John Bennett's blog

John Bennett's picture
John Bennett is the Executive Director of the Sierra Club of Canada. Sierra Club Canada was established in Canada in 1963 and today has five chapters across the country (BC, Prairie, Ontario, Quebec & Atlantic Canada). Sierra Club Canada also has dozens of local groups across the country in communities from Cape Breton to Vancouver! It also has an amazing youth affiliate -- The Sierra Youth Coalition. Major national campaigns include climate change, nuclear energy, protecting biodiversity and transitioning to a sustainable economy. Sierra Club Canada has earned an excellent reputation within its constituency and the broader public for its thoroughly researched positions and for refusing to compromise on its ideals. Sierra Club Canada believes in the power of people everywhere working together to create a better world for all.

Please permit me: Ontario proposes ending permit process for endangered species

| January 24, 2013
Please permit me: Ontario proposes ending permit process for endangered species

This week we launched a campaign to convince the Ontario government to NOT end permitting for projects that impact provincially recognized endangered species (Note: if you haven't sent a letter yet please do so today). Not that we support giving anyone a permit to harass, harm or kill endangered species, it's a defensive measure -- the province is proposing replacing permits with voluntary rules developers would be expected to follow. They say it's a government cost-cutting measure.

In reality, of course, it is a cost-cutting measure for developers looking to avoid proper studies and delays. Permitting is important because every case is unique and the Ministry of Natural Resources must review each application to harass, harm or kill any endangered species as required under the provincial Endangered Species Act.

Admittedly, the permitting process has largely proven to be a rubber stamping process, but it does enable the province to track the cumulative impact of development on endangered species (and hopefully someday control it under the powers of the provincial act).

The new voluntary system would assume rules are observed and all is fine-and-dandy. It will do for endangered species what gutting enforcement of the Highway Traffic Act would do for human safety. The same arguments put forward (e.g. developers can be expected to voluntarily respect laws and government would save money) could also be applied to drivers and the cost of policing. Unfortunately, the ensuing mayhem would be the same.

The point being is this: cuts to endangered species protection cost everyone. It will deprive us of biodiversity and precious natural capital that comes with it. It's dumb, short sighted and cruel.

For the most part we are talking about making it easier to throw-up more condos and subdivisions when we know the urban sprawl model is expensive and unsustainable and that there are better ways to house and employ us.

With more than 60 species in Ontario on the brink of extinction, and every single municipality desperately trying to finance the cost of services and aging infrastructure, isn't it time politicians stopped pandering to the developers who fund their campaigns and drive up the cost of government? Isn't it time to end the days of sweetheart deals for developers?

There is literally a mountain of evidence to support recognizing our natural capital when making economic decisions. Rather than making it easier for developers to ignore our natural capital we need regulations designed to make sure they make good decisions (not just hope they'll do so voluntarily).

The Ontario government has chosen to go backwards instead of forwards. Let's hope public opinion will convince them to reverse course.

embedded_video

Comments

I really like your way to describe the mention post as its nice by me on the other hand I get alot requirements realted to my need and I am also here for you to give you an advice all about clothes for men that how they make thir selves good as look so for it get an ideas all about these and make your self nice as look summer suits for men than other.Thanks for sharing

Login or register to post comments