Democracy Watch's blog

Democracy Watch's picture
Democracy Watch sets out news, opinion, analysis and proposals for change from Democracy Watch, Canada's leading democratic reform, good government and corporate responsibility organization.

More than 15 million adult Canadians want to move toward an elected Head of State -- so let's get the conversation started

| July 5, 2013
More than 15 million adult Canadians want to move toward an elected Head of State -- so let's get the conversation started

A country’s Head of State is not just a hollow symbol of old history. The person represents the people of a country -- their values and common purpose, their sense of unity, their loyalty to each other and their national pride.

A survey of more than 2,000 Canadians conducted by Harris-Decima in February 2013 found that a majority of Canadians (55%) want to change to a democratically chosen Canadian Head of State, while only 34% want to continue with a member of the British royal family.

This means more than 15 million adult Canadians (and likely their kids as well) want to retire the monarchy and change to a democratically chosen Canadian head of state.

A survey of more than 2,000 Canadians by Harris-Decima in May 2012 showed that 65% of adult Canadians want the Governor General and Lieutenant Governors to have clear powers and to be elected.  As well, a survey of more than 2,000 Canadians by Harris-Decima in November-December 2013 showed that 84% of adult Canadians want enforceable rules to restrict key powers of the Prime Minister and provincial premiers.

Clearly Canadians want change.

A country’s Head of State is the person with the ultimate power to make key decisions about how government operates, and to represent the country.  Canada’s Head of State is currently Queen Elizabeth, with the Governor General (and in the provinces the Lieutenant Governors) representing her in Canada.

Because Canada’s Head of State, and the provincial Lieutenant Governors, represent the British royal family and are not democratically chosen, they have no legitimacy to stop the Prime Minister or provincial premiers from abusing their powers (as many of them have in recent years). In fact, the Governor General and the Lieutenant Governors are chosen by the Prime Minister and premiers.

Only 16 of the 54 countries in the Commonwealth association of countries still have the British Royal family as their Head of State. The 33 countries that have retired the British monarchy are still members of the Commonwealth, and still have their historical ties to Britain -- but they have all grown up and are fully independent now -- standing on their own two feet with all their own government institutions.

Limiting who can be Canada’s Head of State to the children of one family in a foreign country is unfair, and undemocratic. Canada should not have an aristocracy -- we are a democracy!

Having a member of the British Royal family as Canada’s head of state is also divisive.  Canada is not British only -- it is a collective of most of the races and ethnicities in the world united by a desire for freedom, democracy, peace, fairness and opportunity.

We will never have national unity and a true sense of belonging for all of Canada’s peoples, or be a fully democratic country, as long as our Head of State is directly associated with, and restricted to, royal heirs of a foreign country who come from only one of Canada’s minorities and one of our multitude of religions.

Canada’s Head of State needs to be modernized -- we need a Canadian selected democratically to represent all Canadians, and clearly empowered to ensure democratic government, as a majority of Canadians want.

embedded_video

Comments

"A country’s Head of State is not just a hollow symbol of old history. The person represents the people of a country -- their values and common purpose, their sense of unity, their loyalty to each other and their national pride."

THANK YOU!  I'm going to use this quote every time I need to articulate why it would be horrible to ditch the monarchy in favour of an elected head of state.  No citizen of any nation should have to deal with a power-hungry politician like Stephen Harper or George Bush as their head of state.  

The three highest levels of power in a democracy are the constitution (the seat of legal power in a nation - interpreted by a supreme court), the head of state (the seat of symbolic power in a nation), and the head of government (the seat of governing power in a nation). It is best that these three authorities remain wholly seperate from each other.  

As well, a survey of more than 2,000 Canadians by Harris-Decima in November-December 2013 showed that 84% of adult Canadians want enforceable rules to restrict key powers of the Prime Minister and provincial premiers.

Yes, but those kind of vague softball questions are kinda like rorschach tests. Everyone reads what they want into the phrase "restrict powers". A right-winger probably doesn't have a problem with Harper proroguing parliament, and neither will any presidential candidate he's likely to vote for.

Limiting who can be Canada’s Head of State to the children of one family in a foreign country is unfair, and undemocratic. Canada should not have an aristocracy -- we are a democracy!

It's aristocratic in the same way that it's democratic for American court prosecutions to be carried out by "the people"(as in "the people vs. so and so"). We are no more governed by the British aristocracy that American attorneys are governed by the opinions of every American citizen.

 

FrinedlyBear wrote:

"The GG is a waste of tax payer dollars, but has virtually no effect on government."

And unless we move to an American/French style "powerful" presidency(which I don't think Canadians would take to very well), any elected head-of-state is going to be just as much a figurehead as the British monarch.

Basically, republicanism amounts to a lot of money and paperwork spent changing the way we choose our figureheads. If Democracy Watch wants to make this an issue, that's their call. But I think the whole thing is just gonna end up going nowhere because, despite what people say in opinion polls, most Canadians really don't care all that much, and the republicans are gonna have a tough time convincing them that they should.  

First get our electoral system democratized by eliminating the current "first past the post" system & at the same time institute an elected senate.

Also institute a recall system, be it a MP or PM.

The current system is a sham & easily manipulated by the corporatized media. 

The GG is a waste of tax payer dollars, but has virtually no effect on government.

 

Login or register to post comments