rabble blogs are the personal pages of some of Canada's most insightful progressive activists and commentators. All opinions belong to the writer; however, writers are expected to adhere to our guidelines. We welcome new bloggers -- contact us for details.

Alberta Diary

djclimenhaga's picture
David Climenhaga, author of the Alberta Diary blog, is a journalist, author, journalism teacher, poet and trade union communicator who has worked in senior writing and editing positions with the Toronto Globe and Mail and the Calgary Herald. His 1995 book, A Poke in the Public Eye, explores the relationships among Canadian journalists, public relations people and politicians. He left journalism after the strike at the Calgary Herald in 1999 and 2000 to work for the trade union movement. Alberta Diary focuses on Alberta politics and social issues.

Ian Urquhart and Len Bracko: A Senate voting strategy for progressive Albertans

| April 20, 2012
Alberta Senate nominee candidate Ian Urquhart

Since the Alberta government is committed to hosing away an extra $3 million of our tax dollars on Monday on the ridiculous exercise of a "Senate nominee election," progressive voters deserve the opportunity to express their protest more effectively than by spoiling than their ballots or formally declining them.

It's a pity the more progressive parties didn’t take advantage of this spectacular opportunity for free advertising despite the preference of most of their supporters for a Triple-A Senate -- that is, Abolish, Abolish and Abolish.

The Senate vote, after all, was going ahead anyway, whether or not we approved -- and, as Ralph Waldo Emerson wisely observed, "a foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds."

But they didn't, so we are left with the choice between a meaningless protest or supporting the only candidates in the race who can be considered even close to progressive, University of Alberta Political Science professor Ian Urquhart and St. Albert City Councillor Len Bracko.

Urquhart, who admits to once supporting the Progressive Conservatives in Ottawa and who has been active in the Alberta Wilderness Association, told the Edmonton Journal in March he has become concerned about the Harper Government's "search and destroy" approach to dealing with Canadians who want to protect the environment.

Bracko, who served for a spell in the Alberta Legislature as a Liberal MLA, has a long record of service to the Edmonton-area bedroom community of St. Albert. On a less positive note, he campaigned on a disappointingly conservative platform in the last municipal election and his recent council performance has been less than stellar.

All the rest are associated with either the Progressive Conservative or the Wildrose branches of the Conservative Party, which has been noted here before, are essentially the same in all important regards.

Senate "reform" -- as opposed to Senate abolition, which is what is needed -- has long been a hobbyhorse of the perpetually dissatisfied far right in this part of the country. These people imagine that a U.S.-style upper house in place of the undemocratic and largely symbolic 19th Century relic we now have would be a panacea to their feelings of alienation in a larger federation where the majority of citizens don’t share their antediluvian views. Thus they have demanded for years a "Triple-E Senate," meaning elected, equal and effective.

Accordingly, to score a propaganda point and scoop up a few of the farthest-right votes, Alberta Progressive Conservative governments held faux Senator elections in 1989 and 2004.

The federal Liberals were in power in 2004, and ignored the results of that vote. However, upon coming to power Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper appointed one of the four "Senators in Waiting," a well-off Calgary area farmer named Bert Brown, to the misnamed Red Chamber.

Brown is the fellow who cut the letters EEE into a barley field north of Calgary International Airport, proving that, in Alberta, there's freedom of the press for anyone who owns a field and a threshing machine.  He later went on to renown as the Senate's biggest spenders of taxpayer dollars, which shouldn't surprise anyone who follows Conservative behaviour, as opposed to Conservative rhetoric.

Others, like Link Byfield of the nutty right-wing publishing empire founded by his father, proved too much even for our neo-Con prime minister to stomach. Byfield has given up on his senatorial dreams and is now carrying the standard of the Wildrose Party in the Barrhead-Morinville-Westlock riding northwest of Edmonton.

Whatever, the pressure for a reformed Senate has largely disappeared for two reasons: first, the people who imagined they could never win power without a Triple-E Senate have won power, and, second, the population and influence of the more-conservative West has increased and is likely to continue to grow.

The PM, however, persisted with the idea of a Senate Reform Act -- which was introduced to Parliament last spring -- probably because he sees the Senate as a useful wedge issue and because a Conservative-packed Senate empowered to activism would be a useful brake on progressive policies introduced by some future non-Conservative government.

That act, according to the government’s news release at the time, "provides a voluntary framework for provinces to implement a democratic process that enables voters to select nominees for the Senate. The Prime Minister will be required to consider the names of Senate nominees when making recommendations on appointments to the Senate." (Emphasis added.)

Now, never mind the qualification about recommendations -- it's the PM and his inner circle who decide who will become a Senator. In our system, a recommendation to the Crown is really a command. But note that the act will leave an escape hatch open for the prime minister in the event voters should decide to cast their ballots for the candidate not approved by our neo-Con masters.

Still, it's said here this would not be the worst outcome -- if a progressive candidate were chosen to be rejected by the Ottawa neo-Cons -- because it would prove the prime minister's Senate reform is a fraud and provide the democratic justification to abolish this chamber once and for all.

So why not vote for Urquhart and "pump the ballot" a little in his favour by voting for no one else, as is your right. If you are simply compelled to vote for more than one simply because you can, you could mark your ballot for both Urquhart and Bracko.

If either an environmentalist or a Liberal wins, it’s a safe bet that Harper won't appoint him to the Senate, which will serve the useful purpose of proving once again that our PM is a shifty manipulator.

If by some miracle he is telling the truth and appoints the candidate we choose, at least we'll have one rare progressive voice in the Senate.

It's not much to get for our $3 million, but it’s something.

This post also appears on david Climenhaga's blog, Alberta Diary.

embedded_video

Comments

There is one more progressive Candidate. Elizabeth Johannson for the evergreens (Greens)

http://evergreenparty.ca/candidates.html

 

 

 

Yet the big surge in Corporate owned Government fascism starts here in Alberta on Monday with the current election – we will be used as an example to the rest of Canada.

 

In Alberta, the biggest single Conservative-Industrial backed endeavor has been the Oil Sands extraction at Fort McMurray. If you check out Google Earth and follow the water shed from McMurray (confluence of the Athabasca and Clear Water Rivers) north, it flows into Lake Athabasca directly across from the outflow into the Slave River. The Slave continues north through Wood Buffalo National Park and on to Great Slave Lake. From Great Slave, the water flows into the mighty Mackenzie River and north again to the Arctic Ocean - Mississippi sized river boats use to ply all these waters. What will the Wildrose Conservatives and the PC's do with complete power as leadership and opposition when they both believe in totally freeing enterprise?

"Find the Cost of Freedom…" Crosby, Stills, Nash and Young

http://youtu.be/ekZEZf14nOU    (a beautiful video)

 

Richard Nixon was a Republican, a Conservative. After apparently rescinding his election promise to end the Vietnam War with the announcement of the intervention in Cambodia on May 1 1970, there was a converse massive escalation. A national Student strike was invoked to protest the announcement and on May 4, nine students were wounded and four killed by gun fire from Ohio State National Guardsmen. Today, here in Alberta, The Wildrose Party are Conservative extremists who along with the Progressive Conservative Party are most likely to win the provincial election in first and second place, forming a Conservative leadership and Conservative opposition. The "big money" is behind them both ...what is known else where as "The Military-Industrial establishment."

 "Ohio…" Crosby, Stills Nash and Young

http://youtu.be/YnOoNM0U6oc

Login or register to post comments