABCP provider, grew from a small start-up to a firm managing $16 billion in assets. That all flew apart when large institutional investors, like banks and major pension funds, demanded ABCP sellers disclose their exposure to the U.S. subprime mortgages.
ABCP sellers tried to calm large investors by pointing out their minimal exposure to U.S. subprime mortgages. Coventree, for example, insisted that only four per cent of their funds had links to these dodgy debts.
That didn't satisfy the big investors. One by one, they bolted for the exit doors to sell what they once described to pension plan members and investors as a safe, "securitized" product.
Banks stood behind their ABCP products, and agreed to make investors whole. Non-bank ABCP sellers like Coventree were a different story. They dug in their heels and refused to yield an inch.
By mid-August 2007, the crisis in non-bank ABCP led to a full-blown financial crisis. A small group of bigwigs quickly met in Montreal to establish an industry-brokered deal for non-bank ABCP providers.
On August 16 and 17, the Bank of Canada injected over $720 million in loans to help finance the arrangement. The ABCP industry (and investments in it) was frozen by federal regulators as the details of the deal were hammered out.
On its own, this closed-door process was scandalous. The so-called Montreal Accord of former ABCP boosters happened without any disclosure to investors. No bond rater, banker, or non-bank ABCP seller has faced charges for selling an asset once stamped as safe and secure.
The Montreal Accord won legal approval in the Ontario Superior Court, but not without a fight. The Court required that the deal gain the support of 50 per cent of ABCP investors. Every individual ABCP "noteholder" was entitled to one vote each. That's why finance heavyweight Purdy Crawford travelled to five cities to promote the "Montreal Accord."
Here was Crawford's pitch: 1) your ABCP assets will remain frozen for five to eight years; 2) you'll then exchange them for similar investments (after eating an unspecified amount of losses); 3) you must relinquish your right to legal action; and 4) you have no right to know what the big players negotiated for themselves.
Not surprisingly, that line didn't resonate too well. The Royal Bank estimates ABCP notes have already lost 40 per cent of their value. At first, Crawford was jeered, booed and told to expect legal action unless finance bigwigs offer compensation for 100 per cent of their defective product. In the end, after cutting two deals worth $192 million, Crawford got a majority vote for the Montreal Accord last Friday.
The federal government now thinks the worst is over. According to Finance Minister Jim Flaherty, future swindles like the ABCP mess can be prevented with better disclosure to investors.
This is false. Canada's financial services industry is still largely self-regulated. Any new disclosure requirements will get bogged down in technical jargon that few will understand. We need real regulation of the financial services industry, and enforcement of tougher regulations. We need a national white-collar crime system that can take on finance bigwigs and hold them accountable.
Purdy Crawford's friends shouldn't have gotten court-sanctioned approval to embalm the corpse they are responsible for. They came out of the Bay Street crematorium with the ashes of the ABCP corpse, and convinced small-time mourners to agree on a bail out in exchange for no autopsy or legal liability. Our pension funds and retirement plans shouldn't have covered up these dirty deeds.
It's high time we acknowledged a double standard in our criminal justice system. Our federal government vents often about crime in the streets, but never about crime in the suites. Craig Hannaford and Bill Majher, two former RCMP top investigators, recently told Canadian Business magazine that our white collar crime process "is pretty much non-existent."
Canadians must turn over a new leaf, and demand stronger laws for corporate accountability. Main Street shouldn't suffer for the duplicity of Bay Street.
The dodgy debt littered through the world financial system is an ongoing problem that needs closer government regulation. As an earlier generation recognized during the Great Depression, our economy can't be sabotaged by ruthless speculators and pocket-stuffers.
Meanwhile, we need a real public inquiry into the ABCP swindle. We also need government intervention to recover the ill-gotten gains by invisible billionaires who should be charged credit card interest for all the time they had our money.
Believe it: a fairer economy is possible. Purdy Crawford's buddies can take that to the bank.
Thank you for reading this story…
More people are reading rabble.ca than ever and unlike many news organizations, we have never put up a paywall – at rabble we’ve always believed in making our reporting and analysis free to all, while striving to make it sustainable as well. Media isn’t free to produce. rabble’s total budget is likely less than what big corporate media spend on photocopying (we kid you not!) and we do not have any major foundation, sponsor or angel investor. Our main supporters are people and organizations -- like you. This is why we need your help. You are what keep us sustainable.
rabble.ca has staked its existence on you. We live or die on community support -- your support! We get hundreds of thousands of visitors and we believe in them. We believe in you. We believe people will put in what they can for the greater good. We call that sustainable.
So what is the easy answer for us? Depend on a community of visitors who care passionately about media that amplifies the voices of people struggling for change and justice. It really is that simple. When the people who visit rabble care enough to contribute a bit then it works for everyone.
And so we’re asking you if you could make a donation, right now, to help us carry forward on our mission. Make a donation today.