Sam Oosterhoff should be expelled from Ontario Premier Doug Ford's caucus because he opposes key human rights.
Oosterhoff is an elected member of provincial parliament (Niagara West), serves in the Ontario Progressive Conservative government as parliamentary assistant for the minister of education, and is vocally "pro-life." You may have heard about his most recent media scandal -- speaking at an anti-choice event even though one of the organizing groups had compared abortion to the Holocaust.
This is not an isolated occurrence. Oosterhoff has a long record as a far-right fundamentalist Christian who opposes Charter rights for women and gender minorities.
How did he get elected in the first place, and why is he still there? Let's start by reviewing Oosterhoff's troublesome history.
- Nineteen-year-old Oosterhoff won the nomination in the Progressive Conservative riding of Niagara West-Glanbrook because the anti-choice groups Campaign Life Coalition and Right Now subverted the nomination process. He beat out favoured nominee Rick Dykstra, the PC president and a former MP.
- He "disappeared" during the byelection campaign, hardly speaking to anyone, and was tight-lipped with reporters. Political analyst Robert Fisher figured he was told to be quiet because of his extreme social conservative views.
- He did make it known during the campaign that he is "100 per cent pro-life" and is against same-sex marriage. And he opposed the Wynne Liberal government's sex-ed curriculum, preferring to revert to a version that does not cover consent and gender identity.
- After his election, he publicly opposed Bill 28 (the "All Families are Equal Act," which gives protections to LGBTQ2SI+ parents) on the grounds that it disrespects mothers and fathers by using gender-neutral terms.
- In May, he ran away from his constituents and pro-choice protesters, refusing to talk to them or answer questions on his abortion stance, after hosting a community coffee event with constituents in Grimsby.
- In December, he shared a Toronto stage with Premier Doug Ford and religious extremist Charles McVety, who is virulently anti-gay and has attacked same-sex marriage as part of the "militant homosexual agenda."
- His staffers called police on a group of seniors reading books at his Beamsville constituency office in May to protest provincial cuts to library funding.
- He pledged at the annual March for Life rally at Queen's Park in Toronto in May, "to fight to make abortion unthinkable in our lifetime," resulting in an avalanche of outrage.
- After that rally, he told the media: "To quote Dr. Seuss, 'A person's a person no matter how small.'" But before his death in 1991, Dr. Seuss (Theodor Geisel) threatened to sue an anti-abortion group for using that line. His widow said she doesn't like people to "hijack Dr. Seuss characters or material to front their own points of view."
- He was in an October photo-op with all-male members of Ontario Craft Brewers (OCB), which caused public controversy because it raised the question: why was the OCB consorting with an extremist anti-choice homophobe? The OCB and several member groups apologized, with some expressing their support for women's rights and the LGBTQ2SI+ community.
- The pandemic kept Oosterhoff quiet until October, when he was part of a group photo with about 40 people in a banquet hall, none of whom were wearing masks or social distancing. Ford refused to demote him.
- He headlined a March 17 event, "Gen Z: Challenging Abortion in Politics," co-organized by a group, the National Campus Life Network, that compared abortion to the Holocaust.
Allow me to share a few crowd-gathered thoughts about this latest event. It was an echo chamber for anti-choice doctrine. A link to the event recording by Rob Gill titles "An Anti-Choice, Hateful Evening with MPP Sam Oosterhoff." (It requires you to download an app.) Questions were screened and selected beforehand, so a submitted question from pro-choice attendee Katie Dean was not answered. And nobody could unmute their mic.
Another pro-choice attendee complained to the organizers:
"I did not hear anything whatsoever that would want to make me to cross over to your side. Why were not any of the difficult questions asked? Why did it just appear to be a pep talk for the College kids. Shameless."
Ontario MPPs Jill Andrew and Marit Stiles -- NDP women's issues critic and education critic respectively -- released a statement before the event, calling out Oosterhoff for abusing his office to attack a woman's right to choose, and demanding that Ford fire him from his post as parliamentary assistant for education.
Back in 2019, when Oosterhoff made his infamous "unthinkable" pledge (and misappropriated Dr. Seuss), NDP Leader Andrea Horwath condemned his comments, saying: "We are horrified that Doug Ford continues to refuse to denounce his MPP's dangerous, anti-choice and anti-women position."
Yet Ford continues to make excuses for Oosterhoff. He spoke with Oosterhoff privately before the March 17 event but refused to divulge their conversation. Ford did disavow Holocaust analogies but claimed that Oosterhoff did not represent the Ontario PCs or the government at the event. But that gave Oosterhoff permission to attend the event, to which he was invited as keynote speaker only because he's an Ontario MPP.
NDP women's critic Jill Andrew stood up in question period on March 23 to demand why the premier had allowed Oosterhoff to headline an anti-choice event. In response, House Leader Paul Calandra was very "troubled" that Andrew would expect the premier to tell his MPPs what they can and cannot do.
So there's been no apology, and no dismissal of Oosterhoff from his privileged parliamentary position or from caucus. This confirms that Ford and his Progressive Conservative party are happy to coddle MPPs who oppose the human rights of women and gender minorities. Jill Andrew explains why in a Facebook post:
"FACT: Many other PC MPPs have been 'cast out of the belly of the whale!' They've been kicked out of the caucus. But I guess women and people's right to choose isn't important enough of an issue for Sam Oosterhoff to face any consequences from Ford. You see, the Ford government are AFRAID of their social conservative base! It's a whole lot of HATE there (sexism, racism, homophobia etc propping up this conservative caucus.) Disgusting hypocrisy."
Five PC MPPs have been removed from Ford's caucus or from cabinet for bad behaviour -- but none for being sexist, racist, or homophobic. (See Roman Baber, Rod Phillips, Belinda Karahalios, Randy Hillier, and Jim Wilson.) Still, it's likely that if Oosterhoff was doing or saying racist things, he'd be gone by now.
Overt racism is a bridge too far for the PC party. Even homophobia must be kept fairly muted. Yet open misogyny is perfectly acceptable. Oosterhoff can be out, loud, and proud when it comes to declaring that women must be subservient to fetuses.
Oosterhoff should resign from his parliamentary position and from caucus but of course he won't. Ford has shown that Oosterhoff’s brand of misogyny is welcome in the party -- even necessary to keep the base happy.
But wait… who is the "base"? Recall that Oosterhoff's nomination for the 2016 byelection was engineered by anti-choice groups, and his Niagara West riding is a safe Conservative seat.
Do most Oosterhoff voters really agree with his views against abortion and same-sex marriage? Wouldn't they just as easily vote for a more moderate Conservative candidate? After all, their MPP's job is to work constructively with a wide range of constituents and issues -- but people can't even take their picture with Oosterhoff for fear of negative media exposure. He's a liability to the party and to his constituents.
It's time for Doug Ford to add extreme anti-choice views as a "bridge too far" when it comes to MPPs in his caucus. Please, give Sam the ooster!
Joyce Arthur is the founder and executive director of the Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada, a national pro-choice group in Canada.
Image credit: Sam Oosterhoff/Facebook
Editor's note, March 25: A previous version of this column incorrectly credited Katie Dean with recording the event "Gen Z: Challenging Abortion in Politics." The event was in fact recorded by Rob Gill. The article has been corrected.
Thank you for reading this story…
More people are reading rabble.ca than ever and unlike many news organizations, we have never put up a paywall – at rabble we’ve always believed in making our reporting and analysis free to all, while striving to make it sustainable as well. Media isn’t free to produce. rabble’s total budget is likely less than what big corporate media spend on photocopying (we kid you not!) and we do not have any major foundation, sponsor or angel investor. Our main supporters are people and organizations -- like you. This is why we need your help. You are what keep us sustainable.
rabble.ca has staked its existence on you. We live or die on community support -- your support! We get hundreds of thousands of visitors and we believe in them. We believe in you. We believe people will put in what they can for the greater good. We call that sustainable.
So what is the easy answer for us? Depend on a community of visitors who care passionately about media that amplifies the voices of people struggling for change and justice. It really is that simple. When the people who visit rabble care enough to contribute a bit then it works for everyone.
And so we’re asking you if you could make a donation, right now, to help us carry forward on our mission. Make a donation today.