rabble blogs are the personal pages of some of Canada's most insightful progressive activists and commentators. All opinions belong to the writer; however, writers are expected to adhere to our guidelines. We welcome new bloggers -- contact us for details.

Hill Dispatches

karl nerenberg's picture
Karl Nerenberg has been reporting on federal politics from Parliament Hill for rabble.ca since September, 2011. In his long career, he has won numerous awards as a broadcaster and documentary filmmaker.

Who gets the $$ for food in the North -- big business or hungry people?

| November 25, 2014
Photo: flickr/Christopher Cotrell

Do you want to see more independent reporting from Parliament? Please chip in now to keep rabble.ca on the Hill!

Anyone who has ever spent any time in Canada's North knows that basic, healthy food is excruciatingly expensive, while what is available on store shelves is severely limited.

Historically, the Inuit, Dene, Cree, Innu and other peoples of the North relied on the land. When things were good, they could fashion a decent, balanced diet for themselves.

They had high-quality, lean meat from caribou, moose, arctic hare, ptarmigan, beaver and muskrat and, for coastal peoples, from sea mammals such as whales and seals.

They had fish from lakes and rivers: lake trout, pickerel (also called walleye), northern pike, whitefish, inconnu (a giant cousin of the whitefish found only in the extreme Northwest), ling cod (or "loche"), speckled and dolly varden trout, and migrating salmon and arctic char.

And, believe it or not, the North was home to a surprising bounty of fruits and even some vegetables. Low-bush cranberries grow in great profusion over much of the North, and are high in vitamin C, as are Saskatoon berries, blueberries and rose hips. Many northern peoples also harvested Labrador tea and edible roots that resemble radishes or Jerusalem artichokes.

Aboriginal traditional cuisine also devised ingenious means of preserving foods for the cold winters and long periods when very little was available. For example, many of the peoples of the North smoked and dried fish and caribou. They would eat the latter together with a kind of "grease" produced by boiling down the animals' bones.

Liver is high in vitamin D and iron, and northerners made abundant us of fish livers. The Gwich'in of the northern Yukon and Northwest Territories mixed ling-cod liver with cranberries and then froze the mixture. They would jokingly call the result "ice cream," but it was a highly nutritious ice cream, containing iron and vitamins D, A and C, as well as high-quality protein.

For a long time after northern Aboriginal peoples started to trade with Europeans, their diet did not change much. The main new elements the strangers from far away brought were the white man's triumvirate of tea, sugar and flour. For the rest, northern people relied on the land.

Food Mail helped make eating a bit more affordable in the North

Even now, the Aboriginal peoples of the North still rely to some extent in what they call "country foods." They continue to hunt, fish and harvest wild plants.

Today, however, a good proportion of the people in Northern communities spend most of their time "in town," working (at service or government jobs, for instance) or attending school, and there is not enough country food to sustain a young and growing population. Depending on the community, northerners rely to a greater extent than ever before on what they can purchase at "the store."

The cost of supplying food, especially fresh food, to remote and isolated Northern communities, by air, is huge. When added to the retail price, that cost makes staples such as milk and eggs -- not to mention northern "luxuries" such as tomatoes -- prohibitively expensive.

For years, northerners would complain that alcoholic beverages provided by provincial or territorial agencies were, in effect, subsidized, so that a bottle of whiskey was the same price in the remote north as in Toronto, while milk was not.

A partial answer to that complaint was Food Mail, a longstanding program whereby Canada Post received a special subsidy to ship nutritious foods directly to people in remote and isolated northern communities.

In 2011, however, the Harper government decided to take the subsidy away from Canada Post and give it, instead, to a few large and highly profitable retail organizations that supply the North.

Subsidies to mammoth businesses with robust bottom lines

The new program is called Nutrition North, and in the year it was set up, 2010, one of those  large retail businesses, the North West Company, had worldwide sales of $1.4 billion and a profit of well over $80 million.

Canada's Auditor General (AG) examined Nutrition North to see, in part, if the federal subsidies are actually getting passed on to the people of the North.

In his fall 2014 report, the AG had to say that he simply could not accurately verify that fact.

People of northern remote communities can definitely attest, however, that food prices remain punishingly high. Some say they would prefer a return to the Food Mail program.

The AG reports that while the Department of Aboriginal and Northern Affairs receives monthly reports on northern food prices, it does not have information on the retailers' profit margins, and so cannot ascertain who is really benefitting from the subsidies, and to what extent.

The government’s excuse for failing to know what the retailers' profit margins are is that such information might be "commercially confidential."

The AG's response to that argument is, in essence: nonsense.

The fall 2014 AG report puts it this way:

"Determining whether the entire amount of the subsidy is being deducted from the selling price of a food item requires an examination of profit margins (both current and over time): the impact of the subsidy may be negated if the profit margin is increased after the full subsidy is applied to the landed cost."

The Northwest Territories (NWT) NDP MP Dennis Bevington points out a couple of other major flaws in the Northern Nutrition program that the AG uncovered.

"The program may be unfair," Bevington says, "because it provides a full subsidy to food going to some communities and only a partial subsidy to other very similar communities. The Auditor General found no basis for this differential treatment."

As well, Bevington points out that the Nutrition North program now gets $60 million per year, the same amount as the government spent on the cancelled Food Mail program four years ago. And, the MP adds, there are heavy administrative costs to the current program: 10 per cent per year.

"Food prices have gone up," Bevington says, "but the program has not kept pace."

Aboriginal and Northern Affairs Minister Bernard Valcourt fights back by pointing to some of the apparent successes of the Nutrition North program.

"The volume of perishable nutritious food shipped to northern communities has increased by approximately 25 percent, and the cost of a food basket for a family of four dropped by approximately $110 a month in the first two years of the program," Valcourt says. "As opposed to the previous Food Mail program, the Nutrition North Canada program is dynamic and is intended to continue improving."

Having said all that, the government still pledges to implement all of the AG's recommendations for fixing the Northern Nutrition program.

Fix everything wrong with Nutrition North, or replace it -- NDP

What the Northwest Territories MP would like to see is that the government improve administration of the program, eliminate its arbitrary and unfair differentiations between similar communities, and make sure none of the subsidy money fattens the coffers of mammoth retailers, who definitely don't need that money in order to afford a balanced diet.

The first two improvements, Bevington believes, should be relatively easy to achieve. He is not so sure about the last one, however, since companies can be slippery when asked to divulge business-related data

The NWT MP says that if it should prove impossible for government officials to get their hands on the retailers’ profit-margin information, then the Nutrition North subsidy program should be replaced.

A while ago, Bevington floated another northern food subsidy idea, which he believed would work better, past then-Aboriginal and Northern Affairs Minister Leona Aglukkaq. The Northwest Territories MP suggested providing subsidies directly to northern families, in the form of "Food Cards" that could only be redeemed for nutritious foods.

Put the money in the people's pockets, Bevington proposed, rather than those of the companies.

The Conservative Minister did not evince the slightest interest.

Photo: flickr/Christopher Cotrell

embedded_video

Comments

We welcome your comments! rabble.ca embraces a pro-human rights, pro-feminist, anti-racist, queer-positive, anti-imperialist and pro-labour stance, and encourages discussions which develop progressive thought. Our full comment policy can be found here. Learn more about Disqus on rabble.ca and your privacy here. Please keep in mind:

Do

  • Tell the truth and avoid rumours.
  • Add context and background.
  • Report typos and logical fallacies.
  • Be respectful.
  • Respect copyright - link to articles.
  • Stay focused. Bring in-depth commentary to our discussion forum, babble.

Don't

  • Use oppressive/offensive language.
  • Libel or defame.
  • Bully or troll.
  • Post spam.
  • Engage trolls. Flag suspect activity instead.